Beck: Stay or Leave?
- Thread starter phinfan_1
- Start date
Jammin29
WiN OuT!
Stay, i dont see why we cant develop a Bench QB with Henne starting in the future instead of keeping McCown and him and penny leaving later and finding another qb for the bench, iv heard becks not doing well now but neither is mccown but beck has potential to be good.
SuperMarksBros.
Formerly Fiedler for MVP
keep. McCown has no upside. Dont wanna give up picks or get in a bidding war for Simms. Nobody else out there. Give him another year, then at least social security will kick in 
Keep Him, He has Talent, Needs Time to Develop is my vote. I would not be suprised if a trade is in the works though.
I'd like to Miami keep Beck, but I read a comment by Sparono in the Sun-Sentinel today where he said a back-up should be a veteran that dosen't need much time to get ready. That doesn't sound good for Beck. I'm not buying the part where he says the Fins have the room to keep 4 QBs.
R_t_Kraken
Active Roster
Keep unless we can get something decent for him via trade (which I doubt.) Drop Mccown.
I've been a Beck supporter since we drafted him but i'm realizing Henne is most likely in the future plans, and Pennington will be at the helm until he's ready. And i'm perfectly cool with that.
I've been a Beck supporter since we drafted him but i'm realizing Henne is most likely in the future plans, and Pennington will be at the helm until he's ready. And i'm perfectly cool with that.
Chubby
SUPERFAN
Exactly Kud, We will end up keeping him for that fact only, I think Mccown will be easier to move then Beck, But I am a big Beck fan and would love to see him later on get a shot and prove everyone wrong, maybe naming pennington as a starter will be the best thing that ever happen to beck.
Chubbs
Chubbs
Chubby
SUPERFAN
Aaaah almost forgot to add, I dont buy this whole "we are keeping 4 Qb's thing".
Not Happening.
Chubbs
Not Happening.
Chubbs
X-Pacolypse
Active Roster
Keep him and develop him as a backup to Henne.
DanTheManFinFan
Starter
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2004
- Messages
- 263
- Reaction score
- 2
Exactly.....and added to all that is the fact that Beck is a leftover castoff from the Camoron/Mule-er (as in jackass) debacle and not a Parcells FO pick, he's as good as gone unless he really outshines McCown....which doesn't sound like is happening now.
csabe
Pro Bowler
- Joined
- May 30, 2004
- Messages
- 1,642
- Reaction score
- 0
I think his days are numbered, Henne is a better prospect and Mccown would be better to put in a game situation to still have a chance to win imo.
Pennington10
Chad Attack
Why should he stay, there are places where he can end up playing sooner then later, I don't think he's going to ever get anymore playing time here with Chad and Chad here. I hate to say that, because he's not a bad QB, but Henne seems like he's got great stuff and a hell of an arm, and Pennington is going to work as the starter until Henne is ready. If we trade him, we can get some kinda value back for him and move on.
emocomputerjock
With stolen wings and evil ways
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2006
- Messages
- 2,575
- Reaction score
- 1
I said stay, but it's up to a combinationn of Beck and the FO at this point. They're not going to take an internets poll seriously like Cam. Beck has got to want to stay, he's got to play like he wants to stay, they have to want to keep him and they're responsible for giving him his shot. We'll find out at some point.
SpaceMountain16
Disgruntled
I don't think either of those choices is the correct answer. We can only assume Beck has some RAW QB talent that has yet to be developed, otherwise he wouldn't have been such a highly touted QB in the draft last year. Until we know for sure what he can give us, i fail to see the reason you get rid of him.
Fish-Head
U made the pudding but forgot the proof.
I just wonder what kind 'if any' vlaue he has on the market right now... I think the decision is made for us until that situation changes... He will be on our roster at the very least until another team becomes desperate.