Are there any players untouchable on the current roster?
- Thread starter Fin Fan in NC
- Start date
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2016
- Messages
- 16,205
- Reaction score
- 20,481
Just wanted to ask and see if there are any players that are untouchable in trades from this current roster? I know there maybe some players that have cap ramifications to the the team, but if those can be addressed is there anyone that you wouldn't trade?
Needs some qualification. I just said in another thread, depends on Sully/Haf. Are they going to try to field a competitive team or go full tank? If they are trying to be competitive, yeah, there are untouchable players "IF* the bar is 'against REASONABLE offers.'
I'd trade anyone for 3 1sts, but that's not reasonable. Trade for a top 5 pick this year? I'd still keep Achane. There are others I'd swap in a trade, but that depends on position/player/cost. Sully needs to listen to every offer and Haf's evaluations. Assume every offer as possible. can't hurt anything.
Are we Guaranteed if we get picks, we will hit on getting a top 5? No
If we get picks for Paul, are we guaranteed we will hit with a better player? No
If we trade away Achane for high picks, will we get a player as dynamic as him? No
When you have quality players, they better severely over pay for them, or it's not worth it...Except for fans more interested in the Draft, then competing in actual games.
Blake the great
Active Roster
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2011
- Messages
- 6,729
- Reaction score
- 9,755
We thought Tunsil was a untouchable player but if a team offers the moon for them then you have to consider it, especially if we are rebuilding or dont have a clear franchise QB in place.
All players have a price unless you have a legit elite level QB.
All players have a price unless you have a legit elite level QB.
phinschamp45
Active Roster
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2012
- Messages
- 1,885
- Reaction score
- 2,172
I'd trade achane for a top 5 pick and draft that DEnd from um. He is going to be ray Lewis like. He will be gone before the 11th pick.
Any top 5 offer for Achane Miami has to take. However, nobody is trading a top 5 pick for Achane. Anything in the first you have to consider since it'll be a couple of years to build a competitive roster and Achane will need a contract before that.
dolphinheel
Active Roster
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2004
- Messages
- 7,216
- Reaction score
- 10,928
Paul, Achane and Brooks.
The Untouchables:
Achane
Brewer
Brooks
Paul
Achane
Brewer
Brooks
Paul
No one is untouchable if the right offer comes along.
Too much love for Achane...YES he's awesome ...but right now in our situation he's like Herschel Walker to me. Give me a Walker haul or near that and he's yours.
Paul? Nah. Tunsil deal or no because we cant keep throwing away our good olinemen and then cry we need ....Olinemen. So stop the BS and start keeping the guys worth keeping on the Oline so we dont have Oline problems 24/7.
Paul? Nah. Tunsil deal or no because we cant keep throwing away our good olinemen and then cry we need ....Olinemen. So stop the BS and start keeping the guys worth keeping on the Oline so we dont have Oline problems 24/7.
phinzfan21
Active Roster
I just hate when past GMs make the mistake of a first round pick automatically has more value than a proven young player already playing like what you'd expect from a first round talent. Gotta give the new guy a shot yeah, but we tend to suck at drafting in the first round anyway. Build through the draft yes, but if some of those young previous draft picks are working out, keep 'em.
Achane, Brooks Minkah
BrowardDolfan
Active Roster
A lot of fans on here of the PDL - Perpetual Draft League. Every pick is a Justin Jefferson that falls through the cracks. No one seems to remember the many more JAGs who get drafted or the outright failures. The grass is always greener. Potential for success better than actually attaining it.