Best QB in the draft

[mandal24]

Most scouts and fans alike will claim Matt Ryan to be the clear-cut number one rated Qb in the draft. I personally believe, like some, he's somewhat overrated. He has great intangibles but take away his comeback vs. VT and his great game against Bowling Green, this peast season was above average but nothing that would show he should be the number 1 rated QB.
I'd go with Brian Brohm. Hes' very athletic. He also shows great poise in the pocket. People wana talk about his injuries, well perhaps his Oline wasn't one of the best. They also want to talk about his arm strength and how its not adequate...thats false.
Joe Flacco-People compare him to Rothlisberger... he has the size but thats where it ends. He's coming from a D1-AA school. He couldn't pass Tyler Palko on the depth charts at Pitt!
Andre Woodson-he has a windup ala Byron Leftwich, hate that
John David Booty-USC was wayyyy too talented not to be contending for a national championship .. I blame Booty..But he is NFL ready
Colt Brennan-Amazingly accurate but will need a few years to learn a pro-style offense.
Josh Johnson-Insane stats, most athletic QB in the draft.. tough to judge coming from D1AA.. but I do think he's a better pro prospect that the other D1AA QB Joe Flacco
Chad Henne-Too inconsistent. Not the most accurate. But he did play against top notch competition and is very NFL ready
Erik Ainge- Nice size. played against top competition but underachieved with NFL-talent around him. NFL ready but kinda inconsistent..nothing too overly exciting about him

 

[Roman529]

Flacco....that's who I want with the # 32 pick.

 

[moonman]

awesome thread

 

[Straztheman]

Flacco....that's who I want with the # 32 pick.

I went with Ryan. I think he's better than Flacco.

 

[Dolphin39]

1. Ryan
2. Flacco
3. Henne
4. Booty

 

[zach8111]

Flacco....that's who I want with the # 32 pick.

wow im glad you are not our GM, cuz he is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo overrated. it is easily Ryan and then Brohm.

 

[adamprez2003]

OMG. Someone actually voted Brennan

 

[KTOWNFINFAN]

OMG. Someone actually voted Brennan

UHHH yeah, hello. He is the greatest QB ever to lace em up and he has been a fine son as well. :wink:

 

[Roman529]

Joe Flacco-People compare him to Rothlisberger... he has the size but thats where it ends. He's coming from a D1-AA school. He couldn't pass Tyler Palko on the depth charts at Pitt!

That idiot coach at Pitt with the moustache...sorry I cannot say his name, is such a great evaluator of talent!!!!!!! That is why he no longer is an NFL coach. Flacco is going to be better than Big Ben, just wait and see.

 

[phinzfan21]

I went
1. Ryan
2. Brohm
3. Flacco
4. Henne
5. Ainge
6. Johnson
7. Woodson
8. Brennan
9. Booty
10. K. Wright (j/k) =)

And this doesn't mean I want us to draft Ryan. =)

 

[Roman529]

wow im glad you are not our GM, cuz he is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo overrated. it is easily Ryan and then Brohm.

You won't be saying this when Flacco is tearing up the NFL in a few years. If you want to talk about overrated you should be talking about Matt Ryan. :wink:

 

[U-M_all_day]

ehh...

flacco
brohm
ryan
henne
booty
johnson
brennan
woodson
other lol


I think ryan is overrated and booty is underrated, imo...

 

[zach8111]

You won't be saying this when Flacco is tearing up the NFL in a few years. If you want to talk about overrated you should be talking about Matt Ryan. :wink:

i think ryan is a bit overrated too but not as much as flacco. flacco couldnt beat out tyler palco at pitt so he transfered to deleware. his footwork is horrible. he cant take a snap from under center, his arm strength is the only thin he has. beck is a better prospect than flacco. flacco wont even be starting in a few years, so unless he is tearing up the bench, i dont know what he would be tearing up. the nfl anaylasis say he is a PROJECT QB and would take at least three years to groom before he is ready to start in the nfl.

 

[phintim]

Brohm would be #1 but injuries made him slide down he reminds me of the Stanford QB that Buffalo got last year who correct me if I am wrong was the most productive rookie QB!

 

[adamprez2003]

You won't be saying this when Flacco is tearing up the NFL in a few years. If you want to talk about overrated you should be talking about Matt Ryan. :wink:

The only two QBs who could potentially surpass Ryan's greatness are Flacco and Bernard Morris IMO. Just based on the physical assets. Still think Ryan is the best though :tongue: