B- from Dr Z.

[retarmyfinfan]

From what I have been reading the last week makes me feel good about our draft. Looking forward to see what John Beck brings to the field.

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2007/writers/dr_z/04/29/draft.report.card/3.html

 

[Mike13]

Good read.

 

[Regan21286]

Nice, though I thought our Day 2 picks were the ones bringing the curve up here. I still think our Day 1 picks are questionable but at least the FO did something.

And I think the Giants grade should be higher (or at least higher than ours). They got a good playmaking CB which they need, a good speedy WR they need, a fair backup for Shockey, a good hardnosed DT, and the steal of the draft (in my opinion) with Belichick's young mentee Zak DeOssie, who I think could be a force at MLB. It's almost like putting Zach Thomas's mind and spirit in a bigger LB's body.

 

[dolfan121]

B- not too shabby!!!!!

 

[dolfan121]

Nice, though I thought our Day 2 picks were the ones bringing the curve up here. I still think our Day 1 picks are questionable but at least the FO did something.

And I think the Giants grade should be higher (or at least higher than ours). They got a good playmaking CB which they need, a good speedy WR they need, a fair backup for Shockey, a good hardnosed DT, and the steal of the draft (in my opinion) with Belichick's young mentee Zak DeOssie, who I think could be a force at MLB. It's almost like putting Zach Thomas's mind and spirit in a bigger LB's body.

hey did you see the highlight where our questionable pick at 9 burnt the Giants good playmaking CB!!!!

 

[Regan21286]

hey did you see the highlight where our questionable pick at 9 burnt the Giants good playmaking CB!!!!

yes, and i saw the highlight where our questionable pick injured himself causing the reason why he is questionable.

 

[Phanatical]

We've had everything from A+ to F.

I guess time will tell if Cam made the right choices.

I'm hoping like heck that I am wrong and that Beck turns out better than Quinn.

 

[23EmilioVasquez]

i think it is a b+ or A draft in the future i might look like a B- but people will change their mind

 

[Pinkboy]

You guys are counting on Sports Illustrated ? LOL !!!That's from the same publication who picked us to go to the super bowl against Carolina last year in their preseason issue.. take what Si says with a grain of salt..

They've had the worst record for predicting things of any publication on the planet.. They are the cause of many jokes around sports teams..

 

[JT#1]

yes, and i saw the highlight where our questionable pick injured himself causing the reason why he is questionable.

yah not the prettyst site/

 

[jdang307]

yes, and i saw the highlight where our questionable pick injured himself causing the reason why he is questionable.

So our #9 pick replicated himself, put on a #8 jersey, and landed on his own leg/ankle? He is amazing, it's like getting two players for one pick.

 

[Regan21286]

http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a179/cbusmike/ginninjruy.jpg yah not the prettyst site/

Not pretty yes, unfortunate sure, but the fact remains that he is injured and his readiness for training camp and possibly the season is questionable.

So our #9 pick replicated himself, put on a #8 jersey, and landed on his own leg/ankle? He is amazing, it's like getting two players for one pick.

He can be amazing if he's healthy. But that's the questionable part right? Is he healthy or not? He couldn't run a full workout rain or not (and if he's coming here, you better believe he'll see rain).