Your Top 5 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Your Top 5

Dogbone34

Dogbone34

cowboy surfer
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
3,778
Reaction score
1,648
Location
Malibu
with Berry and Suh off the board and no trade down options, who are your top 5 picks for #12?

1 Dez Bryant
2 Rolando McClain
3 CJ Spillar
4 Earl Thomas
5 Brandon Spikes
 
Pat White and Sean Smith in the second round last year were big mistakes. Our D front needs improvement as well as our receivers.

Trade: Paul Soliai, Will Allen, Fasano, and Joey Porter.

Draft in order:

1a. Terrence Cody, 1b. Joe Haden, 1c. Brandon Spikes, 1d. Brandon Graham
2a. Kam Chancellor, 2b. Danario Alexander, 2c. Nate Allen 2d. Marty Gilyard
3a. Jimmy Graham/Dedrick Epps, 3b. Phillip Dillard, 3c. Freddie Barnes, 3d. Brandon Harris CB.
 
1) Rolando McClain
2) Dez Bryant
3) CJ Spiller
4) Derrick Morgan
5) Golden Tate
 
DolGinn said:
Pat White and Sean Smith in the second round last year were big mistakes. Our D front needs improvement as well as our receivers.

Trade: Paul Soliai, Will Allen, Fasano, and Joey Porter.

Draft in order:

1a. Terrence Cody, 1b. Joe Haden, 1c. Brandon Spikes, 1d. Brandon Graham
2a. Kam Chancellor, 2b. Danario Alexander, 2c. Nate Allen 2d. Marty Gilyard
3a. Jimmy Graham/Dedrick Epps, 3b. Phillip Dillard, 3c. Freddie Barnes, 3d. Brandon Harris CB.
Click to expand...

I don't understand how you say Sean Smith in the 2nd was a mistake, then come back with Kam Chancellor in your mock.
 
WelcomeBack said:
I don't understand how you say Sean Smith in the 2nd was a mistake, then comd back with Kam Chancellor in your mock.
Click to expand...

Sean Smith had one highlight play, and it came in the preseason. The secondary was terrible this year again. Vontae Davis provides much hope and has played well at times. Free Safety is what we know it is. Therefore, Kam Chancellor.
 
DolGinn said:
Sean Smith had one highlight play, and it came in the preseason. The secondary was terrible this year again. Vontae Davis provides much hope and has played well at times. Free Safety is what we know it is. Therefore, Kam Chancellor.
Click to expand...

Highlight plays do not designate the skill of a cornerback.

Here's some stats...you tell me if you'd care about who we had.

Player 1 - 39 tackles, 0 INT, 12 passes defended

Player 2 - 34 tackles, 1 INT, 4 passes defended
 
DolGinn said:
Sean Smith had one highlight play, and it came in the preseason. The secondary was terrible this year again. Vontae Davis provides much hope and has played well at times. Free Safety is what we know it is. Therefore, Kam Chancellor.
Click to expand...

we already have two, arguably three strong safeties on the team. Kam Chancellor wouldn't bring us anything we don't currently have.
 
WelcomeBack said:
I don't understand how you say Sean Smith in the 2nd was a mistake, then comd back with Kam Chancellor in your mock.
Click to expand...

As a VT student, I've seen a lot of Chancellor, and I don't want him starting for our team. First of all, he's a SS...we're looking for a ball-hawk FS. He's an athletic freak, but he struggles in coverage at times. I was high on him coming into this year and he disappointed me a bit. He can bring the big hits from time to time, but isn't always fundamentally sound and misses more tackles than he should. Think Taylor Mays lite.
 
DolGinn said:
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/players/profile?playerId=3596
Click to expand...

Goodman's gone, and apparently is sitting at home just like the Dolphins are this postseason. It took Goodman how many years to reach that level? And he didn't do anything until just last season with the Dolphins.

Sean Smith is a rookie, starting his first 16 games of his career. He's an awesome cover corner who needs to learn how to play the ball and tackle better. You can teach those things.
 
WelcomeBack said:
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/players/profile?playerId=3596
Click to expand...

Goodman's gone, and apparently is sitting at home just like the Dolphins are this postseason. It took Goodman how many years to reach that level? And he didn't do anything until just last season with the Dolphins.

Sean Smith is a rookie, starting his first 16 games of his career. He's an awesome cover corner who needs to learn how to play the ball and tackle better. You can teach those things.[/quote]

We kept Allen and traded Goodman. And then got Smith. Brilliant!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom