skillkills
Active Roster
Name me another college prospect who was an elite passer and athlete like Murray who wasn't considered great.There are no "great" QB's in this draft. The analogy was the "great" vs. "good"...played out between Haskins and Lock.
Herbert needs another year because he lacks polish. Even so, I doubt having an extra year in his belt would solidify him as a number one pick. He would need to have a jump like Mayfield's junior and senior season to be in consideration. Whereas Tua is already there since his sophomore season.Hell, I look Herbert better than Fromm and Tua...
You were on my case for assigning a 3rd round grade on Haskins for pointing out a legitimate issue about him and you turn around and take a questionable stance against two elite prospects? Both Tua and Murray can elevate teams as rookies. With Herbert, you need to pray to the football gods and carry around a rabbit foot wishing and hoping he becomes the answer.