2025 QBs | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

2025 QBs

LargoFin

Super Donator
Club Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2018
Messages
7,643
Reaction score
8,022
Age
51
Location
Largo, Florida
Let's get the TedSlimm list going. I followed the PFF ranking first, then after they ran out of quarterbacks at top 20 I switched over to NFL Draft Buzz ranking.


QUARTERBACKS 2025

NflDraftBuzz.comDraftTek.comPFFName (link)SchoolHeightWeightAge
5 (31)4 (20)1 (6) ⭐Jalen MilroeALA6-222521.8 RJr 🌱
3 (7)8 (61)2 (16)Cam WardMiami6-222322.3 RSr
1 (4) ⭐3 (8)3 (21)Shedeur SandersCOL6-221522.7 Sr
7 (48)9 (88)4 (53)Garrett NussmeierLSU6-220022.6 RJr🌱
4 (26)1 (2) ⭐5 (57)Carson BeckUGA6-422021.8 Sr
2 (6)2 (4)6 (59)Quinn EwersTEX6-221021.5 RSr
9 (60)12 (146)7 (71)Miller MossUSC6-220521.6 RJr 🌱
15 (96)3 (35)8 (81)Connor WeigmanTAMU6-322021.1 RSo 🌱🌱
10 (62)6 (41)9 (99)Drew AllarPSU6-523520.6 Jr 🌱
8 (53)7 (45)10 (104)Jaxson DartOle Miss6-222521.4 Sr
14 (91)13 (185)11 (108)Jalon DanielsKAN6-122022.0 RJr 🌱
16 (103)15 (220)12 (110)Riley LeonardND6-421622.0 Sr
24 (259)NR13 (130)Graham MertzUF6-221623.9 RSr
12 (84)NR14 (139)Noah FifitaARI5-1018821.2 RSo 🌱🌱
6 (41)19 (295)15 (142)Dillon GabrielORE6-020023.9 Sr
11 (74)10 (91)16 (151)Cade KlubnikCLE6-221020.1 Jr 🌱
17 (110)24 (353)17 (163)Brady CookMIZ6-221522.8 Sr
13 (84)22 (347)18 (166)Donovan SmithUH6-523523.0 Sr
23 (234)20 (326)19 (197)KJ JeffersonUCF6-324723.3 RSr
19 (198)23 (349)20 (199)DJ UiagaleleiFSU6-425223.5 RSr
18 (193)21 (329)NRKyle McCordSYR6-322022.0 Sr
20 (201)NRNRHaynes KingGT6-321523.0 RJr 🌱
21 (223)NRNRTaylen GreenARK6-623021.1 RJr 🌱
22 (227)14 (218)NRPreston StoneSMU6-121922.1 Jr 🌱
25 (259)11 (118)NRWill HowardtOSU6-423523.1 Sr
26 (264)NRNRGarrett GreeneWVU5-1120123.0 Sr
27 (289)27 (407)NRKurtis RourkeIND6-522324.0 RSr
28 (297)17 (260)NRWill RogersWASH6-221623.1 Sr
29 (320)18 (274)NRTyler Van DykeWIS6-422523.7 RSr
30 (323)NRNRChandler RogersCAL6-020023.0 RSr
55 (550)16 (250)NRGrayson McCallNC St6-322024.0 Sr
43 (457)25 (356)NRSeth HeniganMEM6-321521.5 Sr
52 (510)26 (375)NRCameron RisingUTAH6-222025.5 Sr
NR28 (416)NRMark GronowskiS DAK St6-323023.0 Sr
31 (340)NRNRTy ThompsonTUL6-422421.0 Jr 🌱
32 (348)NRNRHudson CardPUR6-321023.0 Sr
33 (375)NRNRMatthew SlukaUNLV6-3215Sr
34 (382)Kaidon SalterLIB6-1200Jr 🌱
35 (392)JT DanielsRice6-2237Sr
36 (392)Hank BachmeierWF6-2215Sr
37 (400)Zach CalzadaINCAR6-5200Sr
38 (412)Collin SchleeVT6-3225Sr
39 (416)Tommy MellottMT St6-0208Sr
40 (417)Dylan MorrisJMU6-1202Sr
41 (429)Sam HuardUTAH6-2200Sr
42 (437)Tyler ShoughLOU6-522525.0 Sr
43 (463)Brock VandagriffUK6-321722.5 Jr 🌱
45 (464)Gerry BohanonBYU6-3226Sr
46 (468)Chandler MorrisN TEX6-0191Jr🌱
47 (468)Jake GarciaE CAR6-3203Jr 🌱
48 (487)Jeff SimsAZ St6-3215Sr
50 (496)Kyron DronesVT6-2234Jr 🌱
51 (497)Sawyer RobertsonBAY6-4220Jr 🌱
53 (519)Max JohnsonNC6-522523.5 Sr
54 (531)Payton ThorneAUB6-220323.3 Sr
56 (584)Spencer PetrasUT St6-523024.1 Sr
 
This is shaping up to be a historic QB class. I may end up with 9 first round grades. Normally I do not have more than 4-5 at most in a great year.
 
This is shaping up to be a historic QB class. I may end up with 9 first round grades. Normally I do not have more than 4-5 at most in a great year.
Most analysts are saying it's a much weaker class.
 
I think it is a mediocre class as well.

There are guys who may be good eventually, like Weigman and Milroe but I don't see a lot of upside with the others.

Nussmeier shows the intangibles you like and makes some legit NFL throws but he like Weigman has not played enough football and both should be part of the NEXT Draft not the coming one.

Sanders looks to be a pretty safe bet as he does some things pretty well but lacks the top end tools to ever be a Franchise guy.

Ewers is the guy who could rise should he return to the level he was playing t before his injury, he looked to have improved quite a bit from last year.

Cam Ward is a fun college QB but is too reckless with the football for me.

I would not want to go into this Draft needing a QB like the Raiders for example.
 
Let's get the TedSlimm list going. I followed the PFF ranking first, then after they ran out of quarterbacks at top 20 I switched over to NFL Draft Buzz ranking.


QUARTERBACKS 2025

NflDraftBuzz.comDraftTek.comPFFName (link)SchoolHeightWeightAge
5 (31)4 (20)1 (6) ⭐Jalen MilroeALA6-222521.8 RJr 🌱
3 (7)8 (61)2 (16)Cam WardMiami6-222322.3 RSr
1 (4) ⭐3 (8)3 (21)Shedeur SandersCOL6-221522.7 Sr
7 (48)9 (88)4 (53)Garrett NussmeierLSU6-220022.6 RJr🌱
4 (26)1 (2) ⭐5 (57)Carson BeckUGA6-422021.8 Sr
2 (6)2 (4)6 (59)Quinn EwersTEX6-221021.5 RSr
9 (60)12 (146)7 (71)Miller MossUSC6-220521.6 RJr 🌱
15 (96)3 (35)8 (81)Connor WeigmanTAMU6-322021.1 RSo 🌱🌱
10 (62)6 (41)9 (99)Drew AllarPSU6-523520.6 Jr 🌱
8 (53)7 (45)10 (104)Jaxson DartOle Miss6-222521.4 Sr
14 (91)13 (185)11 (108)Jalon DanielsKAN6-122022.0 RJr 🌱
16 (103)15 (220)12 (110)Riley LeonardND6-421622.0 Sr
24 (259)NR13 (130)Graham MertzUF6-221623.9 RSr
12 (84)NR14 (139)Noah FifitaARI5-1018821.2 RSo 🌱🌱
6 (41)19 (295)15 (142)Dillon GabrielORE6-020023.9 Sr
11 (74)10 (91)16 (151)Cade KlubnikCLE6-221020.1 Jr 🌱
17 (110)24 (353)17 (163)Brady CookMIZ6-221522.8 Sr
13 (84)22 (347)18 (166)Donovan SmithUH6-523523.0 Sr
23 (234)20 (326)19 (197)KJ JeffersonUCF6-324723.3 RSr
19 (198)23 (349)20 (199)DJ UiagaleleiFSU6-425223.5 RSr
18 (193)21 (329)NRKyle McCordSYR6-322022.0 Sr
20 (201)NRNRHaynes KingGT6-321523.0 RJr 🌱
21 (223)NRNRTaylen GreenARK6-623021.1 RJr 🌱
22 (227)14 (218)NRPreston StoneSMU6-121922.1 Jr 🌱
25 (259)11 (118)NRWill HowardtOSU6-423523.1 Sr
26 (264)NRNRGarrett GreeneWVU5-1120123.0 Sr
27 (289)27 (407)NRKurtis RourkeIND6-522324.0 RSr
28 (297)17 (260)NRWill RogersWASH6-221623.1 Sr
29 (320)18 (274)NRTyler Van DykeWIS6-422523.7 RSr
30 (323)NRNRChandler RogersCAL6-020023.0 RSr
55 (550)16 (250)NRGrayson McCallNC St6-322024.0 Sr
43 (457)25 (356)NRSeth HeniganMEM6-321521.5 Sr
52 (510)26 (375)NRCameron RisingUTAH6-222025.5 Sr
NR28 (416)NRMark GronowskiS DAK St6-323023.0 Sr
31 (340)NRNRTy ThompsonTUL6-422421.0 Jr 🌱
32 (348)NRNRHudson CardPUR6-321023.0 Sr
33 (375)NRNRMatthew SlukaUNLV6-3215Sr
34 (382)Kaidon SalterLIB6-1200Jr 🌱
35 (392)JT DanielsRice6-2237Sr
36 (392)Hank BachmeierWF6-2215Sr
37 (400)Zach CalzadaINCAR6-5200Sr
38 (412)Collin SchleeVT6-3225Sr
39 (416)Tommy MellottMT St6-0208Sr
40 (417)Dylan MorrisJMU6-1202Sr
41 (429)Sam HuardUTAH6-2200Sr
42 (437)Tyler ShoughLOU6-522525.0 Sr
43 (463)Brock VandagriffUK6-321722.5 Jr 🌱
45 (464)Gerry BohanonBYU6-3226Sr
46 (468)Chandler MorrisN TEX6-0191Jr🌱
47 (468)Jake GarciaE CAR6-3203Jr 🌱
48 (487)Jeff SimsAZ St6-3215Sr
50 (496)Kyron DronesVT6-2234Jr 🌱
51 (497)Sawyer RobertsonBAY6-4220Jr 🌱
53 (519)Max JohnsonNC6-522523.5 Sr
54 (531)Payton ThorneAUB6-220323.3 Sr
56 (584)Spencer PetrasUT St6-523024.1 Sr
Came Across this youtube video Talking Dolphins and '25 QB class it was really good
 
At a cursory look, I might have Sanders as the top quarterback. He looks pretty darn accurate and is athletic. I do think he holds onto the ball longer than he needs to sometimes. That could be a bit of a learning curve. The Robert Griffin III comp isn't terrible.

I like Ewers a lot. Can he stay healthy?

Allar is my wildcard. As a bigger guy, it looks like he's built for the NFL game. If he really ends up in the 2nd round, I'd pounce if I were Miami. I think he probably sneaks into the 1st.

Ward and Milroe I'll have to spend more time on.
 
I had Milroe as #1 two games ago, right now he is undraftable. We need to wait for the end of the season.
 
Let's get the TedSlimm list going. I followed the PFF ranking first, then after they ran out of quarterbacks at top 20 I switched over to NFL Draft Buzz ranking.


QUARTERBACKS 2025

NflDraftBuzz.comDraftTek.comPFFName (link)SchoolHeightWeightAge
5 (31)4 (20)1 (6) ⭐Jalen MilroeALA6-222521.8 RJr 🌱
3 (7)8 (61)2 (16)Cam WardMiami6-222322.3 RSr
1 (4) ⭐3 (8)3 (21)Shedeur SandersCOL6-221522.7 Sr
7 (48)9 (88)4 (53)Garrett NussmeierLSU6-220022.6 RJr🌱
4 (26)1 (2) ⭐5 (57)Carson BeckUGA6-422021.8 Sr
2 (6)2 (4)6 (59)Quinn EwersTEX6-221021.5 RSr
9 (60)12 (146)7 (71)Miller MossUSC6-220521.6 RJr 🌱
15 (96)3 (35)8 (81)Connor WeigmanTAMU6-322021.1 RSo 🌱🌱
10 (62)6 (41)9 (99)Drew AllarPSU6-523520.6 Jr 🌱
8 (53)7 (45)10 (104)Jaxson DartOle Miss6-222521.4 Sr
14 (91)13 (185)11 (108)Jalon DanielsKAN6-122022.0 RJr 🌱
16 (103)15 (220)12 (110)Riley LeonardND6-421622.0 Sr
24 (259)NR13 (130)Graham MertzUF6-221623.9 RSr
12 (84)NR14 (139)Noah FifitaARI5-1018821.2 RSo 🌱🌱
6 (41)19 (295)15 (142)Dillon GabrielORE6-020023.9 Sr
11 (74)10 (91)16 (151)Cade KlubnikCLE6-221020.1 Jr 🌱
17 (110)24 (353)17 (163)Brady CookMIZ6-221522.8 Sr
13 (84)22 (347)18 (166)Donovan SmithUH6-523523.0 Sr
23 (234)20 (326)19 (197)KJ JeffersonUCF6-324723.3 RSr
19 (198)23 (349)20 (199)DJ UiagaleleiFSU6-425223.5 RSr
18 (193)21 (329)NRKyle McCordSYR6-322022.0 Sr
20 (201)NRNRHaynes KingGT6-321523.0 RJr 🌱
21 (223)NRNRTaylen GreenARK6-623021.1 RJr 🌱
22 (227)14 (218)NRPreston StoneSMU6-121922.1 Jr 🌱
25 (259)11 (118)NRWill HowardtOSU6-423523.1 Sr
26 (264)NRNRGarrett GreeneWVU5-1120123.0 Sr
27 (289)27 (407)NRKurtis RourkeIND6-522324.0 RSr
28 (297)17 (260)NRWill RogersWASH6-221623.1 Sr
29 (320)18 (274)NRTyler Van DykeWIS6-422523.7 RSr
30 (323)NRNRChandler RogersCAL6-020023.0 RSr
55 (550)16 (250)NRGrayson McCallNC St6-322024.0 Sr
43 (457)25 (356)NRSeth HeniganMEM6-321521.5 Sr
52 (510)26 (375)NRCameron RisingUTAH6-222025.5 Sr
NR28 (416)NRMark GronowskiS DAK St6-323023.0 Sr
31 (340)NRNRTy ThompsonTUL6-422421.0 Jr 🌱
32 (348)NRNRHudson CardPUR6-321023.0 Sr
33 (375)NRNRMatthew SlukaUNLV6-3215Sr
34 (382)Kaidon SalterLIB6-1200Jr 🌱
35 (392)JT DanielsRice6-2237Sr
36 (392)Hank BachmeierWF6-2215Sr
37 (400)Zach CalzadaINCAR6-5200Sr
38 (412)Collin SchleeVT6-3225Sr
39 (416)Tommy MellottMT St6-0208Sr
40 (417)Dylan MorrisJMU6-1202Sr
41 (429)Sam HuardUTAH6-2200Sr
42 (437)Tyler ShoughLOU6-522525.0 Sr
43 (463)Brock VandagriffUK6-321722.5 Jr 🌱
45 (464)Gerry BohanonBYU6-3226Sr
46 (468)Chandler MorrisN TEX6-0191Jr🌱
47 (468)Jake GarciaE CAR6-3203Jr 🌱
48 (487)Jeff SimsAZ St6-3215Sr
50 (496)Kyron DronesVT6-2234Jr 🌱
51 (497)Sawyer RobertsonBAY6-4220Jr 🌱
53 (519)Max JohnsonNC6-522523.5 Sr
54 (531)Payton ThorneAUB6-220323.3 Sr
56 (584)Spencer PetrasUT St6-523024.1 Sr
Not a very good draft for QB
 
At a cursory look, I might have Sanders as the top quarterback. He looks pretty darn accurate and is athletic. I do think he holds onto the ball longer than he needs to sometimes. That could be a bit of a learning curve. The Robert Griffin III comp isn't terrible.

I like Ewers a lot. Can he stay healthy?

Allar is my wildcard. As a bigger guy, it looks like he's built for the NFL game. If he really ends up in the 2nd round, I'd pounce if I were Miami. I think he probably sneaks into the 1st.

Ward and Milroe I'll have to spend more time on.
I would pass on him, because of the baggage that comes with (Deon) him.
 
Back
Top Bottom