Which Nfl Players Could Realistically (and Not So Realistically) Still Be Traded This Summer? | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Which Nfl Players Could Realistically (and Not So Realistically) Still Be Traded This Summer?

djphinfan said:
I wouldn't trade Drake, the lack of depth is not good, and he’s young enough to be a nice Piece in the unit for the future,..

Gesecki I would though...
Click to expand...

After 1 season you would trade Gesecki? Unreal...
 
Etuoo33 said:
The guy has won a couple games so we should trade him, maybe for a 4th or 5th, that will be out of the NFL in 2 years....
Click to expand...

No... but if somebody would do a 2 or an early 3?.....it might be a good idea.

Running backs generally have a short lifespan...and this time is building for 2020.
 
I like Drake, but I would take a 3rd. Lets see what Ballage can do during the rebuild.
If we drafted the rest of the team like we do RB's... We would have a dynasty.
 
ANUFan said:
After 1 season you would trade Gesecki? Unreal...
Click to expand...
It is, I admit it’s pretty unrealistic, but I’m just trying to salvage some draft stock..If I could mitigate the damage by offsetting the cost with a Lower round pick I would do it..

I’m just not confident at all, I’m sure he could get 30 catches but to me thats not worth the price of what he can’t do
 
djphinfan said:
It is, I admit it’s pretty unrealistic, but I’m just trying to salvage some draft stock..If I could mitigate the damage by offsetting the cost with a Lower round pick I would do it..

I’m just not confident at all, I’m sure he could get 30 catches but to me thats not worth the price of what he can’t do
Click to expand...

You would make a terrible GM.
Young player with play making ability at the college level.
Played at a position that's nutritious hard to learn.
Played under a former coach that didn't showcase his particular skillset.
Now, seems to be under a coaching staff that may understand what he can and can't do.

But your solution is to get rid of the player based on his first year evaluation....For what?
 
BlueFin said:
No... but if somebody would do a 2 or an early 3?.....it might be a good idea.

Running backs generally have a short lifespan...and this time is building for 2020.
Click to expand...

I hear you, but IMO it's unrealistic to think you can get that high of a pick for a RB who has promise but no real stats to back it up. I'd do it for a #2 in a heartbeat, a 3 would have to be from a team that would picking early, in theory for me. I think he has more value to this team than a late 3rd,
 
ANUFan said:
You would make a terrible GM.
Young player with play making ability at the college level.
Played at a position that's nutritious hard to learn.
Played under a former coach that didn't showcase his particular skillset.
Now, seems to be under a coaching staff that may understand what he can and can't do.

But your solution is to get rid of the player based on his first year evaluation....For what?
Click to expand...



And you dropping a high 2nd round pick on him last year would be a poor GM move..

Of course the Gm who made that pick is going to think like you..

I would not of selected the player, and what I saw last year doesn’t deter me from that.

But I hope you are right about him and he at least doesn’t become a wasted 2nd round pick.

Me saying I would trade him is just thinking out loud, I don’t think anyone would do that.
 
djphinfan said:
And you dropping a high 2nd round pick on him last year would be a poor GM move..

Of course the Gm who made that pick is going to think like you..

I would not of selected the player, and what I saw last year doesn’t deter me from that.

But I hope you are right about him and he at least doesn’t become a wasted 2nd round pick.

Me saying I would trade him is just thinking out loud, I don’t think anyone would do that.
Click to expand...

They guy had 2nd round grade as a NFL prospect and your quote is "And you dropping a high 2nd round pick on him last year would be a poor GM move"
You think they just randomly assign those grades to any player?

I trust the analysis process a lot more that assigned him that 2nd round grade than your hindsight and shortsightedness after his rookie year.
 
Etuoo33 said:
I hear you, but IMO it's unrealistic to think you can get that high of a pick for a RB who has promise but no real stats to back it up. I'd do it for a #2 in a heartbeat, a 3 would have to be from a team that would picking early, in theory for me. I think he has more value to this team than a late 3rd,
Click to expand...

Exactly my feelings!
 
ANUFan said:
They guy had 2nd round grade as a NFL prospect and your quote is "And you dropping a high 2nd round pick on him last year would be a poor GM move"
You think they just randomly assign those grades to any player?

I trust the analysis process a lot more that assigned him that 2nd round grade than your hindsight and shortsightedness after his rookie year.
Click to expand...
Grades are subjective, and this is one player that we are talking about so opinions about him can vary...Russell Wilson didn’t have a first or 2nd round grade..should of been the #1 pick or #2 overall, etc..

And you thinking we should trust the draft advisory board blindly over what we personally see and evaluate is your opinion not mine, use them as a reference but not to make your final call, jmo, you can follow anyone you trust..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom