I'm not sure I fully get the "Ross is terrible owner' crowd. I may not agree with every move he makes, but the guy is trying! He is spending money, he has engaged fans, he is concerned about the "Dolphins" brand and he seems geniune in wanting to do the right thing. He may be going through a learning curve.....but the guy is smart and I'm sure he didn't become a success real estate developer repeating the same mistakes over and over again.
Lets give this a chance. I don't know if he will make any changes or not, but I do know he is more familiar with what is going on than any of we are......
Yeah if you must err its better to err on the side of continuity rather than being too rash. We only see a snippet of what goes on in the organization, I would have killed Ireland for the Albert trade but I didn't know Martin was skipping out on training camp or allegedly suicidal, for instance.
LeBatard is right that there is a lot of luck in picking great players and I'm sure a lot of good GMs have been fired simply because they were unlucky, but with Ireland its not just the talent evaluation that he's been average to bad at, its the overall strategy:
-In 2011 we did almost nothing to improve the team after coming off a 7-9 season, standing still is going backwards in the NFL, thats true of every team from SB champs all the way down to 7-9 teams.
-Demanding offset language is dumb, did we have it on Martin's contract? Does anybody give a **** at this point?
-burning bridges with guys like Parcells and even Sparano, you need to be as connected and networked as possible to get in on trade opportunities like the Boldin trade for instance.
-Not extending players until recently. Its the one advantage teams have to keep their young talent from testing the open market, assuming you extend the right guys its win-win for the organization and the player.
-Taking a left tackle with the first overall pick when you need a QB--DUMB. Trading up for Daniel Thomas with Ryan Mallet sitting there and you still need a QB--DUMB
-but the most egregious of all his management mistakes is the way we're building around Tannehill, we were a year behind on getting him weapons in the passing game. We were a year behind on solidifying the offense by insuring we had a good line, good backs and good depth. By looking at our cap situation its obvious he was attempting to peak in year 3 but we needed to and should have peaked in year 2. You never know what the future holds, you can't bank on anything.
Somebody here had a great sig and it most definitely applies for Ireland: YOU CAN'T FIX STUPID!!