[Discussion]- Marino or Young

[spydertl79]

Marino by a longshot

 

[kastofsna120]

the real question is: Benny Friedman or Dan Marino? pretty much a toss-up

 

[MOULDSROCKS]

Young!

 

[67 stangman]

:lolcry: :lolcry: :stupid:

 

[PHINATIC13]

:yeahthat:

Stupid discussion because there is nothing to discuss. Marino and it isnt even close

 

[yankeehillbilly]

Young had the advantage of playing in the West Coast Offense. Lots of intermediate passes which jacks up the completion % and thus the QB rating. Young also had Rice, Watters, Taylor, Rathman, Walls, etc. as well as a dominating defense. Dan had some very good receivers but never had the running game and defense.

I will admit that Young was more versatile since he could run the ball if he had to, and Im not saying that Young isnt HOF material because he most certainly is....but in pretty much any scenario I can imagine, if I had the choice of Marino or Young to lead my team I would have to go with Dan.