That's exactly it.
Sometimes a great pass is broken up by perfect coverage.
Perspective or agenda is key.
That pass yesterday to Hill is a perfect example.
Beasley, Kelly etc. May Say it was underthrown and Hill had to come back for the ball.
Others may say Tua put the ball in the one place the defenders couldn't get it. He perfectly read that defense and placed it where only his WR could catch it. Or he found the soft spot.
Depending on your opinion determines how good the pass was.
Brady and Tua could throw the exact same pass, to the same WR with the same outcome. However, Brady threw it to where only his WR could catch it where as Tua underthrew it.
Or Tua underthrew it, but Rodgers knew his throw would draw a PI.
It happens to all the non elites.
If your Tua, Wilson Goff etc..... your passes ar, for the most part, judged more on the negative side. Where as Rodgers, Brady and Mahomes get the benefit of the doubt that they knew what the were doing.
Mahomes. Future hall of fame, arguably best in the game today. But let me tell you, he throw a lot of ugly passes. But you wouldn't know it listening to the comnentators.
Just watch Kurt Warner and Chris Simms evaluate the same game for Tua. How do they both have polar opposite takes on Tuas performance?