Here is my take on Chambers:
His biggest problem is consistancy... something we all know. So 1 game isnt gunna change my opinion... this is what he does. Has some good games, and some bad ones... rarely stringing them together.
Now, to the question of whether I feel he is a #1 receiver...
To me, the thing that seperates good receivers from true #1 receivers, is that a true #1 WR can consistantly beat double coverage. Chad Johnson is a perfect example. He guarentees he wont be stopped because he knows that he can beat double (and even sometimes triple) teams. Examples of true #1's IMO are:
MHarrison, TO, RMoss, Steve Smith, Chad, Holt, Ward, Muhamad.
Now, this is why in my mind Chambers wasnt a
true #1.
BUT... I was thinking for a while, and I realized... Do we actually know how well Chambers deals with double teams? I mean, on TV, the camera focuses on the QB... not what is going on down field.
Could it be that our lame QBs have just seen the double coverage and dont look his way because of it? I was trying to think of examples of opportunities where he has been fed the ball despite double teams. I cant remember many(maybe just because they didnt end up being completions
)... 1 play this year that I can remember was in the KC game. The pass Sage threw. Chambers was
tightly guarded by 2 DBs on each side of him, and Chambers made a great play on the ball, and took it to the house.
Maybe Chambers is more capable of this than we know...
However, another criteria of mine that defines a true #1 receiver is his ability to make the QB better. Steve Smith is a perfect example... Delhommie isnt that great. CJohnson also did it with Kitna (who never was that great until Chad really broke out). Chambers has not had that effect on our QBs.
So by my standards... he is only a descent #1 WR(better than some other teams #1s), but he isnt a
true #1.
I do think he can be a great #1 (not a
true #1, but still great and very productive). But Chambers will need a
true #1 QB for him to take his game to that next level...
(sorry if its sorta rambling and kinda long... I am in the middle of pullin an all-nighter studying for a final exam and am kinda cracked-out off no sleep... :desk: )