Discussion in 'Miami Dolphins Forum' started by Brown42000, Mar 23, 2008.
According to this article he isn't.
this may be one of the stupidest qb lists ive ever read. I dont even feel like i have to justify it with any explination. and i dont undersand it talking about the best punting avg in a season when talking about a qb.
ok the source is buffalo news.. of course they arnt gonna recognize the best pure passing qb of all time... you cannot even put tom brady on that list because he is still playing.. and some other names are just dumb to think of when you cannot even put marino in there... the author of that post should be stoned to death for his ignorance
I DON'T THINK YOU COULD OF WROTE IT MUCH BETTER THAN THAT!!
u have to remember its buffalo
From the Buffalo News....im suprised Jim Kelly or Doug Flutie arent number one and two!
Buffalo should just focus on keeping it's team in Buffalo. LOSERS.
While there are legitimate beefs against calling Marino the best ever, he is EASILY in the top three.
Surprised Jim Kelly isnt on the list..
For the most part, all anyone cares about is super bowl titles, so in the end, dont be surprised when Marino is forgotten about in these kind of conversations. When its all said and done, Manning and Brady are going to surpass Marino in the medias eyes, just because they won super bowls. Now they probably shouldn't, but they will.
All I can say to this is :lol::lol::lol::lol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol::sidelol:
I hate Larry Felser even though from what I hear Otto Graham and Sammy Baugh were out of this world. Still a different game in this era and Marino should be on that list.
He has Brady but says Manning is on deck? What kind of nonsense is that . . . I know Brady has 3 championships . . . but Manning clearly is going to BLOW AWAY all the QB stats. I dunno man.
U throw Marino in there simply because he is the greatest pocket passer of all time.
Unfortunately . . . Dan is not going to be there forever, after a while . . . the lack of a championship is going to bring him down, and little by little more people are possibly going to surpass him in the record books. But we all know how great he was, and with the lack of a defense and running game, he kept Miami competitive for many years . . . and single handly put on what may be considered the GREATEST single game performance in NFL history when he picked apart the 1985 Bears in the Orange Bowl in front of the 1972 Dolphins . . . and kept the Bears from going undefeated.
First off it's buffalonews and not to mention Buffalo should be worrying about them moving their team to Toronto.
Just another example of an idiot making a controversial and moronic list to draw attention to himself.
he's the best passer of all-time
whether he won a ring or not
he's the best PASSER of all-time
and if a Quarterback's position is defined as one who PASSES the ball, he has to be at least in the top 3.
how dare anyone even question him in top 5
But at least we've established there are still plenty of morons in Buffalo. Like they know anything about quarterbacks anyway.
Elway over Manning or Marino is Ludacris
I understand biases from being a Toronto Bills fan, but Marino defined the QB position better than Brady or Elway, hands down.
They probaly have Rob Johnson on that list.
I agree, that list is pretty worthless.
I love Dan as much as anyone.....But, top 7? If you are argueing "pure passer", sure. I'll have him top 5.
Gents....The QB position was played, and, played well for the game style BEFORE 1985!
I think the main deal with this is the argument re; QBs and Super Bowls and that relevence to the HOF argument. See; Fran Tarkington
ETA: All you guys that are giving the Buffalo press a bad time......Elway. That guy was part and parcel with the heartbreak that IS the Bills.. (And Western NY) ..So, what interest do they have in skewing based on divisional stuff?
Actuallu, according to this stupid report, he would be #9 after the on deck manning...
This list is rediculous, of course it had to come out of Buffalo
That tells me everything