2018 Qbs: Production Analysis | Page 4 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

2018 Qbs: Production Analysis

Blake Bortles

DATA:

Com: 259
Att: 382 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 67.8 (Red flag, just over 67.5)
TD: 25
INT: 9
SK: 21

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 18.2 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 42.4 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 15.3 (Yellow flag, 14-16)
Reliability: 34.3 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is borderline draftable, because his flags are borderline. Late rounds for me.
 
Johnny Manziel

DATA:

Com: 300
Att: 429 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 69.9 (Red flag, over 67.5)
TD: 37
INT: 13
SK: 19

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 22.6 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 33.0 (Red flag under 34)
Att/TD: 11.6 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 44.9 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable, because of two red flags.
 
Teddy Bridgewater

DATA:

Com: 303
Att: 427 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 71.0 (Red flag, over 67.5)
TD: 31
INT: 4
SK: 23

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 18.6 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 106.8 (Green flag, over 70)
Att/TD: 13.7 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 102.1 (Yellow flag 70 - 117)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable. Green flag overcomes the red flag. Reliability is very high and scoring is not elite, so mid to late rounds for me.
 
Derek Carr

DATA:

Com: 454
Att: 659 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 68.9 (Red flag, over 67.5)
TD: 50
INT: 8
SK: 11

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 59.9 (Green flag, over 34)
Att/int: 82.4 (Green flag, over 70)
Att/TD: 13.2 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 258 (Red flag, way over 117)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable because green flags overcome red flags, but I would not draft him because reliability is way too high.
 
Jimmy Garropolo

DATA:

Com: 375
Att: 568 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 66.0 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 53
INT: 9
SK: 19

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 29.9(clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 63.1 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 10.7 (clears the benchmark, 10.5-14 almost elite)
Reliability: 116 (Yellow flag, 70-116)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable. Reliability is a high, but scoring is excellent, which puts him in first round conversation, but probably second round. So Rd1 to Rd2.
 
Logan Thomas

DATA:

Com: 228
Att: 403 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 56.6 (Red flag under 61)
TD: 16
INT: 13
SK: 29

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 13.9 (Red flag under 17)
Att/int: 31.0 (Red flag under 34)
Att/TD: 25.2 (Red flag over 16)
Reliability: 9.7 (Red flag way under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many red flags.
 
Tom Savage

DATA:

Com: 238
Att: 389 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 61.2 (Yellow flag 61 - 63)
TD: 21
INT: 9
SK: 43

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 9.0 (Red flag under under 17)
Att/int: 43.2 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 18.5 (Red flag over 16)
Reliability: 12.9 (Red flag under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many bad flags.
 
Aaron Murray

DATA:

Com: 225
Att: 347 (Yellow flag 280 - 350)
C%: 64.8 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 26
INT: 9
SK: 13

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 26.7 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 39.6 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 13.4 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 50.0 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable. Borderline attempts are a concern because the QB does not have a great frame, strength and size to increase the production load. Mid rounds for me.
 
AJ McCarron

DATA:

Com: 226
Att: 336 (Yellow flag 280-350)
C%: 64.8 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 28
INT: 7
SK: 17

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 19.8 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 48.0(clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 12.0 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 53.2 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)
Additional: Two-time National Champion. Green flag.

Conclusion: This QB is first-round value.
 
Zach Mettenburger

DATA:

Com: 192
Att: 296 (Yellow flag 280 - 350)
C%: 64.9 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 22
INT: 8
SK: 21

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 14.1 (Red flag under 17)
Att/int: 37.0 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 13.5 (clears the benchmark under 14)
Reliability: 25.1 (Red flag under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many bad flags.
 
David Fales

DATA:

Com: 312
Att: 487 (clears the benchmark over 350)
C%: 64.1 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 33
INT: 13
SK: 19

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 25.6 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 37.5(clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 14.8 (Yellow flag 14-16)
Reliability: 41.7 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is draftable. He had borderline winning record in senior year and scoring is not under 14, so mid rounds for me, 3-4th round.
 
Keith Wenning

DATA:

Com: 319
Att: 498 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 64.1 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 35
INT: 17
SK: 13

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 38.3 (Green flag, over 34)
Att/int: 71.1 (Green flag, over 70)
Att/TD: 14.2 (Yellow flag 14-16)
Reliability: 123 (Red flag over 117)

Conclusion: This Qb is draftable. Green flags overcome red flags. However, reliability is very high, and he should not be drafted.
 
Tajh Boyd

DATA:

Com: 283
Att: 413 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 68.5 (Red flag, over 67.5)
TD: 34
INT: 11
SK: 26

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 12.9 (Red flag under 17)
Att/int: 37.6 (clears the benchmark, not under 35.8)
Att/TD: 12.2 (clears the benchmark, under 14)
Reliability: 37.3 (Red flag under 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB is not draftable because of too many red flags.
 
Garrett Gilbert

DATA:

Com: 335
Att: 504 (clears the benchmark 350)
C%: 66.5 (clears the benchmark, 63-67.5)
TD: 21
INT: 7
SK: 26

ANALYSIS:

Att/Sk: 19.4 (clears the benchmark, not under 17)
Att/int: 72 (Green flag, over 70)
Att/TD: 24.0 (Red flag, over 16)
Reliability: 38.7 (clears the benchmark, not less than 28.5)

Conclusion: This QB could be drafted because green flag overcomes the red flag. However, red flag on scoring is very high. It's not worth it.
 
Back
Top Bottom