Alex Smith | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Alex Smith

#1dolphinsfan

#1dolphinsfan

Perennial All-Pro
Joined
Feb 19, 2007
Messages
8,211
Reaction score
15
Location
Nevada
If he ends up lossing he starting job to JT O'sullivan or Shaun Hill and he gets cut would you guys be willing to give him a shot down in Miami
 
No. He has done absolutely nothing to warrant giving him a shot.

Smith is not experienced enough to be a stop gap and we already have our QB for the near future in Henne or Beck.
 
Thank god we didn't get the number 1 overall that year or we would have him. We got Ronnie instead
 
No way, the guy is having a tough time showing that he is an NFL QB. (and i know he has never had the same O-coordinatior) Even with Gore tearing it up, he could not even manage the offense. He played at Utah under Urban Meyer (who is now at Florida) and his system is known for being great for college QB's, just not great at producing NFL QB's.

On a second note, why keep even going after QBs that have big question marks??? Why go keep going after QB's who have not proven anything? For example, McCown, A. Smith, and Simms. Why keep wanting to go after former pro bowl QB's comming off major injuries? For instance, Culpepper, Green. I know we still have hope for Henne, but if not why not go after a real QB with no question marks???
 
#1dolphinsfan said:
If he ends up lossing he starting job to JT O'sullivan or Shaun Hill and he gets cut would you guys be willing to give him a shot down in Miami
Click to expand...

Sure why not, we (as a team) can never have too many interceptions :unsure:

And how could we pass up on a quarterback that has been beat out by JT or Shaun HIll- that would be like insane.
 
really... really??? you serious???
if Shaun Hill and/or JT O' freaking beats out Alex Smith (who has been playing horrible throughout taboot), that is just enough reason NOT to bring him in....


why must people always bring up names to bring just because they may become available... unnecessary... and plainly stupid!!!



Geforce said:
No. He has done absolutely nothing to warrant giving him a shot.

Smith is not experienced enough to be a stop gap and we already have our QB for the near future in Henne or Beck.
Click to expand...
 
HENNE is the future PERIOD!! Will he be behind center this year - who knows for sure but next year and beyond he is the guy. Why bring in another backup. We already have 2.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom