dol_fan4life
Practice Squad
- Joined
- Dec 17, 2006
- Messages
- 86
- Reaction score
- 0
Who do you think was our biggest loss this year?
Biggest Loss This Year??
- Thread starter dol_fan4life
- Start date
pennPhinFan
FinHeaven VIP
Probably both McIntosh and James.. after all together they weighed 640 lbs... thats pretty big if you ask me!
but really.. i'd say welker by straight up loss of player, as he was most consistent, but factoring in what we got in return for our 'losses', i'd say mcmichael because we got nothing for him in return and our backups aren't too fantastic at TE
but really.. i'd say welker by straight up loss of player, as he was most consistent, but factoring in what we got in return for our 'losses', i'd say mcmichael because we got nothing for him in return and our backups aren't too fantastic at TE
Aqua4Ever04
Active Roster
I think a solid TE is better than a 3rd WR who had 1 TD catch in his entire career and just 650 yards last year. (His career year at that.) We got a 2nd round pick for Welker which I would take any day no doubt about it.
dominizzo
CAMERON EARTH WAKE
Randy biggy time
Uruguayfinfan
Uruguayan fin lover
Last year i just saw dolphins to see wes welker play, so i believe he is.
Aqua4Ever04
Active Roster
So be a Patriots' fan then.
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2003
- Messages
- 1,045
- Reaction score
- 4
Welker was the biggest loss so far.
I agree a solid TE is better than a 3rd WR, but we didn't have a solid TE last season.
Aqua4Ever04
Active Roster
I just don't understand what the love fest was with Welker. Yeah I too loved him because of his overachieving self, but the truth was he was an average player. He had 1 RECEIVING TOUCHDOWN in his career here and never exceded 700 yards and could never break big kick returns. Getting a 2nd round pick for him was brilliant, great move for the Dolphins.
EDIT: How does Welker have 13 votes and Carter with none? Carter was very good for us and will be replaced by a 2nd round pick in Matt Roth. Strange, that's the same thing we got for Welker. :confused:
Trowa
Seasoned Veteran
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2007
- Messages
- 598
- Reaction score
- 0
I weep when I think of Sammy Morris being in New England. If they destroyed us using Heath Evans just think of what might happen with a Maroney/Morris combo. I still say Morris was our biggest loss because of where he went and the fact we still don't know if Ricky will come back. If Ricky comes back then I agree it was McMike because of the void it left at TE and the fact that we got no compensation for him. And I understand the circumstances around why we didn't but it doesn't change the fact that it hurt us not to. All things considered at this moment in time it's gotta be Sammy Morris and people should realize that losing him could be back breaking. Of course if Ricky comes back that point could be moot.
icephinfan
Dolphins Fan!!!
MexDolfan
Seasoned Veteran
Every loss this off season was under some priority judging, so I can't try to judge anything like what have we obtain as compensation.
My point is that if we just see the loss and not if this decision was right of wrong, then I'll say TE. Randy's hands have helped us many times in the past and his efforts in the field were responsible of many comebacks.
My point is that if we just see the loss and not if this decision was right of wrong, then I'll say TE. Randy's hands have helped us many times in the past and his efforts in the field were responsible of many comebacks.