A look at the Free Agent Gaurds | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

A look at the Free Agent Gaurds

MrChadRico

☠️ Banned ☠️
Super Donator
Joined
Aug 18, 2018
Messages
14,869
Reaction score
33,369
Age
41
Location
Kansas
With many posters not wanting to draft a Gaurd in round 1, I thought this was a good time to actually look at who's available in Free agency. Remember, we need both RG and LG. Please add more gaurds and a little write up on any others I left out if you think they are worth talking about.



G - Will Fries - 6'6" 305 pounds - coming off injury - Since Week 9 of the 2022 season, Fries has been the starting right guard for the Colts. He has grown exponentially each season since being drafted in the 7th round of the 2021 draft, peaking in 2024 as Pro Football Focus' top-graded right guard in the league (through the first five weeks). He suffered a fractured ankle in Week 5 of the season.

As a run blocker, Fries showcases a devastating mean streak with an ability to finish plays. He is a people mover on combo blocks and he has the athleticism to get to the second level and wash out linebackers attempting to read the play. His style of play fits perfectly with how the Dolphins design their zone blocking scheme with his impressive blend of power and athleticism.

Rumor is the Colts will try to resign him.

* https://www.si.com/nfl/colts/news/colts-internal-free-agent-profiles-will-fries




G- Teven Jenkins - 6'6" 321 lbs. - Drafted as a tackle, Teven Jenkins has made a solid transition inside to guard. He turns 27 in March, so he has the youth that teams want when signing free agents. He has missed time with injuries, including three games last season, but he has 40 starts in his career.

Chicago Bears left guard Teven Jenkins is undeniably talented. He's a downright nasty bully in the run game and has been one of the Bears' better starting offensive linemen over the last four years (when he's been healthy.) Unfortunately, he hasn't been healthy all that often. Bears are not expecting to offer him a new contract.




G - Kevin Zeitler - 6'4" 315 lbs. 34, so hes old but played at nearly and all-pro level in 2024. The 12-year veteran went to Detroit last offseason, with the reputation of being an iron man, playing over 1,000 snaps in all but three of his NFL seasons—and primarily doing so at right guard.

He had been one of the most consistently great guards in the NFL for a decade, the Lions may be looking to resign him and he also might want to play for a legit contender so the likleyhood of the Dolphins getting him is rather low.




G- James Daniels - 6'4 336 lbs. 27 yrs old - Steelers OG James Daniels is set to enter free agency without a contract extension after an injury-plagued season. At 27 years old, with seven years of NFL experience—including three with the Steelers—his injury history raises concerns about his market value. The Steelers have indicated they plan to move on.

On his first 209 snaps of the 2024 season before suffering the Achilles injury, Daniels was the number-one graded guard in the NFL—earning an outstanding 92.9 overall grade from Pro Football Focus. The Steelers offensive lineman was on the fast track to a massive payday during the 2025 offseason.




G- Mekhi Becton - 6'7" 364 lbs. - A huge human. Becton is just 25-years old (will be 26 in April) with experience at both guard and tackle. He has shown he can play guard at a relatively high level. The stats for Becton might not be great - 26 hurries/5 sacks allowed; graded 54th out of 80 OGs — but there is no question his first year at guard was a big success.

ESPN's Adam Schefter said the following about where things stand between Becton and the Eagles:

"Mekhi Becton found a home in Philadelphia, and he chose to go to Philadelphia in large part because he believed that [Eagles offensive line coach] Jeff Stoutland would help rebuild his career, and that's exactly what happened. Now, he can go out and seek greener pastures elsewhere, or he and the Eagles could work out a fair deal where he could continue to thrive. So, I think Mekhi Becton is going to be inclined to stay."




G- Brandon Scherff - 33, 6'5" 315 lbs. - guard for the Jacksonville Jaguars, is a free agent in 2025. He is considered a top free agent and a reliable starter. Scherff was drafted by the Washington Redskins in the first round of the 2015 NFL draft.

He played for the Redskins for seven seasons and was selected to five Pro Bowls. Scherff has been a reliable presence for the Jaguars, starting all 51 regular season games during his three-year contract. He has been particularly good in pass protection. Scherff is considered a very capable starter, particularly in pass protection.



G - Patrick Mekari - 6'4" 305, 27 - Mekari is a former undrafted free agent who has played all five positions on the offensive line for the Baltimore Ravens He's a solid player who's never been an All-Pro or Pro Bowler. In 2024, he played nearly every down at left guard Mekari's versatility and ability to play anywhere on the offensive line make him a valuable player. He's a good value for the price and could be a valuable addition to another team



G - Aaron Banks - 6'5" 327, 27 - Aaron Banks will be an unrestricted free agent this offseason and the 49ers probably won't re-sign him. That's because he was highly inconsistent during the past three seasons as the starting left guard. And yet, he still could have a significant market. Banks moves very well in the run game for his size, which is presumably what made him most attractive to the 49ers in the first place, but still has room to grow in pass protection.
 
I think Scherff might offer us the best value.

I like that he hasn't missed a game in the last 3 years.

He is very good in pass protection. We throw the ball more than we run it.

Due to his age 33 he probably won't cost much.

My original FA Target was Mekari but he might be out of our price range.

Most of the other FA OG's have either been frequently injured and or will be expensive.

Then draft an OG in round 2. Milum would be my first choice because of his ability to play LT. Jackson or Mbow could be other good options too.
 
Probably can’t afford Jenkins, Becton isn’t really a scheme fit and while the older guys like are interesting stop gaps, that’s all they are. I’d rather commit that money to someone we’ll get 3-4 years out of as I think both will still command 8-10 million.

That leaves Banks, Daniels, fries and Mekari and that’s probably the order I’d want them in. Happy with either and then I bring back Wynn and still drafting a guard with one of the top 2 picks we have.
 
Probably can’t afford Jenkins, Becton isn’t really a scheme fit and while the older guys like are interesting stop gaps, that’s all they are. I’d rather commit that money to someone we’ll get 3-4 years out of as I think both will still command 8-10 million.

That leaves Banks, Daniels, fries and Mekari and that’s probably the order I’d want them in. Happy with either and then I bring back Wynn and still drafting a guard with one of the top 2 picks we have.
Fries is my #1, not crazy about anyone else to be honest.

*edit - i love Becton but we won't take him, hes too big, McDaneil and Grier like small quick guards.
 
Fries is my #1, not crazy about anyone else to be honest.

*edit - i love Becton but we won't take him, hes too big, McDaneil and Grier like small quick guards.
not crazy about any of the others myself other than Fries but we'll have to compete for him which will make it hard since most teams in the NFL have more cap space than us
 
not crazy about any of the others myself other than Fries but we'll have to compete for him which will make it hard since most teams in the NFL have more cap space than us
Yea, I've been saying it all year, fixing the Oline isn't as easy as everyone seems to think it is. There isn't a plethora of talent available. And were also counting on Jackson, who's had 1 good season in 5 years and gets hurt alot and Paul who's a complete unknown.

We could get 2 decent gaurds and end up having tackle issues.
 
Kind of between a rock and a hard place situation here. I don't love the FA market ... guard isn't deep and those guys are gonna get paid. Fries will be back with the Colts. I'd talk to Scherff and Zeitler ... at least they'll be healthy and consistent for a season while being age affordable.

I also dislike trusting Grier to find one or 2 in the draft ... especially with high picks which could be better used on virtually every level of the D. I'd prefer to wait and pick 1 or 2 late but his hit % after the 2nd rd is virtually zero ... so it's draft 1 early or not at all.

I'd trade back as much as it made sense to do so with willing partners. Get as many 2nd-5th rd picks as possible and fill out the roster. Looks like a deep G draft and tons of starters will be picked in those rounds.
 
Yea, I've been saying it all year, fixing the Oline isn't as easy as everyone seems to think it is. There isn't a plethora of talent available. And were also counting on Jackson, who's had 1 good season in 5 years and gets hurt alot and Paul who's a complete unknown.

We could get 2 decent gaurds and end up having tackle issues.
that's why regardless of who we might get in free agency we still need to draft OL as well
 
that's why regardless of who we might get in free agency we still need to draft OL as well
It is hard to drive this point home to people who want to draft skill positions with every pick. Jackson has a lengthy injury history and two years left on his extension. One more serious injury and we could easily be looking to cut him next offseason as it would free up $13M in cap space for 2026.

If Armstead retires it is basically a total reset on the OL. Brewers and Jackson are on 2 year contracts and we have no guards. Paul is the only player we have signed for the next 3 years.
 
Will Hernandez is another option who should be extremely feasible and provide the toughness on the OL that we've lacked for quite some time now. He is also great in Pass Pro. I think this one makes a ton of sense and prefer it to happen as the "weaker" of the 2 Guard signings I anticipate. Will Hernandez and James Daniels/Patrick Mekari would excellent. Bringing back Isaiah Wynn on a cheap deal would be good for me too.

Potential Cap Casualties/Trade Candidates due to contract
Alex Cappa - CIN
Joel Bitonio - CLE
Jack Conklin - CLE
Wyatt Teller - CLE
Jonah Williams - ARZ
Joe Thuney - KC
Andre James - LV
Garrett Bradbury - MIN
Ed Ingram - MIN
Ryan Bates - CHI
Shaq Mason - HOU
Braden Smith - IND
Jermaine Eluemanor - NYG
Andrew Wylie - WAS
 
Fries is my #1, not crazy about anyone else to be honest.

*edit - i love Becton but we won't take him, hes too big, McDaneil and Grier like small quick guards.
Such as who? Rob Hunt, who they tried to re-sign?
 
Such as who? Rob Hunt, who they tried to re-sign?
Hunt was drafted to be a Tackle, the zone scheme they run relys on quick footed gaurds. Everyone knows this. EVERYONE. Becton is a mammoth of a person, he isn't your protoypical zone blocking gaurd.

Again, you know this. Your just mad at me becuase I'm not waving the pom-poms for your idol Tua.
 
Back
Top Bottom