#86 Booker or Gadsden? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

#86 Booker or Gadsden?

booker...gadsden had the better hands but booker can beat people deep.
 
Man, props for an original, great question in the main forum.

Seriously.

This is a brain-buster that I have to think about. They are both awesome. I love Booker's speed and hands, but you HAVE to love Oronde's route-running and hands. You could throw it 8 feet above the dude and he'd still catch it.

Good question. I gotta think about that one.
 
Right now playing opposite of Chambers in their prime? Gadsden, he seems like the perfect compliment IMO.
 
If you are talking about both of them in their prime I would have to take Booker, when he was with the Bears he was a legit number one pro bowl level receiver. Man I did love Gadsdens hands though.....
 
Booker without a doubt. I loved Gadsden back in the day, but Booker is the whole package. Don't forget that Booker throws a prettier pass than any QB this team had in the 21st Century other than Pepper.
 
DolphinDevil28 said:
Man, props for an original, great question in the main forum.

Seriously.

This is a brain-buster that I have to think about. They are both awesome. I love Booker's speed and hands, but you HAVE to love Oronde's route-running and hands. You could throw it 8 feet above the dude and he'd still catch it.

Good question. I gotta think about that one.
Click to expand...


Thanks DD, coming from you, its an honor.
 
Oronde. we'd have gone to the playoffs with him on our roster last year.


now before you crucify me listen...

you KNOW he would have come up with a bunch of those over, under, behind, in front of, throws that Frerotte threw, so i think that definetly would have resulted in at LEAST one more win.....Right?
 
Nick13 said:
Oronde. we'd have gone to the playoffs with him on our roster last year.


now before you crucify me listen...

you KNOW he would have come up with a bunch of those over, under, behind, in front of, throws that Frerotte threw, so i think that definetly would have resulted in at LEAST one more win.....Right?
Click to expand...

:shakeno:
 
Wow, this is interesting,U can argue for either.....I'm gonna give my "rating" opinion.

HANDS- Gadsden by far!!This guy has made some catches that make Chris Carter look average, Booker struggled earlier in the year with his hands but even if Booker had good hands..Oronde had great hands. ADV.Gadsden

SPEED- While I dont agree Booker is by any means fast,he still looks like a burner next to Gadsden.ADV.BOOKER

Route Running- This is the hardest for me to judge...Nobody was a better chain mover on 3rd down in Dolphins history than Gadsden...but Booker has more to offer as far as what he can-cant do..ADV.BOOKER

CLUTCH- Like I just said as far as 3rd down catches to move the chains no one was better, not to mention the Game Winners or(or 4th and 1's)ADV.GADSDEN

..heres my tiebreaker.hmmmmmmmmmm U cant ignore the fact Gadsden had Marino for a while and Booker had to suffer a year with Feeley...

..Booker is the better WR overall. Its not a "hands down" statement but Gadsden was just too 1 dimensional.
 
Nick13 said:
Oronde. we'd have gone to the playoffs with him on our roster last year.


now before you crucify me listen...

you KNOW he would have come up with a bunch of those over, under, behind, in front of, throws that Frerotte threw, so i think that definetly would have resulted in at LEAST one more win.....Right?
Click to expand...

I see what your saying but Booker made two huge plays for TD's vs Denver and S.D. that Gadsden could not have...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom