Dan Marino vs John Elway

[Roman529]

I live in Colorado so I pretty much saw every game Elway played either on tv or in person....you are forgetting Elway's stat of most wins ever by a QB...he has one more win than Marino....Elway also had the most 4th quarter comebacks ever....but Marino does have 420 TD's to Elways 300.....Marino's stats are way ahead of Elways.....Brett Favre could surpass most of Marino's records if he plays three more years......BUT, I still say Marino was the best ever!!!!!!

 

[JAcK o D1AmonDs]

Elway great qb The Comeback kid. 1 more win the Marino and 2 super bowl rings both because of Terrell Davis along with his success in the 90's. Terrell Davis SuperBowl MVP vs the Packers and Elway was VS The Falcon who i have no clue how the hell they got to the SB but oh well. Elway was average with out Davis good with him

 

[maven]

John Elway was a great QB & IMO the best qb of all time. Elway was a complete player. He was a one man gang & led the broncos to 3 SB's in the '80's. Those Bronco teams were terrible, yet he somehow led them to the SB three times. And to follow it up and finally win two in a row & retire after going to the SB 5 times. Elway's legacy will last longer & be more remembered than Marino's. Dan's records will be broken & he'll be thought of as a #'s qb who never achieved greatness. Compare Elway's greatest moments to Dan's & there's no comparison.

 

['Deep]

Terrel Davis made Elway look way better. As much as I dislike the Bills and Kelly, Kelly was the better QB of the two.

Well Kelly had a running game (a superstar in Thurman Thomas and a better than average backup in Kenneth Davis), and he still managed to lose four Super Bowls. Sorry, but I disagree that Kelly was better than Elway.