Beware assumptions: Miami Dolphins quarterback RT is indestructible man of steel | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Beware assumptions: Miami Dolphins quarterback RT is indestructible man of steel

AL R

Super Donator
Club Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2010
Messages
24,164
Reaction score
23,791
Location
Davie, FL
This does not mean Tannehill is going to be playing anytime soon. Indeed, this does not even mean the MRI is correct. That’s why Tannehill is going for a second examination and opinion as early as Tuesday.

At any rate, he’s not playing at the New York Jets on Saturday. And he isn’t playing the following week at the Buffalo Bills. A source told me Monday the initial plan is to play Matt Moore in those games and give Tannehill time to stabilize the left knee.
And if the season-finale against New England is a meaningful game, and if Tannehill is mobile and up to it, and if there is no chance for long term damage to be done by playing, then Gase will ask a million questions of the team’s medical staff and the Dolphins will consider trotting out SuperQB against the Patriots. But that comes with zero certainty.

That means on the fifth day of the 2017 league year, sometime in March, the Dolphins will guarantee approximately $14.5 million of Tannehill’s salary simply by having him on the roster. And that guarantee means Tannehill will remain the Dolphins quarterback beyond this season.That brings me to the injury portion of this saga. Remember the Dolphins feared Tannehill had torn his ACL rather than sprained it?

Team doctors performed what is called the Lachman test that showed enough instability to cause them to believe Tannehill tore the ACL. Well, the ensuing MRI suggested Tannehill only has a sprain.
But the dicey part of all this medical jargon is that a sprain is by definition a partial tear.

So while Tannehill does not have a full rupture, his ACL is indeed partially torn. That’s in the MRI he had. And unlike the MCL that heals itself through rest and regeneration, the ACL does not regenerate So the only way Tannehill can get that knee stable again is by hoping scar tissue builds up in the area to cover the partial tear -- which isn’t as good as having a new ACL -- and by strengthening his quadriceps so much as to provide added stability. Tannehill would also wear a left knee brace perhaps the rest of his career to ensure even more stability.But here is the uncomfortable part: Players who have had partially torn ligaments can be more susceptible to a complete rupture later on.

Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/s...-salguero/article120512268.html#storylink=cpy

Highlights from Armando- read elsewhere yesterday that surgery might still be needed if he cant stabilize the knee.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Screw coming back this year, put him on IR. If he needs surgery or if it gets worse we could have been looking at him missing the entire off season and potentially taking a full season to return to his old self. Even if he misses the rest of this season, it will be HUGE if he is 100% for the start of training camp and he is able to run without any problems next year

Tho even after saying all that - if it increass his chance of staying healthy in the years ahead perhaps he should have the surgery
 
I thought a tear was dislodged/torn from the joint, and a sprain was a stretching of the ligament. Stretch not being torn, but it being elastic that it goes back to size w/o surgery. How is that a tear? IDK, please advise.
 
I thought a tear was dislodged/torn from the joint, and a sprain was a stretching of the ligament. Stretch not being torn, but it being elastic that it goes back to size w/o surgery. How is that a tear? IDK, please advise.

David J. Chao, MD ‏@ProFootballDoc 19h19 hours ago
David J. Chao, MD Retweeted Armando Salguero
Yes.
Sprain = tear
Grade 1 sprain = minimal tear
Grade 2 sprain = moderate or partial tear
Grade 3 sprain = complete tear.
 
You can have a grade 1 sprain and still not have the ligament torn. It could just be very overworked/stretched. No harm in getting a second opinion to judge the severity of this.
 
im not gonna play doctor - they have the best of the best advising him and im not going to buy into a moderate sprain being worse than a full blown tear because of future implications

pfft
 
David J. Chao, MD ‏@ProFootballDoc 19h19 hours ago
David J. Chao, MD Retweeted Armando Salguero
Yes.
Sprain = tear
Grade 1 sprain = minimal tear
Grade 2 sprain = moderate or partial tear
Grade 3 sprain = complete tear.

Gotcha, thanks for the info.
 
Stupid stupid article. He has absolutely no medical knowledge whatsoever. Yeah sure, a tear is better than a sprain. Nice writing
 
This does not mean Tannehill is going to be playing anytime soon. Indeed, this does not even mean the MRI is correct. That’s why Tannehill is going for a second examination and opinion as early as Tuesday.

At any rate, he’s not playing at the New York Jets on Saturday. And he isn’t playing the following week at the Buffalo Bills. A source told me Monday the initial plan is to play Matt Moore in those games and give Tannehill time to stabilize the left knee.
And if the season-finale against New England is a meaningful game, and if Tannehill is mobile and up to it, and if there is no chance for long term damage to be done by playing, then Gase will ask a million questions of the team’s medical staff and the Dolphins will consider trotting out SuperQB against the Patriots. But that comes with zero certainty.

That means on the fifth day of the 2017 league year, sometime in March, the Dolphins will guarantee approximately $14.5 million of Tannehill’s salary simply by having him on the roster. And that guarantee means Tannehill will remain the Dolphins quarterback beyond this season.That brings me to the injury portion of this saga. Remember the Dolphins feared Tannehill had torn his ACL rather than sprained it?

Team doctors performed what is called the Lachman test that showed enough instability to cause them to believe Tannehill tore the ACL. Well, the ensuing MRI suggested Tannehill only has a sprain.
But the dicey part of all this medical jargon is that a sprain is by definition a partial tear.

So while Tannehill does not have a full rupture, his ACL is indeed partially torn. That’s in the MRI he had. And unlike the MCL that heals itself through rest and regeneration, the ACL does not regenerate So the only way Tannehill can get that knee stable again is by hoping scar tissue builds up in the area to cover the partial tear -- which isn’t as good as having a new ACL -- and by strengthening his quadriceps so much as to provide added stability. Tannehill would also wear a left knee brace perhaps the rest of his career to ensure even more stability.But here is the uncomfortable part: Players who have had partially torn ligaments can be more susceptible to a complete rupture later on.

Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/s...-salguero/article120512268.html#storylink=cpy

Highlights from Armando- read elsewhere yesterday that surgery might still be needed if he cant stabilize the knee.

I just have trouble believing what Armando says, the guy is kind of a hack.
 
Bottom line, I think the staff has shown they will not throw injured players out there f it jeopardizes their future. They've been extremely cautious with Howard and IR'ed Pouncey when he's supposedly insisting he can play. I think we can trust the staff not to roll Tannehill out there again in 2016 if it jeopardizes 2017 and beyond. These guys have to be taking the approach where they realize the 2016 Dolphins are not a Super Bowl team with or without Ryan Tannehill with the fact that anything can happen if you get into the playoffs as a secondary, in the back of your mind type thought. I feel they're taking this approach as should we as fans.
 
Back
Top Bottom