Couch or McPherson | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Couch or McPherson

Which QB Would You Rather Us Go After

  • Tim Couch

    Votes: 45 34.4%

  • Adrian McPherson

    Votes: 86 65.6%
  • Total voters
    131
Agent51

Agent51

Practice Squad
Joined
Apr 8, 2005
Messages
5,589
Reaction score
0
Age
40
Location
Hawai'i
Lemme start by apologizing for yet another Adrian related thread, however mine isn't praising or bashing him, lol, it's just seeing which of the two QBs we are talking about possibly bringing in everyone would rather have

OK, with the new talk of us possibly interested in claiming Adrian off waivers, who would you guys rather take, assuming we definately take one or the other? My vote is for Tim Couch simply because I personally think he does have the potential to be successful, or at least win games, if he stays healthy, whereas Adrian is dropping down the depth charts of the NEW ORLEANS SAINTS. Tim has been in the league for a bit and knows how things work and such, Adrian would be another rookie coming in so not only would he be someone that couldn't even make the saint's final roster, but he would also be a rookie. It seems to me that Tim Couch would have more potential to help our team, at this point in time anyway, than Adrian McPherson.
 
that is not very tough a guy who has proven that he cant hack it or guy we know nothin about. Adrian
 
Couch can help immediately if healthy, Adrian would be more of a prospect. Since Couch has some experience and some potential, I voted for him. I'd still like to see how good Berlin or Rosenfels can do with the 1st team before I make any judgments.

My list?

Feeley
Couch
Berlin
Rosenfels
McPherson
Frerotte
 
couch has the experince to start we dont no about macpherson yet
 
I'm still looking for the options

C: NO MORE 2nd Stringers, cast offs, or CUT players from other teams
D: None of the above
 
AD. He would instantly become the QB with the best RAW, I stress raw, talent on this team.
 
Regan21286 said:
Couch can help immediately if healthy, Adrian would be more of a prospect. Since Couch has some experience and some potential, I voted for him. I'd still like to see how good Berlin or Rosenfels can do with the 1st team before I make any judgments.

My list?

Feeley
Couch
Berlin
Rosenfels
McPherson
Frerotte
Click to expand...

I also wanna see what our guys can do, and I also think there are other QBs I would liek to have from around the league, I was just making the poll to see which of the two everyone would want since Couch and McPherson are the ones that Finheaven and other sites have been reporting we are interested in
 
Agent51 said:
Lemme start by apologizing for yet another Adrian related thread, however mine isn't praising or bashing him, lol, it's just seeing which of the two QBs we are talking about possibly bringing in everyone would rather have

OK, with the new talk of us possibly interested in claiming Adrian off waivers, who would you guys rather take, assuming we definately take one or the other? My vote is for Tim Couch simply because I personally think he does have the potential to be successful, or at least win games, if he stays healthy, whereas Adrian is dropping down the depth charts of the NEW ORLEANS SAINTS. Tim has been in the league for a bit and knows how things work and such, Adrian would be another rookie coming in so not only would he be someone that couldn't even make the saint's final roster, but he would also be a rookie. It seems to me that Tim Couch would have more potential to help our team, at this point in time anyway, than Adrian McPherson.
Click to expand...

Well, Couch could possibly (provided he is healed) help us THIS year when Gus tanks it (and he will, beyond a doubt). McPh would be a developmental guy that Saban wants...Heck, he could go after both...Cut AJ, Sage and Berlin...who knows...McPh would not help us this year and if he does, it'll mean the season is over in November for us...
 
This poll should have had a third option...none of the above. Couch will not be a competent started anywhere ever again, McPherson would not start this year and I highly doubt he could even dislodge Feeley as the back-up, I can't believe we're two weeks away from the season opener and some are calling for new QBs to be brought it, this year, we sink or swim with Frerotte and Feeley.
 
Bigjbizzle2 said:
that is not very tough a guy who has proven that he cant hack it or guy we know nothin about. Adrian
Click to expand...
We know one thing about him. He is being beat out for the third qb spot for N.O. by Kliff Kingsbury........
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom