EDITED TO MAKE REVISIONS VOICED. LET'S SEE HOW IT DOES NOW.
I asked Grok for a 7-round mock draft for our Miami Dolphins, focusing on our needs and demanding players who’d crawl through broken glass—grinders with elite toughness, film study, and leadership. With Raheem Mostert now gone, our RB room is thinner, relying on De’Von Achane and Jaylen Wright. This revised mock fixes errors about Kelvin Banks Jr., Jahdae Barron, Carson Schwesinger, and the punter signing, and explains why Cam Skattebo, the draft’s toughest player, still didn’t make the cut despite the RB need. Let’s see if this builds a physical, AFC East-ready roster.
Methodology
Revised 7-Round Mock Draft
Round 1, Pick 13: JAHDAE BARRON, CB, TEXAS
Correction: KELVIN BANKS JR. HAS NOT PLAYED GUARD AND IS PROJECTED AS A TACKLE. The original mock listed Banks as a guard with 34 starts—wrong. Banks, a Texas OT, has 42 starts at left tackle, no guard experience (PFF, NFL Draft Buzz). He’s a top-10 tackle prospect, often gone by 13 (Daniel Jeremiah, USA TODAY). We need a guard, not a tackle, with Patrick Paul developing behind Terron Armstead (maybe retiring post-2025).
Why Barron? Barron’s a first-round stud (15-25, PFF, Mel Kiper), ideal at 13. His 2024 stats (47 tackles, 4 INTs, 90.7 PFF coverage grade) show playmaking, but his slot/outside physicality is key. Post-Kendall Fuller, we need a CB2 for Jalen Ramsey.
Correction: JAHDAE BARRON IS A FIRST-ROUND PROSPECT, NOT ROUND 3. Barron was mocked at 98—mistake. His first-round stock moved him to 13, shifting Xavier Watts (safety) to Round 3 to grab a guard, our top need post-Robert Hunt.
Why Booker? Booker (15-20, PFF, NFL Draft Buzz) is a steal at 48 due to a deep CB/DT class. His 2024 stats (80.7 PFF run-blocking, no sacks allowed) and wrestling background make him a mauler for our weak O-line (28th pass block win rate).
Why Watts? Watts (45-60, PFF) slides to 98 after prioritizing guard. His 2024 stats (52 tackles, 4 INTs) are solid, but his hard-hitting style shines. Post-Jevon Holland, he battles Ifeatu Melifonwu for safety.
Round 4, Pick 135: ORONDE GADSDEN II, TE, SYRACUSE
Why Gadsden? Gadsden (130-150, NFL Draft Buzz) is a TE2 behind Jonnu Smith. His 2024 stats (45 catches, 600 yds) were limited by Syracuse’s QB, but his catches and blocking pop.
Correction: CARSON SCHWESINGER PROJECTED EARLIER THAN ROUND 7. Originally at 224, his 2024 stats (104 tackles, 4.5 sacks) place him at 120-160 (PFF), Rounds 4-5 (The Athletic).
Why Schwesinger? Schwesinger bolsters LB depth behind David Long Jr./Anthony Walker Jr. His play-chasing and special-teams upside shine.
Why Atkins? Atkins (150-170, PFF) adds guard depth. His 2024 stats (80.5 PFF pass-blocking) and run-blocking tenacity stand out.
Why Hall? Hall (140-160, NFL Draft Buzz) adds edge depth behind Jaelan Phillips/Bradley Chubb. His 2024 stats (4 sacks, 28 tackles) are modest, but his edge-setting effort shines.
Correction: MIAMI SIGNED A PUNTER, TAYLOR UNNEEDED. Taylor was replaced with Catalon to address safety depth.
Why Catalon? Catalon (220-240, NFL Draft Buzz) adds safety depth. His 2024 stats (48 tackles, 3 INTs) and physicality stand out.
Change: WITH MOSTERT GONE, ADDED RB DEPTH. Instead of Ko’o Kia (DT), we draft Kaliq Brown to bolster the RB room behind Achane and Wright, prioritizing a tough, complementary back over additional DT depth, as Sieler/Dennis suffice for now.
Why Brown? Brown (240-260, NFL Draft Buzz) is a late-round gem. His 2024 stats (1,200 yds, 12 TDs, 5.8 yds/carry) show productivity, but his physical running and pass-blocking stand out.
Why Cam Skattebo Was Not Selected
Skattebo’s Toughness:
Skattebo (5-11, 215 lbs) is the draft’s toughest player. In 2024, he ran for 1,664 yards, 19 TDs (6.3 yds/carry), caught 37 passes for 506 yards, 2 TDs, and threw a TD pass (PFF). His 87.9 PFF run grade, 4.1 yds after contact, and 9.2% broken tackle rate show power. Bleacher Report calls him a “human battering ram.” NFL Draft Buzz praises his pass-blocking (80.2 PFF) and kick-returning. ESPN’s Matt Miller notes his “blue-collar mentality,” playing through an ankle injury. Coach Kenny Dillingham calls him “our heart” (Yahoo Sports). His Senior Bowl dominance screams grit.
Why Not Skattebo?
Discussion
This mock delivers your “broken glass” vision with tough, film-obsessed leaders. Strengths:
I asked Grok for a 7-round mock draft for our Miami Dolphins, focusing on our needs and demanding players who’d crawl through broken glass—grinders with elite toughness, film study, and leadership. With Raheem Mostert now gone, our RB room is thinner, relying on De’Von Achane and Jaylen Wright. This revised mock fixes errors about Kelvin Banks Jr., Jahdae Barron, Carson Schwesinger, and the punter signing, and explains why Cam Skattebo, the draft’s toughest player, still didn’t make the cut despite the RB need. Let’s see if this builds a physical, AFC East-ready roster.
Methodology
- Availability Check: Players are picked using 2025 NFL Draft big boards (PFF, NFL Draft Buzz, ESPN, The Athletic), with rankings matching pick ranges (e.g., Pick 13: ~10-20; Round 7: 200+ or UDFA), verified via NFL Mock Draft Database and April 2025 mocks.
- Toughness Criteria: We want players with proven physicality, work ethic, and leadership—extra film study, playing through pain, finishing plays. Scouting reports (PFF, NFL Draft Buzz, ESPN) and coach quotes confirm high-motor traits.
- Team Fit: Picks target Miami’s 2024 roster needs (per ESPN, PFF): guard (post-Robert Hunt), cornerback (post-Kendall Fuller), safety (post-Jevon Holland), defensive tackle (post-Calais Campbell), and TE2 (behind Jonnu Smith). Edge and linebacker depth adds physicality around Tua Tagovailoa. With a punter signed, we focus on safety and edge. Running back depth is now a consideration with Mostert gone, but Achane and Wright remain the core, so RB isn’t a top priority.
- Sources: Rankings and toughness come from PFF’s 2025 big board, NFL Draft Buzz, The Athletic, ESPN, Senior Bowl reports, Yahoo Sports, and Bleacher Report, backed by film analysis and coach testimonials.
Revised 7-Round Mock Draft
Round 1, Pick 13: JAHDAE BARRON, CB, TEXAS
Correction: KELVIN BANKS JR. HAS NOT PLAYED GUARD AND IS PROJECTED AS A TACKLE. The original mock listed Banks as a guard with 34 starts—wrong. Banks, a Texas OT, has 42 starts at left tackle, no guard experience (PFF, NFL Draft Buzz). He’s a top-10 tackle prospect, often gone by 13 (Daniel Jeremiah, USA TODAY). We need a guard, not a tackle, with Patrick Paul developing behind Terron Armstead (maybe retiring post-2025).
Why Barron? Barron’s a first-round stud (15-25, PFF, Mel Kiper), ideal at 13. His 2024 stats (47 tackles, 4 INTs, 90.7 PFF coverage grade) show playmaking, but his slot/outside physicality is key. Post-Kendall Fuller, we need a CB2 for Jalen Ramsey.
- Toughness Factor: Barron’s 8.2% missed tackle rate and “dog mentality” (The Athletic) shine. A captain, he dominates press coverage and sets the tone.
- Team Fit: Our secondary struggled in 2024 (24th, 238.6 yds/g). Kohou’s slot-bound, and Cam Smith/Ethan Bonner aren’t ready. Barron’s versatility fits Anthony Weaver’s aggressive scheme.
- Availability: Barron’s 15-25 range (65% of mocks, NFL.com, PFF) fits 13, with top tackles and QBs (Shedeur Sanders) gone.
Correction: JAHDAE BARRON IS A FIRST-ROUND PROSPECT, NOT ROUND 3. Barron was mocked at 98—mistake. His first-round stock moved him to 13, shifting Xavier Watts (safety) to Round 3 to grab a guard, our top need post-Robert Hunt.
Why Booker? Booker (15-20, PFF, NFL Draft Buzz) is a steal at 48 due to a deep CB/DT class. His 2024 stats (80.7 PFF run-blocking, no sacks allowed) and wrestling background make him a mauler for our weak O-line (28th pass block win rate).
- Toughness Factor: ESPN’s “nasty streak” fits—Booker pancakes defenders, finishes blocks, and lives in the film room. As Alabama’s line anchor, he’s a leader.
- Team Fit: Liam Eichenberg (55.5 PFF grade) and Robert Jones (51.8 pass-blocking) let Tua get sacked 34 times. Booker starts at guard, pairs with James Daniels, and boosts Achane/Wright’s run game.
- Availability: Booker’s top-20 rank fits 48, sliding due to tackle-heavy boards (NFL.com).
Why Watts? Watts (45-60, PFF) slides to 98 after prioritizing guard. His 2024 stats (52 tackles, 4 INTs) are solid, but his hard-hitting style shines. Post-Jevon Holland, he battles Ifeatu Melifonwu for safety.
- Toughness Factor: Watts hits like a linebacker (10.5% missed tackle rate), obsesses over film, and rallies Notre Dame’s defense (PFF). Pure grit.
- Team Fit: Our safeties lack physicality with Poyer (33) aging. The secondary allowed 6.8 yds/attempt (22nd). Watts’ box/deep versatility fits Weaver’s scheme.
- Availability: Watts’ 40-60 range aligns with 98, with top safeties (Malaki Starks) gone.
- Toughness Factor: West’s high-effort play (80.5 PFF run-defense grade) and diving tackles show relentless motor, outworking blockers.
- Team Fit: Miami’s D-line (20th, 128.4 yds/g) needs depth due to Calais Campbell's departure. West’s run-stopping complements Sieler’s pass rush.
- Availability: West’s 100-150 range fits 116 (PFF, The Athletic).
Round 4, Pick 135: ORONDE GADSDEN II, TE, SYRACUSE
Why Gadsden? Gadsden (130-150, NFL Draft Buzz) is a TE2 behind Jonnu Smith. His 2024 stats (45 catches, 600 yds) were limited by Syracuse’s QB, but his catches and blocking pop.
- Toughness Factor: Gadsden’s physicality and film-study habits make him a grinder. His Dolphins legacy (dad Oronde Gadsden) adds drive.
- Team Fit: Our TEs (42 receptions) need a pass-catcher. Gadsden’s 6-5, 235-lb frame is a red-zone weapon for Tua.
- Availability: Gadsden’s 130-150 range fits 135 (PFF, ESPN).
Correction: CARSON SCHWESINGER PROJECTED EARLIER THAN ROUND 7. Originally at 224, his 2024 stats (104 tackles, 4.5 sacks) place him at 120-160 (PFF), Rounds 4-5 (The Athletic).
Why Schwesinger? Schwesinger bolsters LB depth behind David Long Jr./Anthony Walker Jr. His play-chasing and special-teams upside shine.
- Toughness Factor: Schwesinger’s 7.8% missed tackle rate and block-shedding (ESPN) show relentless effort, outworking UCLA’s defense.
- Team Fit: Our LBs (25th run defense EPA) need depth with Walker on a one-year deal. Schwesinger adds versatility.
- Availability: His 120-160 range fits 150.
Why Atkins? Atkins (150-170, PFF) adds guard depth. His 2024 stats (80.5 PFF pass-blocking) and run-blocking tenacity stand out.
- Toughness Factor: Atkins’ aggressive blocking and play-finishing mentality (PFF) make him a grinder.
- Team Fit: Guard depth is key post-Hunt, with Eichenberg/Jones inconsistent. Atkins offers upside.
- Availability: His 150-170 range fits 155.
Why Hall? Hall (140-160, NFL Draft Buzz) adds edge depth behind Jaelan Phillips/Bradley Chubb. His 2024 stats (4 sacks, 28 tackles) are modest, but his edge-setting effort shines.
- Toughness Factor: Hall’s non-stop motor (NFL Draft Buzz) outworks Baylor’s line.
- Team Fit: Edge depth is needed post-Phillips’ injury. Hall aids run defense.
- Availability: His Round 6-7 stock fits 224 (ESPN).
Correction: MIAMI SIGNED A PUNTER, TAYLOR UNNEEDED. Taylor was replaced with Catalon to address safety depth.
Why Catalon? Catalon (220-240, NFL Draft Buzz) adds safety depth. His 2024 stats (48 tackles, 3 INTs) and physicality stand out.
- Toughness Factor: Catalon’s 9.1% missed tackle rate and film study (NFL Draft Buzz) show grit, playing through past injuries.
- Team Fit: Safety depth is needed post-Holland with Poyer aging. Catalon’s box-safety role fits Weaver’s scheme.
- Availability: His 220-240 range fits 231 (PFF).
Change: WITH MOSTERT GONE, ADDED RB DEPTH. Instead of Ko’o Kia (DT), we draft Kaliq Brown to bolster the RB room behind Achane and Wright, prioritizing a tough, complementary back over additional DT depth, as Sieler/Dennis suffice for now.
Why Brown? Brown (240-260, NFL Draft Buzz) is a late-round gem. His 2024 stats (1,200 yds, 12 TDs, 5.8 yds/carry) show productivity, but his physical running and pass-blocking stand out.
- Toughness Factor: Brown’s 8.5% broken tackle rate and relentless style (NFL Draft Buzz) make him a grinder, fighting for extra yards and excelling in pass protection.
- Team Fit: With Mostert gone, Achane (speed) and Wright (developing) need a physical RB3. Brown’s power complements McDaniel’s scheme, adding depth for injury-prone Achane.
- Availability: Brown’s Round 7/UDFA range fits 253 (PFF, ESPN).
Why Cam Skattebo Was Not Selected
Skattebo’s Toughness:
Skattebo (5-11, 215 lbs) is the draft’s toughest player. In 2024, he ran for 1,664 yards, 19 TDs (6.3 yds/carry), caught 37 passes for 506 yards, 2 TDs, and threw a TD pass (PFF). His 87.9 PFF run grade, 4.1 yds after contact, and 9.2% broken tackle rate show power. Bleacher Report calls him a “human battering ram.” NFL Draft Buzz praises his pass-blocking (80.2 PFF) and kick-returning. ESPN’s Matt Miller notes his “blue-collar mentality,” playing through an ankle injury. Coach Kenny Dillingham calls him “our heart” (Yahoo Sports). His Senior Bowl dominance screams grit.
Why Not Skattebo?
- RB Still Not a Top Need: Even with Mostert gone, Achane (1,087 yds, 8.2 yds/carry) and Wright (rookie upside) form a strong duo. ESPN/PFF prioritize guard, CB, safety, DT, TE2 over RB, as O-line (28th pass block win rate) and secondary (24th pass defense) are critical. Brown in Round 7 addresses RB depth without sacrificing early picks.
- Draft Value: RBs are devalued; only Ashton Jeanty is a Round 1 prospect (NFL.com). Skattebo (70-100, PFF) goes in Rounds 3-4 (e.g., No. 85 Colts, Bleacher Report). Picks 13/48 hit CB/guard; by 98, he’s gone. Early RB picks would skip bigger needs.
- Scheme Mismatch: McDaniel’s outside-zone scheme favors Achane’s 4.32 speed and Wright’s burst. Skattebo’s power style (4.58 40, NFL Draft Buzz) fits gap schemes (Steelers). Brown’s 5.8 yds/carry better aligns with Miami’s speed-based runs.
- Toughness Elsewhere: Barron’s “dog mentality,” Booker’s “nasty streak,” Watts’ hits, Dennis’ hustle, and Gadsden’s physicality match Skattebo’s grit at key spots. Brown’s late-round toughness (8.5% broken tackle rate) adds RB depth without losing focus.
- Workload Concerns: Skattebo’s 468 touches (2022-24) raise durability flags for his 215-lb frame (Yahoo Sports). Miami prefers less-worn players (Booker, Watts) or late-round RBs like Brown with lighter workloads.
- Availability: Skattebo’s Round 3-4 projection (e.g., No. 92 Eagles, PFF) means he’s gone by 98. Trading up sacrifices depth for guard, DT, or safety. Brown’s availability at 253 fits better.
Discussion
This mock delivers your “broken glass” vision with tough, film-obsessed leaders. Strengths:
- Starters: Barron (CB), Booker (G), and Watts (S) are Day 1 impact players, fixing our secondary and O-line.
- Key Adds: Dennis (DT) and Gadsden (TE2) bring high-motor upside.
- Depth: Schwesinger (LB), Atkins (G), Hall (EDGE), Catalon (S), and Brown (RB) add physicality, with Brown addressing the RB need post-Mostert.
- Fit: Picks align with McDaniel’s/Weaver’s schemes, strengthening the trenches, secondary, and now RB depth.
- Skattebo Omission: Justified by Achane/Wright’s strength, Brown’s late-round fit, and urgent needs (O-line, secondary), though his grit is tempting.
Concerns: Skattebo’s leadership could’ve been a culture boost, but Brown’s toughness and scheme fit work better late. The focus on guard, CB, and safety is solid, but fans might crave a bigger RB splash. Does this roster have the grit to dominate the AFC East?
Last edited: