Could a team made out of this years draft class beat last years team? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Could a team made out of this years draft class beat last years team?

patswho?

winner
Joined
Aug 12, 2004
Messages
522
Reaction score
0
Thought crossed my mind

QB-Ryan
HB-McFadden/Mendenhall
FB- Peyton Hills
TE-Carlson/Davis
LT-Jake Long
LG- Branden Albert
C- Mike Pollack
RG-Chilo Rachal
RT-Ryan Clady
WR- Sweed/D.Jackson
WR-Kelly/D.Thomas

LE-Merling
DT-Dorsey
DT-Ellis
RE- Chris Long
OLB- Rivers
ILB- Dan Connor
OLB- Gholston
CB- Mckelvin/Cromartie
CB-Talib/Jenkins
S- Kenny Phillips
S- Reggie smith

thoughts?
 
Well we should match it up with last year's draft first.

QB- Jamarcus Russel
RB- Adrian Peterson/Marshawn Lynch
FB-LeRon Mcclain
TE-Greg Olsen/Zach Miller
LT-Joe Thomas
LG-Ben Grubbs
C- Ryan Kalil
RG-Arron Sears
RT-Levi Brown
WR- Calvin Johnson/Ted Ginn
WR-Dwayne Bowe/Robert Meachem

LE-Gaines Adamas
DT-Amobi Okoye
DT-Adam Carriker/Justin Harrel
RE- Jamaal Anderson
OLB- Lawrence Timmons
ILB- Patrick Willis
OLB- Anthony Spencer
CB- Darrelle Revis/Aaron Ross
CB-Leon Hall/Chris Houston
S- Laron Landry
S- Michael Griffin/Brandon Meriweather

Compared to this year's draft I would pick Russel over Ryan, although Russel looks extremely lazy and how far can you go in the raiders system.

Peterson over Mcfadden isn't even close I think. Peterson all the way.

FB doesn't even matter.

WR- Calvin Johnson didn't have a great year but the guy is a freak physically and better than Sweed. Ginn is better then Jackson and Bowe had a solid year so I'll say he's better too.

TE- Olsen didn't look too hot so We'll give this year's draft that position.

LT- Joe Thomas over Jake Long. Long will be good but Joe Thomas played like a perennial pro bowl veteran.

LG- Yet to be known

C- Yet to be known hard to judge

RG- Agaian hard to judge.

RT- I think Clady will be about equal to Brown.

LE- Adamas looked lost most the season so I'll say Merling

DT- This years DT class is better however Okoye has so much potential being so young.

RE- Chris Long over Jamaal Anderson for sure.

OLB- Rivers against Timmons. I'll take Timmons. I've been to a bunch of USC games I'm not extremely impressed with Rivers

ILB- Willis by a mile not even an issue

OLB- Gholston over Spencer for sure

CB- I think this year's CB class is better than last years.

S- Landry and Meriweather and Nelson are pretty good I'll go with last year's class.

Overall I think last year's draft was much stronger on offense and this year's draft is better at defense, but grading a class as a whole I'd take last years, but who am I to say anything.
 
yes they could. there were high school teams that could've beat our team last year.
 
Back
Top Bottom