lets say Leinart is gone, we dont trade our pick and J Williams, Ngata and AJ/Brooks/Greenway are on the board. Who do you see us taking? personally i'd take AJ/Brooks/greenway or ngata n Pass on J. Williams as they say he is a very good CB but can play S/CB but thing is, he will stay a good CB not great.
a Must Pick u take...
- Thread starter SweepeR
- Start date
I pass on Jimmy Williams because even though its a need position i really don't see williams having the athleticism of recent high picked cb's (newman, hall, robinson) i rate all 3 linebackers very highly and i think a few things would weigh on sabans mind (is seau coming back, how many more years can zach go for, whos available in FA (peterson, arrington)) I really think we can't go wrong with any of the linebackers or Ngata and would be thrilled if we picked any of them
Al13
Don´t mess with Clint
i think it really doesn´t matter if seau is coming back, we need a replacement for him even if he stays, because he is getting injured on a regular basis now
why de when we have bigger needs? i think we can address taht next year or so. Ngata and AJ/green/brooks woudl be GREAT picks but i say we go Ngata or a LB if we STILL pick up Peterson. Im feelin NGata a lot due to him being another once in a decade type or prospect according to ppl/scouts. with a Run stopper like that, the D can fall into place slowly as well and i should expect many more sacks from KC and JT and more room for CC/peterson/and Z Thomas especialy to kamikaze in the hole.
Enforcerfin33
Los Lonely Boys the Return....
lol.....well god he's older than some of the coaches man!!!Al13 said:
DolphinsRising
Yankee Hater
- Joined
- Apr 25, 2005
- Messages
- 264
- Reaction score
- 0
Greenway. Using a top 10 pick on a DT/NT is a waste.
fishypete
FinHeaven Elite
You take the best talented player available regardless of their position.
DBoston80
Undisputed #1
Greenway is a mid 1st rounder..If thats the direction we go in..we need to trade down and pick up some more picks, personnally I would take Hawk.
RonnieB23
Starter
U think Saban's gonna pass on J. William after blasting his secondary for the lack of tackling, U guys are crazy. If i was a betting man, my money would go on Williams for next year draft.
musphinzfan
Pro Bowler
- Joined
- Dec 29, 2003
- Messages
- 1,514
- Reaction score
- 0
RonnieB23 said:
Good possibility....Only thing is Jimmy williams will move to FS...Best tackler in the draft for a CB/FS.
Canadi-Phin
I hate everyone else in the AFC East
The more I read about Brooks the more I like him. He is a freak, he's huge and fast. Same with Greenway, very big LB, This is what Saban likes, Hawk is very talented but not sure if he fits the size of LB that Saban likes. Zach has done great in the scheme and I think Hawk would do well but if he wants size I think he looks at the other two. Ngata is a beast. I've read he tore his ACL two years ago and is only starting to fully recover, that's incredible cause he has played like a beast. He would help shape our D for years. Having a game changing guy at nose tackle would be ahuge plus especially if you can leave him in on passing downs and he can still get pressure. Look at the plays Traylor has made for this team. He has helped on tons of Short yardage situations. But having a 23 year old beast for ten years would be nice. Williams is a very talented Db, I would love to have him. he hits like a truck and is very fast. I would be very happy with any of the 5 players above but I think if Ngata is everything that he has been hyped up to be then we take him. NT are very hard to find in this league, finding great ones is near impossible. Our Defense starts up front and he would allow Wright to play along side him with his quickness and we could pressure the QB all day. This is very deep LB class and could get quality down the line. I also think we could pick up talented CB in the later rounds, Zemetis of Penn State in the 2nd or 3rd. Ngata would be my choice but we will have to wait until Prodays and th combine to see wha these guy are really made of.