2019 Draft - Grier & Flores first draft review | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

2019 Draft - Grier & Flores first draft review

Grade for 2019 draft class

  • A

  • B+

  • B

  • B-

  • C

  • C-

  • D

Results are only viewable after voting.
P

phin1984!

Active Roster
Joined
Jan 21, 2012
Messages
745
Reaction score
644
What do you grade the 2019 draft:

Wilkins
Trade Rosen
Dieter
AVG
Prince
Gaskin

For me it’s a B+ they 50% hit rate is good. We’ve got at least 3 hits with Wilkins, AVG and Gaskin. Dieter TBD

Nobody talks about the first draft of the Grier and Flores era but we’ve got over 2 and a half seasons watching them.
 
It is solid probably a B-

Wilkins is a starter but Simmons is better then him who the Titans drafted.

Dieter worked his way to be a starter.

AVG is a borderline starter a better spot starter or a good sub package player.

Gaskins is a 3rd down back.
 
B-minus or C-plus. Wilkins is solid but unspectacular. Rosen was a wasted pick. Deiter may not make a decent roster. AVG is a backup quality player. Gaskin is a backup quality player.

We got four contributors, so it’s not terrible, but we got one starter and three guys who are fringe roster players on a playoff team.
 
I gave it a B for the picks being mostly successful but the failed Rosen experiment. Gaskin is a whatever, he was a late rounder, surprised hes our #1 still.
 
I look at it this way, who on that list is getting a second contract from us??? We’re not picking up that 5th year for Wilkins at 13 mil and AVG hasn’t even lived up to his name until last night. Rosen may have cost us that center the saints drafted and Gaskin may have allowed us to pass on a rb instead of iggy. Now since those aren’t guarantees, I’ll give the draft a C
 
As always, the grades depend a lot on how old you are - ie how much grade inflation there’s been since you were in school. “Average” is anywhere from C to B+ or even A- depending on your age.

2019 was an “average” draft overall.
 
Gaskin for me is a good 3rd down back, a decent return for a 7th round pick. AVG a good spot player but good value 5th round. Wilkins has started playing really well. PFF grade Wilkins as the 6th ranked IDL for what it’s worth
 

Attachments

  • 6A981BA7-6419-490B-B4C0-2FBC3E0E9DD0.png
    6A981BA7-6419-490B-B4C0-2FBC3E0E9DD0.png
    200.8 KB · Views: 19
I voted C. Wilkins is solid and a team leader. Gaskin was nice value in the 7th. AVG sure looked good yesterday, but he needs more games like that.

I thought Dieter was playing well before he got hurt.

The Rosen trade obviously didn't work out. I think McCoy, the center, would have been available with that pick.
 
I’m the only one giving a D I guess. I also feel the grades others are giving would be a lot lower if it wasn’t for yesterday’s win and everyone feeling better about the team
Wilkins-C- DTs could be had for cheap in FA and I’m not burning the 13th overall pick on a DT unless he’s a sack guy. Wilkins has not lived up to his draft position.
2nd round F. The whole Rosen thing was poorly handled from day one.
Deiter- F just cause he is starting for one of the worse lines ever doesn’t change that. He’s terrible. I remember pff having him ranked dead last of all lineman
4th round F- burned it on Rosen
5th round AVG- B- good pick for the 5th round but he’s a fringe starter
6th round -F prince I don’t think ever took a snap
7th gaskin-B solid player but not a #1

Obviously the lower the round the less value the grade has unless you hit big which they didn’t. Overall, all we have to show for that draft is Wilkins and AVG. that’s a pretty poor draft.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom