A Better Squad Next Season?

[rent this space]

Like Dan Marino?

I’m 51 yrs old and the “Killer B’s” hold a special place in my heart. I was a young kid when they were beating up offenses. YMMV… regardless, his jersey number shouldn’t trigger Dolphins fans. He’s one of the all-time great Dolphins.

yes, a much better choice, imo

 

[Marine-O]

I don’t see any improvements to change things

 

[PhinFan1968]

2 can play at this game:

While the Miami Dolphins have made notable offseason moves, their roster decisions raise concerns about whether they have genuinely positioned themselves for success in the 2025-2026 NFL season. Several key acquisitions and strategic areas remain questionable and could hinder their ability to compete at the highest level.

1. Questionable Quarterback Depth​

The addition of Zach Wilson as Tua Tagovailoa’s backup is not the upgrade Miami needed. Wilson struggled significantly during his tenure with the Jets, showcasing poor decision-making, inaccuracy, and an inability to handle pressure. His presence as a backup does little to solidify the quarterback position, particularly given Tua’s injury history. If Tagovailoa misses time, relying on Wilson could spell disaster for the Dolphins' offense.

2. Offensive Line Concerns Remain​

While the signings of James Daniels and Larry Borom appear to address offensive line issues, neither guarantees stability. Daniels is coming off a serious Achilles injury, which can significantly hinder a lineman’s mobility and effectiveness. Borom, while versatile, has yet to prove himself as a high-quality starter. Developing chemistry within the line takes time, and Miami still lacks an elite-caliber tackle to anchor protection for their quarterback.

3. Defensive Losses Outweigh Gains​

e-signing Elijah Campbell and adding Ifeatu Melifonwu do not compensate for the loss of Jevon Holland, a crucial playmaker in the Dolphins' secondary. While Campbell is a solid special teams player, he has yet to prove he can handle a full-time defensive role. Additionally, acquiring a depth piece like Bump Cooper Jr. off waivers does little to strengthen the secondary against elite AFC quarterbacks. Without a proven difference-maker in the defensive backfield, the Dolphins may struggle against high-powered passing offenses.

4. No True Game-Changer Acquisitions​

Despite multiple signings, none of Miami’s offseason additions represent a major game-changer. Their roster moves have focused on depth rather than impact players. In a competitive AFC where teams like the Chiefs, Ravens, and Bengals continue to stack elite talent, Miami’s approach feels more like patchwork rather than a legitimate push toward Super Bowl contention.

5. Coaching and Strategy Limitations​

While coaching remains a crucial factor, the Dolphins’ success is ultimately dictated by talent on the field. Even the best coaching staff cannot compensate for weaknesses in quarterback depth, an uncertain offensive line, and a defense that lacks elite playmakers. Unless Miami overhauls its offensive scheme to minimize risks and maximizes defensive efficiency, they may once again fall short in the postseason.

Conclusion​

The Dolphins' offseason moves indicate an attempt to improve, but they have yet to address the key concerns that plagued them last season. The reliance on an injury-prone quarterback, a shaky offensive line, and an unproven defensive secondary makes it difficult to confidently say Miami is a serious contender. While they may still compete for a playoff spot, expecting them to make a deep postseason run with these acquisitions seems overly optimistic.

Even AI has more of a clue than the goggles squad. "Miami's approach feels more like patchwork rather than a legitimate push toward Super Bowl contention." Just music, right there.

I like how the AI left the Bills off the "competitive AFC teams" list hahahaha.

 

[rent this space]

Even AI has more of a clue than the goggles squad. "Miami's approach feels more like patchwork rather than a legitimate push toward Super Bowl contention." Just music, right there.

I like how the AI left the Bills off the "competitive AFC teams" list hahahaha.

AI left out the Bills but it has a clue?

 

[PhinFan1968]

AI left out the Bills but it has a clue?

Proof you can be 25% wrong overall and still realize this team sucks...there's hope for everybody.

 

[Highzenga]

It’s not.

What did we lose?

I guess Campbell if he doesn’t resign but it’s a super deep DT draft.

Sure lost both safeties but does that matter? We had one of if not the worst graded safety duo’s and still finished as a borderline top 10 defense. We didn’t sign two superstars however it’d be difficult for them to be worse.

Same with guard. Eich and Jones were the worst graded guard duo’s and we already improved on one spot with James Daniels who if he comes back healthy is an upper echelon guard. If he’s not 100% I’m still pretty sure even if he gets both legs amputated, his stump would still be an improvement over Eich.

Sure we need a linebacker but didn’t really have one last year. Dodson would be nice to resign but he didn’t play most of the year anyways.

Yeah there’s a hole at corner but fuller left like 3 games early so he only played like 11 total games anyways. Asante Samuel would be a gift if they spend one big signing we’ll see what they do there.

The biggest additions and most impactful on the season were already on the roster and that’s getting Tua/Chubb and Phillips back. Can they play a whole season? Who knows but those are the additions that will make the difference whether we are good or not this year.

Thank you for talking me off the ledge

 

[BSQ]

The soft practices are backfiring on McD. In an effort to keep guys healthier he is putting players out on the field that aren't really ready to go. When they get hit it's something they're not used to which is crazy. Have much more physical practices and you'll see a much more physical team on game day. The overall effect will be a healthier and more powerful team. Also, the team will be more prepared coming out in the first quarter. This team should stop playing from behind all the time. I don't think it's our strategy but it seems like we're always chasing teams in the second half. I'd switch up the mindset to be a run first team behind a huge oline with great backs. Use the run to set up play action. Use clock, have long drives that keeps opposing offenses sitting on the bench. The better we run the ball the easier it becomes to pass.
We got a few oline pieces but in this draft it better be all about the trenches. They have been avoided for far too long. We'll go as far as our new oline takes us. We have to nail it big time in this draft, no more Eichenbergs!!I would do the baddest oline guy on the board at 13, bring in a monster, unless Warren TE. Penn State drops too us. This guy has unlimited upside and could upgrade our entire offense! I love the player!! Short of that, oline all the way!!

 

[Jamesw]

Lol...... Not by me. I actually have a sense of humor.

You’re a good Mod. Appreciate what you do.

 

[Buff]

On injury management I think that comes down, oddly enough, to more physical practices. This one is up do McDaniel and the coaching staff IMHO.

Great points, OP. I really like the Daniels signing. That takes the pressure off overdrafting an offensive lineman early.

Overdrafting an OL at pick 13 - the draft is stacked with quality O linemen, and the 12 teams ahead of Miami do not all need an O lineman. I think there is virtually zero chance of over drafting an Oliner this year with pick 13.

 

[Buff]

This is looking like a far worse roster in reality. Unless Tua can carry us on his shoulders, this may end up as a top 5 pick season.

How is it looking worse?

Hollands play had regressed and fans wanted him gone, so maybe the Detroit safety may not be as good, but is he that much worse than Holland?
James Daniels at L or R Guard is an upgrade over Eich.
We picked up a WR that had a breakout year last year, and if he isnt better that Berrios/OBJ/ or any other WR on the team then I call BS.
Wilson may not be great, but we saw how bad our backups were last year. I dont expect him to play much anyways.

 

[AMakados10]

Lol..... It beats the hell out of random, biased, semi-literate, incoherent twatters.......

Just saying......

Not for me. I appreciate original thoughts regardless if I agree with them or not. To me, that’s the whole point of engaging on a forum with other people.

If this place becomes bot thread central, I don’t see the point of coming. I’ll just use my AI apps instead.

 

[Mach2]

Not for me. I appreciate original thoughts regardless if I agree with them or not. To me, that’s the whole point of engaging on a forum with other people.

If this place becomes bot thread central, I don’t see the point of coming. I’ll just use my AI apps instead.

Meh.

As a thread premise I don't see a big issue. It's not like the discussion would be back and forth AI responses.

Over 70 posts and all have been "human" opinions and observations.

Sure, one can point out the downside if taken to the extreme. I can't envision it coming to that point.

 

[JamesWsenior]

Meh.

As a thread premise I don't see a big issue. It's not like the discussion would be back and forth AI responses.

Over 70 posts and all have been "human" opinions and observations.

Sure, one can point out the downside if taken to the extreme. I can't envision it coming to that point.

Let's just get Chad Bots vs Grier Bots and have a grammatical feast of perfection.

Absolutely could not think of anything more boring.

Chatbots are perfect example of geeks thinking ppl actually wanna chat with a computer. Right HAL?

 

[Ray R]

The Miami Dolphins have been proactive in enhancing their roster for the 2025-2026 NFL season. Key offseason moves include:

Quarterback Acquisition: The Dolphins signed former New York Jets quarterback Zach Wilson to a one-year, $6 million contract, potentially increasing to $10 million with incentives. Wilson, drafted second overall in 2021, aims to provide experienced backup for Tua Tagovailoa, who faced injury challenges last season.

Offensive Line Improvements: To strengthen their offensive line, Miami added guard James Daniels and tackle Larry Borom. Daniels, despite an Achilles injury, is considered a significant upgrade, while Borom's versatility offers depth across multiple positions.

Defensive Reinforcement: The team re-signed safety Elijah Campbell to a one-year, $1.9 million contract. Campbell has been a valuable special teams player and has the potential to step into a larger defensive role, especially with the departure of Jevon Holland.

Additional Roster Moves: The Dolphins signed offensive tackle Braeden Daniels, aiming to bolster their offensive line depth. They also claimed cornerback Bump Cooper Jr. off waivers, adding depth to their secondary. Additionally, nose tackle Neil Farrell Jr., a Super Bowl LVIII champion with the Kansas City Chiefs, joined Miami, bringing valuable experience to the defensive front.

Ifeatu Melifonwu is a 25-year-old safety who signed a one-year, $4 million contract with the Miami Dolphins in March 2025.

To further improve their performance in the upcoming season, the Dolphins should focus on:

1. Injury Management: Ensuring key players maintain optimal health, particularly Tua Tagovailoa, to enhance offensive consistency.

2. Offensive Line Cohesion: Developing chemistry among the new and existing offensive linemen to provide better protection and establish a robust running game.

3. Defensive Depth: Integrating new defensive acquisitions effectively to strengthen the pass rush and secondary coverage.

4. Coaching and Strategy: Leveraging coaching expertise to optimize player talents and implement effective game strategies.

By addressing these areas, the Dolphins can position themselves for a successful 2025-2026 season.

BINGO!!!

 

[Ray R]

Umm...free agency isn't over yet

Better and better. - LOL