2015 Miami Dolphins Free Agency: An Early Guide to the Market | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

2015 Miami Dolphins Free Agency: An Early Guide to the Market

AL R

Super Donator
Club Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
24,164
Reaction score
23,791
Location
Davie, FL
With Miami needing to open up cap space, some veterans will be on the chopping block as the team tries to spend more effectively. Many of the Dolphins’ issues in 2014 came back to lacking explosiveness and playmakers at key positions, so change should be a welcome addition. Upgrading mediocre talent should not be hard for a quality general manager.
Some of the cuts are obvious if we’re judging by the lack of production that came in 2014. With the help of Over The Cap, we take a look at cuts that should occur to help alleviate Miami’s cap issues.

  • LB Dannell Ellerbe can be released to save $5.65 million. He would count as $4.2 million dead money on the cap.
  • CB Cortland Finnegan can be cut to save $5.475 million, with a $1 million dead cap hit.
  • DT Randy Starks can be released to save $5 million toward the cap, also with a $1 million dead cap hit.
  • WR Brian Hartline can be released to save $3.15 million, but his dead money is $4.2 million.
  • WR Mike Wallace can be cut to save $2.5 million, but if he's traded, Miami saves $5.5 million.
  • WR Brandon Gibson's release would save $3.26 million toward the cap.
  • LB Philip Wheeler can be designated as a June 1st cut to save $3 million toward the cap, but Miami doesn't get that cap room until that date.
  • RG Shelley Smith can be released to save $2.75 million.
  • Backup lineman Nate Garner can be cut to save $1.65 million.
The more likely cuts would give the Dolphins nearly $20 million to play with after factoring in the rookie-draft-class cost. Losing Dannell Ellerbe wouldn’t be significant at all since he wasn’t the impact player Miami had hoped when it signed him in 2013.
Vets Randy Starks, Cortland Finnegan and Brandon Gibson were too up and down in 2014, and none are worth their high-salary numbers moving forward. Philip Wheeler should be considered for a June 1st, as the money saved on his contract is much more significant with that designation. That leaves a tough decision on Brian Hartline.
Hartline wasn’t the same player in Bill Lazor’s offense, and he’s way overpaid for what he is. He’s the 16th-highest paid receiver in the NFL, but below-average as a starter. Until Mike Wallace’s self-benching in Week 17, it was a foregone conclusion that Hartline would be cut, but now, Wallace could be dumped for a mere $600,000 more than Hartline.
That could be worth it to purge a problem from the locker room, even though the talent difference is steep.
Either way, Miami should be able to open around $20 million to improve the roster. Let’s assume that one of Wallace/Hartline is released or traded as we look at the team needs moving forward.
Miami could also restructure Cameron Wake’s contract to open another $5 million of cap space. If Wake takes the restructure, it basically ensures he will end his career as a Dolphin, as his final two years on his deal would be hard to release. This would be a wise decision as Wake is a valuable leader in the locker room and improved his play in the last few weeks of the season.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/...ee-agency-an-early-guide-to-the-market/page/2

Not a big bleacher fan but here is a little look at 2015.
 
Nate Garner shouldn't be cut. You cut football players. Nate Garner is a retiree enjoying the South Florida sun. He ought to be treated as such.
 
Fields makes a lot of money too.

I am not cutting Hartline. Not a popular opinion, but he is a steady receiver and I am not changing up RT's targets too much.
 
Fields absolutely needs to be the FIRST cut. Good person, good punter. But I ain't spending no four million dollars of my salary cap on a friggin' punter unless he's booming 70 yarders on a consistent basis.
 
I agree fields needs to go. the reason im ok with hartline being cut or traded is bc he doesn't really fit the system and is being paid way to much. if he would take a pay cut then I would be ok with keeping him. we need to get more explosive. all of those guys can go
 
For what it's worth, here is what random yahoos on the internet who work for media outlets have speculated:

1. We are not going to make high offers to retain the services of Jared Odrick or Charles Clay. We only want them back at 'our' price.
2. The team is likely to cut Mike Wallace. Lots of speculation about this but the general feeling is that the problems are real and that's why they floated some info to Darlington and Armando.
3. A bunch of 'veterans' will not be back. So that would seem to indicate that guys like Delmas and Finnegan will be playing elsewhere.
 
Hartline and Gibson are both good value at $3 million each. They'll probably both be back, especially Hartline, because as opposed to Ireland, I don't think Philbin/Hickey believes in creating holes until they're sure the filler is already on the roster.

If we can't work out a deal with Clay we'll probably franchise him.

Finnegan is too expensive. Wheeler should have been cut after the Packers game. I'd like to see Delmas back but he'll probably get good money elsewhere. Ellerbe is a tough call, its hard to know how good he could have been after the position change. Starks and Odrick are goners. Shelly Smith may be worth keeping around at $3 million.

Wallace is a tough one, and one I waver back and forth on. If it weren't a glorified preseason game he'd be gone for sure, but the fact that it was complicates the matter. Its kind of the opposite of the Wheeler situation, Wheeler's message was he wanted less responsibility and was pissed he was put in to a position to look bad, while Wallace's message is "I can do so much more, GIVE ME MOAR!!!" Wallace's delivery method for his message sucks, and maybe he caused irreparable damage, and maybe he can't be trusted to not lollygag in games that matter anymore, but I don't mind the fact that he's pissed that he isn't getting more targets.
 
I want delmas back. the guy played 10x better than I thought he would. we need to get clay back. those are the only two im worried about. but clay has to be priority.
 
I would keep Wallace, make a good effort to keep Clay unless we are sure we can get a good TE.
Cut Fields for sure, unless he wants to restructure..No point in paying 4 mill for an average punter at this point in his career.
Cut wheeler, ellerbee, garner, starks, Gibson for sure
cut Hartline unless you don't think you can upgrade in the draft
 
LB Dannell Ellerbe - will be a 9.8 million cap hit, that's slightly more than Wake! You have to let him go.
CB Cortland Finnegan - age caught up to him, he's most likely done.
DT Randy Starks - Earl Mitchell will allow us to cut Starks or not resign Odrick.
WR Brian Hartline - will be here one more year.
WR Mike Wallace - cap hit decreases 5.15, also stays
WR Brandon Gibson's - Let him go
LB Philip Wheeler - needs to go but I think he stays one more year.
RG Shelley Smith - Stays.
Backup lineman Nate Garner - Let go
 
Usually when you see a list of potential cuts like this, you think to yourself "Dang, this is a disaster." In this case, I look at this list of potential cuts and think "Dang, we are getting free money!"

Ellerbe: garbage player. Replacement level at best. $4.2 million in 'dead' money frees up $5.65 million in money that can be spent on players who can actually get on the field and not be awful.

Finnegan: I'll take a $1 million cap hit and spend that free $5.475 million dollars on a cornerback who can tackle someone in bounds with 30 seconds to play after the guy cuts inside.

Gibson: I actually like Gibson, but $3.26 million saved and the net loss is... a guy who doesn't get put on the field to begin with. Free money.

Philip Wheeler: I don't care if cutting this guy costs us money. I just feel better knowing that he's gone.

Shelley Smith: Easy decision. If we're going to put the worst guard on the planet (Colledge) out there in his place, why pay this guy almost $3 million? Free money.

Nate Garner: Free money. Hey, maybe we can recoup some since he technically retired on us mid-season.

Again, it's free money! We are losing players who are getting paid big money and are performing about as well as bums Hickey picks up off the street. Anyone out there really think Dannell Ellerbe is worth $6 million more than Kelvin Sheppard or even Jason freakin' Trusnik?

[video=youtube_share;GjfYA68GfCg]http://youtu.be/GjfYA68GfCg[/video]
 
Fields makes a lot of money too.
I am not cutting Hartline. Not a popular opinion, but he is a steady receiver and I am not changing up RT's targets too much.

I agree. However, his position (no 2 WR) needs to be upgraded. He needs to restructure and be relegated to number 3 or 4. Landry should be starting and then moving to the slot when they go to 3 and 4 receiver sets. Gibson needs to be cut and his spot upgraded with a promising young draft pick.
 
I would keep Wallace, make a good effort to keep Clay unless we are sure we can get a good TE.
Cut Fields for sure, unless he wants to restructure..No point in paying 4 mill for an average punter at this point in his career.
Cut wheeler, ellerbee, garner, starks, Gibson for sure
cut Hartline unless you don't think you can upgrade in the draft

No way should we keep Michelle Wallace.....his die has been cast and he's thrown himself in with the Percy Harvins of the world.

I just get the sense that when he gets the boot there will be an overall sense of relief and weight off the shoulders just like when Harvin was booted.

Now, if we can get some kind of trade deal for him that's even better but knowing our FO they'll f it up anyway and get another loser
 
There's talk of Minnesota not sure if they wanna bring Chad Greenway back or not. I would pick him up.
 
Back
Top Bottom