All Time Phins Team | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

All Time Phins Team

R

RealDriscoll

Still Perfect.. and You're Not.
Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
2,107
Reaction score
19
Age
42
Location
Baltimore MD/ Miami, Flor
Coach: Don Shula
QB: Dan Marino
FB: Larry Czonka
RB: Mercury Morriss
TE: Keith Jackson
WR: Paul Warfield
WR: Mark CLayton
T: Richmond Webb
G: Larry Little
C: Dwight Serphenson
G: Jim Langler
T: Vernon Carey

DE: Jason Taylor
DT: Tim Bowens
DT: Manny Fernandez
DE: Trace Armstrong
LB: Zach Thomas
LB: John Offerdahl
LB: Nick Bonnicouni
CB: Patrick Surtain
CB: Sam Madison
S: Louis Oliver
S: Jake Scott
K: Olindo Mare
P: Reggie Roby
KR: Ted Ginn Jr.
 
Not bad except for the rookie being on the all-time team. I'd drop Vernon Carey (even if I had to put Wade in there). I believe Doug Betters would be better than Trace as well. I also wonder about Madison being better than McNeal but it was hard to compare the two...

Good job overall. Is this close to the thread from last year, same topic?
 
RealDriscoll said:
Coach: Don Shula
QB: Dan Marino
FB: Larry Czonka
RB: Mercury Morriss
TE: Keith Jackson
WR: Paul Warfield
WR: Mark CLayton
T: Richmond Webb
G: Larry Little
C: Dwight Serphenson
G: Jim Langler
T: Vernon Carey

DE: Jason Taylor
DT: Tim Bowens
DT: Manny Fernandez
DE: Trace Armstrong
LB: Zach Thomas
LB: John Offerdahl
LB: Nick Bonnicouni
CB: Patrick Surtain
CB: Sam Madison
S: Louis Oliver
S: Jake Scott
K: Olindo Mare
P: Reggie Roby
KR: Ted Ginn Jr.
Click to expand...

Pretty good list but I would make these changes.
Mercury Morris at running back instead of Ricky Williams? Hmm

Jim Langer is a HOF center not guard. Bob Kuechenberg should be the other guard.

Vernon Carey hasn't played long enough to be on the list. Besides at this point, Norm Evans was much better.

Louis Oliver was good but I would still give Dick Anderson the slight nod.

Ted Ginn, Jr hasn't return a single kick yet so how can he be on this list? Fulton Walker held the NFL record for punt return yards in a season for 11 seasons.
 
Geforce said:
Pretty good list but I would make these changes.
Mercury Morris at running back instead of Ricky Williams? Hmm

Jim Langer is a HOF center not guard. Bob Kuechenberg should be the other guard.

Vernon Carey hasn't played long enough to be on the list. Besides at this point, Norm Evans was much better.

Louis Oliver was good but I would still give Dick Anderson the slight nod.

Ted Ginn, Jr hasn't return a single kick yet so how can he be on this list? Fulton Walker held the NFL record for punt return yards in a season for 11 seasons.
Click to expand...

Yeah I agree. I also think you put Den Herder and Stanfill at the 2 DE spots.
 
I`d put Wayne Moore or Norm Evans over Carey. Dick Anderson over Louis Oliver. Ricky Williams over Mercury. Bill Stanfill over Trace. Finally, how can Ginn even be on the list, because of potential? Fulton Walker gets my nod.
 
late again said:
Yeah I agree. I also think you put Den Herder and Stanfill at the 2 DE spots.
Click to expand...

If you were to put both Vern Den Herder and Bill Stanfill at the DE spots, you would have to remove Jason Taylor. I don't think either of them are better than JT.
 
Who in the rightful mind would put Ted Ginn Jr. on the all time team when he hasn't played a down or made the team as a player. Only a moron would do something like that.
 
RealDriscoll said:
Coach: Don Shula
QB: Dan Marino
FB: Larry Czonka
RB: Mercury Morris
TE: Keith Jackson
WR: Paul Warfield
WR: Mark CLayton
T: Richmond Webb
G: Larry Little
C: Dwight Stephenson
G: Jim Langer/Bob Kuechenberg
T: Vernon Carey/Norm Evans

DE: Jason Taylor
DT: Tim Bowens/Bob Baumhower
DT: Manny Fernandez
DE: Trace Armstrong/Bill Stanfill
LB: Zach Thomas
LB: John Offerdahl
LB: Nick Bounticonti
CB: Patrick Surtain
CB: Sam Madison
S: Louis Oliver/Dick Anderson
S: Jake Scott
K: Olindo Mare/Garo Yepremian
P: Reggie Roby
KR: Ted Ginn Jr.
Click to expand...

My corrections are too the right in bold.

1)Jim Langer was a hall of fame center, not a guard, that position has to go to Kuechenberg.

2) Vernon Carey might one day earn a spot on this team, But for now I place a few guys ahead of him at tackle.

3) Bob Baumhower went to like 5 straight pro bowls as a key player on the Killer Bees, Bowens is close but not quite there.

4) Trace Armstrong was good, but Bill Stanfill was much better, his career, like Stephensons, was cut a bit short by injury.

5) Louis Oliver was a popular player, but Dick Anderson was a GREAT safety on the greatest Dolphin teams in history.

The only other major problem I have with your list is three middle linebackers on the list, they probably are the three greatest Dolphin linebackers, but this team has no outside backers.
 
I'm sorry, Ricky had one great year here, but his problems knock him off any all-time Dolphin list.

Mercury notched a 1000 yards the same year Csonka did as well, he was an awesome back and was under utilized due to the talent those teams had.
 
Seems like this topic comes up every few months, and I always bite.

QB - Marino
HB - Morris
FB - Csonka
WR - Warfield
WR - Clayton
TE - Jackson
OT - Webb
OT - Evans
G - Keuchenberg
G - Little
C - Stephenson

DE - Taylor
DE - Stanfill
DT - Baumhower
DT - Bowens
LB - Thomas
LB - Offerdahl
LB - Cox
CB - Madison
CB - Surtain
S - Scott
S - Anderson

As always the hardest omission is Langer, but you can only have one center. Cox makes it over Buonticonti because there really shouldn't be three inside linebackers and Cox played outside as well as inside. For the guy who said Vincent over Madison, did you know that Madison went to four pro bowls as a phin and Vincent zero?
 
You gotta fit AJ Duhe in there somewhere. The Jason Taylor of his time.
 
BlueFin said:
I'm sorry, Ricky had one great year here, but his problems knock him off any all-time Dolphin list.

Mercury notched a 1000 yards the same year Csonka did as well, he was an awesome back and was under utilized due to the talent those teams had.
Click to expand...


I would still take Ricky, I could hand the ball to him 50 times a game. Him & Csonk? You gotta be kidding, that would be insane. The opposing team would be wicked concussed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom