Rosen: Post A Grade... | Page 6 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Rosen: Post A Grade...

MDFINFAN said:
Did you forget he made the throws to get to the point where a running back takes it in. it's more than just throwing TD's, if you get your team into position to run it in.. That's just as good.
Click to expand...

This team isnt running it in the endzone many times this year against defenses. He played ok against backups. Lets pipe it down a bit.

Lets remember Fitz who looked liked ass in the first half against the first team defense, strolled down the field in the second half for a TD. Large difference between first team defenses and the guys that will be looking for a second career that Rosen was facing.

And last week he had the whole half against a first team defesne (albeit not a good one) and we scored 6 points.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
MDFINFAN said:
Did you forget he made the throws to get to the point where a running back takes it in. it's more than just throwing TD's, if you get your team into position to run it in.. That's just as good.
Click to expand...
I'm willing to bet that if we had a 0TD 16INT QB at the end of the season, people wouldn't be clamoring for him to continue to be the starter because "he got them in position". This is a strange take.
 
Kamelion4291 said:
I'm willing to bet that if we had a 0TD 16INT QB at the end of the season, people wouldn't be clamoring for him to continue to be the starter because "he got them in position". This is a strange take.
Click to expand...
A strange take is complaining he didnt throw a TD, after he led the team to a TD. What do you want? For him to get TDs for your fntasy league or for the phins to win?
 
PhxSunFan34 said:
A strange take is complaining he didnt throw a TD, after he led the team to a TD. What do you want? For him to get TDs for your fntasy league or for the phins to win?
Click to expand...
If we have a QB that never throws a TD, we won't win much. This shouldn't be a discussion.
 
TDs by air or land don't matter to me.

We've been so point deprived for so long

we're all suffering TD malnutrition.
 
C.

I think many are grading him too high because Fitz has looked pretty crappy.

But I think C is fine grade for what alot of others have pointed out. New O, pitiful oline, Stills and an undrafted rookie are your best options out wide, etc, etc..
 
Ross said:
C.

I think many are grading him too high because Fitz has looked pretty crappy.

But I think C is fine grade for what alot of others have pointed out. New O, pitiful oline, Stills and an undrafted rookie are your best options out wide, etc, etc..
Click to expand...

The guys running for his life on practically every play and is still making plays and you give him a C?

unreal... Lets put Brady or Brees back there and see how they do.
 
ANUFan said:
The guys running for his life on practically every play and is still making plays and you give him a C?

unreal... Lets put Brady or Brees back there and see how they do.
Click to expand...

Most likely fine as they are two of the best to play the game and Rosen is...well, not.
 
"Lets put Brady or Brees back there and see how they do."

You really think they wouldn't do better? You really think they would have problems IDing the 'mike'?

Give me a break
 
ANUFan said:
Yeah..Brady under duress always looks like Brady! What a clown opinion to make.
Click to expand...

I can't imagine two hall of fame QB's faring better then a second year QB regardless of the situation. Completely ridiculous idea...
 
I am not calling anyone a clown for their opinion,but if you think Rosen is doing things at the QB position under circumstances that Brady or Brees couldn't do, well, your nose is red and round and your shoes are too big
 
INC. Gonna have to evaluate him when we have live bullets flying.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom