FinHeaven Fantasy NFL Keeper Draft | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

FinHeaven Fantasy NFL Keeper Draft

JimToss

Thank You Chad Pennington
Joined
Sep 8, 2008
Messages
1,085
Reaction score
16
Location
Maryland
Hi All,
This thread is a bit of a spin off of an idea I posted in the Dolphins Forums. (http://www.finheaven.com/forums/f2/who-would-be-your-dolphins-keepers-246905.html?posted=1#post1062906514post1062906514)
The post got good response and many wanted to execute this actual idea.
Here's the premise:
Due to impending CBA doom, the NFL has decided to make all players free agents and place them into a draft.
Each team is allowed to protect 3 players to prevent them from going into the pool.
The idea is to include 32 people to take each of the NFL teams. Each person designates 3 players "keepers" who do not go into the pool of FA's.
Once all teams are filled and keepers designated we will follow the order of the 2009 NFL draft to make it easy. I'll make sure every team has a pick and no team has 2 picks.
Think just like a regular fantasy draft, where each round is reversed. Therefore the Steelers get the #32 and #33 pick in the draft.
Remember to draft/keep not based on fantasy points, but based on in real life who would you want to build a team around. Remember to factor in age and positional demand of the players. When you pick a team, copy and paste what is below (most recent added) and add your name and players. I'll try to keep this updated. Copy the most recent addition to it (even if I didn't update it.) Until you physically sign your name to the sheet you are not counted. Sorry about being kind of a jerk about that but it would get annoying inputing 32 people.

A mods help may be needed for this. I may be PMing people if this takes off. Thanks in advance. Also if someone can sticky this it would be great.


Have Fun!
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions- Bahama Fin Fan - Calvin Johnson, Ernie Sims, Jeff Bakus, Donovan McNabb
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, Oshiomogho Atogwe, Reggie Wayne
3. Kansas City Chiefs- Emeraldfin: Matt Cassell, Branden Albert, Dwayne Bowe, Justin Tuck
4. Seattle Seahawks-KillerJosh373-Lofa Tatupu, Josh Wilson, TJ Housmanzadeh, Ryan Clady
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers, Chad Pennington
6. Cincinatti Bengals- Swantoon- Carson Palmer, Chad Johnson, Leon Hall
7. Oakland Raiders-Dlockz-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars- ADavieDolphin-Rasheen Mathis, Maurice Jones Drew,John Henderson
9. Green Bay Packers- 1 dol fan: Arron Rodgers, Greg Jennings, Aaron Kampman.
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills- ciscoholgate: Lee Evans, Trent Edwards, Leodis McKelvin
12. Denver Broncos- SpurzN703 - Brandon Marshall, Champ Bailey, Brian Dawkins
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints- Milldog-Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Pierre Thomas
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-edwardstoevans-Darrelle Revis, D'Brickishaw Ferguson, Kris Jenkins
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers- Orlando Fan- Gaines Adams, Jeff faine, Kellen Winslow
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Tony Romo, DeMarcus Ware, Terence Newman
21. Philadelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: Adrian Peterson, Jared Allen, Bryant McKinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-Matt Ryan, Roddy White, Micheal Turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts- Mdfinfan06- Peyton Manning, Dwight Freeney, Bob Sanders
28. Carolina Panthers-KDong13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-JDOE - Eli Manning, Brandon Jacobs, Osi Umenyiora
30.Tennessee Titans- I MiZFiT I - Chris Johnson, Lendale White, Nick Harper
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben RoethlisbergerWE HAVE ALL 32 TEAMS!!!!!!!!!
Let the Draft begin!
Ground Rules:
Only current NFL players none of the 2009 NFL rookie class. Also any preexisting injuries must be accounted for. Remember in this draft Michael Vick is still in jail, and Plaxico's leg still has a bullet hole. No funny stuff.
Obviously all players who are protected are ineligible for the draft. As are all drafted players.
If a player who has already been selected/drafted is picked make sure to try to tell the person (preferably by PM.) However, any picks which are made after the mistake will be counted. The person will just insert their new pick with the players not available to them.
24 hours will be given from the time of the previous pick to make the next selection. After that the pick will be skipped and the player (such as the above situation) can make the pick at anytime, however any picks before the selection will be counted.

After you make you selection it is your duty to private message the player who is behind you, telling them that they are on the clock. This will help keep the draft moving.

Remember the Draft inverts with each round. The Steelers have the 32 and 33rd pick of the draft. While the Cardinals have the 31st and 34th. Detroit has the last pick in the 2nd round as well as the first pick in the third.

I think that is about it. If any suggestions, we can talk in here.

I am going to private message the Lions GM, and officially place him on the clock. However, due to it being the first pick 36 hours will be granted before moving on.


Could everyone please do their part in keeping the picks updated my posting our original list of keepers with your new draft pick!
 
Miami Dolphins:
Jake Long
Ronnie Brown
Vernon Carey
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins-
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears-
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-
23. New England Pats-
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins-
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
Miami Dolphins:
Jake Long
Ronnie Brown
Vernon Carey

I want to set the precident of everyone doing it themselves so I don't have to deal with controlling everyone. That way it locks people in to it also.
So if you could will you copy and paste the list I made and insert your name and keepers.
That way I can just copy and paste it back onto the first post, like I did. That way there is no discrepancy to who took waht team. I am not going to count anyone officially locked in until they do that.
Thanks

Edit:
I put yours in due to me just putting in that rule.
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Det Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. KC Chiefs-
4. Sea Seahawks-
5. Clev Browns- Clownfish
6. Cin Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jax Jaguars-
9. GB Packers-
10. SF 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Den Broncos-
13. Wash Redskins-
14. NO Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. SD Chargers-
17. NY Jets-
18. Chi Bears-
19. TB Bucs-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philly Eagles-
22. Minn Vikings- FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. NE Pats-
24. Atl Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins-
26. Balt Raven-
27. Ind Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. NY Giants-
30. Tenn Titans-
31. Arz Cardinals-
32. Pitt Steelers-
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins-
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears-
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins-
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears-
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins-
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears-
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-


I added yours Tyler due to me just putting that rule in. Ex post facto as those crazy Romans say.
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears-
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings- FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. Peterson, J. Allen, B. McKinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears-
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings- FinsFan_in_Iraq: Adrian Peterson, Jared Allen, Bryant McKinnie
23. New England Patriots-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals-
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
I would also love to read people's rationales for these picks... Very interesting stuff... Mine is as follows...

Bears - 'Da bears' are a team in need all over the field and both sides of the ball IMO... I feel that this would be a chance to upgrade as well as get younger... if I was GM I would be putting a premium on youth in this scenario...

Jay Cutler - Think he is a no brainer for this team... Young strong armed pro bowl QB... 'Nuff said.

Lance Briggs - He was the Bears sole selection to the Pro Bowl last year and the heart of their defense if Urlacher is the soul... Again I think he is a standout and no brainer in the scenario...

Matt Forte - Ok he was a little bit of a risk... A 23 yr old rookie RB who had an excellent season... Downside? He is young... Upside? He is young... I think he is a complete back as he showed great instincts carrying and receiving... Over 1,200 yards as a rook with 8 TD's I don't think he can be ignored.... And since I would plan on improving the line through the 'Keeper Draft' I think the sky is the limit... :lol:

Other considerations... Urlacher obviously, I just think he has lost a step and Briggs is better and younger with upside... Ok here is where I sweated... Olsen the young TE... First off I think that more people are going to be inclined to protect positions like RB and QB... meaning there will be less available... TE might be a spot I could plunder even though Olsen looks to be a real player as TE was a strength for them last year (in fact I think he led all receivers for Da Bears... Ouch). I just think in this scenario there are alot of TE's to be had and Forte, in what I would try to do, would be a smarter pick even though I might lose Olsen. I considered Devin Hester for his versatiltiy for about a millisecond and even the newly acquired Orlando Pace but again... For this scenario I think you have to protect your best YOUNGEST 3... Cutler, Briggs and Forte are it IMHO.

So who has the stones to take the Chargers??? :lol:
 
Hi All,
This thread is a bit of a spin off of an idea I posted in the Dolphins Forums. (http://www.finheaven.com/forums/f2/who-would-be-your-dolphins-keepers-246905.html?posted=1#post1062906514post1062906514)
The post got good response and many wanted to execute this actual idea.
Here's the premise:
Due to impending CBA doom, the NFL has decided to make all players free agents and place them into a draft.
Each team is allowed to protect 3 players to prevent them from going into the pool.
The idea is to include 32 people to take each of the NFL teams. Each person designates 3 players "keepers" who do not go into the pool of FA's.
Once all teams are filled and keepers designated we will follow the order of the 2009 NFL draft to make it easy. I'll make sure every team has a pick and no team has 2 picks.
Think just like a regular fantasy draft, where each round is reversed. Therefore the Steelers get the #32 and #33 pick in the draft.
Remember to draft/keep not based on fantasy points, but based on in real life who would you want to build a team around. Remember to factor in age and positional demand of the players. When you pick a team, copy and paste what is below (most recent added) and add your name and players. I'll try to keep this updated. Copy the most recent addition to it (even if I didn't update it.) Until you physically sign your name to the sheet you are not counted. Sorry about being kind of a jerk about that but it would get annoying inputing 32 people.

A mods help may be needed for this. I may be PMing people if this takes off. Thanks in advance. Also if someone can sticky this it would be great.

Have Fun!-

One quick clarification, is the draft gonna be 22 rounds or 50 rounds (we've already got 3 players)? Also, can we add players that are coming into the NFL in this years draft?

Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams-
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers-
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys-
21. Philladelphia Eagles-
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons-
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-
 
Back
Top Bottom