QB1 Burrow
QB2A/QB2B Tua/Herbert (The Durability negative on Tua drops him even with Herbert)
QB4 Love
QB2A/QB2B Tua/Herbert (The Durability negative on Tua drops him even with Herbert)
QB4 Love
Eason is potentially better than all of them. He's got the strongest arm and the fastest release in this class, and if he responds well to a 2-3 year learning curve, he'll be the best QB in the NFL.
But he aint ready to start... he's a total project.
The Tuaistas always say, shoot for the stars... we have to, have to take this guy in the first round... even trade up for him... even though he's never healthy... (I think they're wrong, but that isn't the point here)... Eason is potentially better... VERY HIGH risk of bust, but if he hits... Oh God... THAT is shooting for the stars, trying to draft a pocket QB who can play until he is 40.
Tua
Burrow
Herbert
Fromm
Love
I think the OP rankings are based on ceiling (?). Love probably has the largest gap between current play and ceiling, but he’s also going to have the hardest time reaching his ceiling out of the group.
I think the OP rankings are based on ceiling (?).
should we project (and consider as part of player ranking) career longevity, floor and ceiling, injury risk, time-to-start, and so on?
I could see teams grading the same way. Durability is important.QB1 Burrow
QB2A/QB2B Tua/Herbert (The Durability negative on Tua drops him even with Herbert)
QB4 Love
We should only project whether a QB on his rookie contract, in his first four years, can lead the team to be competitive with the best of the teams over a course of each season, take them to the playoffs, and give the team a chance at a superbowl.
Nothing else, not whether he is a decent quarterback, whether he has the tools, or footwork, or whether he can be in the league and good for the next 10 years.
Love over Burrow and Herbert? Get the F outta here!
I agree with most of that.I think that a strict numerical rating might be less than accurate.
Let me try it this way.
Burrow. High floor, high ceiling. Ready to start right away.
Tua. Low floor (injury), high ceiling. Needs a year off
Herbert. Mid floor, high ceiling. Ready to start.
Love. Low floor, high ceiling. Needs a year, maybe two.
Eason. Low floor, high ceiling. Needs a year, maybe two.
Fromm. Low floor, mid ceiling. Sure looks like a backup to me.
Hurts. Mid floor, high ceiling... as a wingback. He's no QB.
That's not true.It's based on biased homerism.
1. Burrow
2. Tua
3. Love
4. Herbert