Not A Good Draft | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Not A Good Draft

I think the draft overall sucked. Very weak class. Didn’t really care about FA, Schedule Release, or the draft. This is a calendar year to not get upset about anything Miami does or doesn’t do.
 
So I was reading the Giants forum and predictably most hate the Jones pic and are pissed we picked up Rosen at the cost we did. He was strongly preferred.

Anyone one poster observed that Josh is going from the frying pan into the fire. In response someone astutely asked "would you rather have Jones and who we drafted or Rosen, Haskins and 12pics next draft?". He impartially made the point that we are in pretty damn good shape going forward!
 
Weird draft. IMHO, we did very well for most of the draft, stockpiling talent for next year with the trade downs, getting the right players with the first two picks (the most important picks) Wilkins and Deiter, but not sure we drafted any more starters. I'm not as optimistic about Rosen as most, so while it is a trade, he could become a 3rd starter and the most important piece to this draft, and I don't want to minimize what the Grier/McKenzie/Flores & the front office did, they masterfully got an extra 2nd next year by trading down, then traded for a young QB who has already been paid his bonus for a late 2nd, so that was good bargaining.

Ultimately, Rosen's success or failure will determine this entire draft. If he succeeds, we crushed it. If he doesn't … well then this becomes a subpar draft where we're rebuilding and only got 2 starters. (plus a 2nd next year).

But in the end, we needed more talent. I'm hopeful someone like Van Ginkel can work but he isn't big enough, not quite fast enough, doesn't shed blockers, needs help (scheme) to get to the QB, and looks more like a special teamer than a starting off-ball LB, and probably not an edge rusher.

Isaiah Prince is a project pure and simple. Big mauling OT with good potential and length, but he gets stood up too much, spends too much time on the ground, isn't a great pass protector, doesn't finish his blocks, and often just stops blocking before the play is finished. In short, he's a long ways from fulfilling that potential, and he looks like a guy that will be very hard to re-sign if he ever reaches that potential, and offers little until he does.

The 7th rounders never have a high chance of success, and these guys are no different, a role playing FB we could have gotten as an UDFA, and a scatback. The real meat of this draft, rounds 3-5, could have all produced starters, but we maneuvered ourselves out of most of those picks, and didn't take advantage of that value. Now, it's all riding on how Rosen works out or doesn't work out.

Give me a 7 th round scatback every year with 5788 yard from scrimmage with 62 TD’s.
 
I didn't follow this draft process closely much at all, so I really didn't come into this with much knowledge on any of these players. Maybe that's why I'm not upset about this draft whatsoever. To me, if Wilkins and Dieder hit, thats a decent draft, especially if Rosen turns into something.

They had so few early picks that the draft was bound to disappoint people looking fo names.
 
Van stinkel pick was very questionable. So many better options.

Or we can just wait and see what happens when he's coached up and plays some actual football.

I was pounding the table for others as well, but obviously they saw something in him that they like. That was a Flores pick, and I'm gonna trust Flores on his guys until he proves otherwise.
 
So you're not happy because the FO selected guys you've never heard of and you believe we are following the model of the most successful NFL team over the last 18 years?

I don't want them to bring new England to Miami, I want them to bring traits but abandon other strategies that new England uses. You guys are horrible man lmfao
 
Back
Top Bottom