Don’t blame OP for sharing but all of these instant reaction grades are stupid. There are some very rare deals that are obviously stupid on Day One. All the rest are TBD and depend on so many variables that it’s silly to even try to grade them.
For example, if Raheem Mostert comes to the Fins and stays healthy and averages 5+ yards per carry like he has for his career, then paying Chase Edmonds $6 million per year was really dumb. If Mostert comes here and tears his ACL and Edmonds gets 300 touches playing a Deebo-esque role, then signing him for $6 million was a steal. If we go RBBC and Edmonds just works as a quality 2-down back who catches a lot of balls, then he’s being paid just right.
Grade could be anywhere from A to F depending on things nobody can definitively project right now.