Draft Game | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Draft Game

S

schisno

2008 Miami Dolphins GM
Joined
Mar 10, 2005
Messages
682
Reaction score
0
Age
42
Draft Game Rules:
1. Your score is simple. If you drafted a player lower than he was drafted in the NFL, you receive a point for each spot he slipped in the GM draft. If you draft a player higher than he was drafted in the NFL, you lose a point for each spot. Add them all together and divide by the total number of picks you had. That is your score. The winner will be the GM with the best average score.
2. Each player is responsible for calculating their own score. The winner will have their score validated. You will have until May 5th to submit your score (one week after the NFL draft.)
3. If you draft an undrafted NFL player, his NFL pick will be #256, one spot after Mr. Irrelevant.
4. If you traded your draft pick, or acquired a rookie by trade, only the team that originally drafted the player may receive the score.

EXAMPLE:
2006 PANTHERS
Round 1 - 13th overall - LenDale White - RB - USC NFL Round 2 - 45th overall -32
Round 2 - 54th overall - Greg Jennings - WR - Western Michigan NFL Round 2 - 52nd overall +2
Round 4 - 110th overall - Babatunde Oshinowo - DT - Stanford NFL Round 6 - 181st overall -71
Round 4 - 120th overall - Dee Webb - CB - Florida NFL Round 7 - 236th overall -116
Round 6 - 169th overall - Owen Daniels - TE - Wisconsin NFL Round 4 - 98th overall +71
Round 7 - 211 overall - Jeremy Mincey - DE - Florida NFL Round 6 - 191st overall +20
Round 7 - 218 overall - Calvin Lowry - S - Penn State NFL Round 4 - 102nd overall +116
Round 7 - 222 overall - Charles Gordon - CB - Kansas NFL Undrafted -2
Click to expand...


Just post your draft scores below.
 
46. New England Patriots: Brandon Flowers, CB, Virginia Tech Round 2 (35) +11

Round 6
169. New England Patriots: Kevin Robinson, WR, Utah State Round 6(182)
-13

183. New England Patriots: Alvin Bowen, LB, Iowa State NFL-Round 5(147) +36

Round 7
194. New England Patriots: Tommy Blake, DE, TCU -62
211. New England Patriots: George Chukwu, DT, Rice -45
223. New England Patriots: Todd Blythe, WR, Iowa State -33

-17.6....eeesh, that 7th round killed me
 
Round 2 (40) Sam Baker, T, USC, Drafted in the NFL Round 1 (21) +19

Round 3 (77) Phillip Wheeler, OLB, Georgia Tech Drafted NFL Round 3 (93)-16

Round 4 (119) Tom Zbikowski S, Notre Dame Drafted NFL Round 3 (86) +33

Round 5 (137) Jason Shirley DT, Fresno State Drafted NFL Round 5 (145) -8

Round 5 (152) Quinton Demps, S, UTEP Drafted NFL Round 4 (117) +35

Round 6 (179) Adrian Arrington WR, Michigan Drafted NFL Round 7 (202) -23

Round 7 (201) D.J. Hall, WR, Alabama Drafted NFL Round None -54

Round 7 (210) Cody Wallace, C/G, Texas A&M Drafted NFL Round 4 (107) +103

Final Draft Score- 89

Hall and Arrington really hurt, me, or else my number would have been much higher.
 
New York Giants
15. Leodis McKelvin, CB, Troy---+4
32. Dan Connor, LB, Penn State----42
47. Dustin Keller, TE, Purdue---+17
64. Anthony Collins, OT, Kansas----48
71. Red Bryant, DT, Texas A&M----50
128. Jordy Nelson, WR, Kansas State---+92
160. Caleb Campbell, S, Army----58
161. Trevor Scott, DE, Buffalo----8
188. Barry Booker, DT, Virgina Tech----68
224. Larry Grant, LB, Ohio State---+10

:lol:

Did not expect Connor or Collins to fall like they did. I admit I went for Red and Caleb alot sooner because the DTs and Safetys were getting picked. I was hoping Scott would get picked sooner than he did but I was close on value. Barry Booker went undrafted but thats okay. Jordy Nelson was the third WR that was picked! obviously helped me. I do not consider myself with the top draft any more.
 
1-10 $700,000 - Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State 1-12 -2
2-41 $500,000 - Kentwan Balmer, DT, North Carolina 1-29 +12
3-79 $400,000 - Xavier Adibi, LB, Virginia Tech 4-118 -39
4-115 $350,000 - Jeremy Thompson, DE, Wake Forest 4-102 +13
5-141 $350,000 - Craig Steltz, S, LSU 4-120 +21
5-156 $350,000 - Paul Smith, QB, Tulsa - UDFA -96
6-168 $350,000 - Dwight Lowery, CB, San Jose State 4-113 +55
6-172 $350,000 - Harry Douglas, WR, Louisville 3-84 +83
7-203 $350,000 - Wallace Gilberry, DE, Alabama - UDFA -50
UDFA $350,000 - Jalen Parmele, RB, Toledo 6-176

Total = -0.3
 
5. Jake Long, OT, Michigan (1) = +4
36. Antoine Cason, CB, Arizona (27) = +9
53. Brian Brohm, QB, Louisville - (56) = -3
101. Bruce Davis, DE, UCLA (88) = +13
126. Orlando Scandrick, CB, Boise State (143) = -17
129. John Sullivan, C, Notre Dame (187) = -58
132. Dexter Jackson, WR, Appalachian State (49) = +83
159. Jamar Adams, S, Michigan (256) = -97
163. Shannon Tevaga, OG, UCLA (256) = -93
197. Chauncey Washington, RB, USC (213) = +16

Total = (-143)/10) = -14.3

Got hurt big time by the Adams one (though I didn't personally pick that one myself :foundout: ) and the Tevaga one. I figured as much for Tevaga but not for Adams. And my UDFA's Barnidge (5th round), Mehlhaff (6th round), and Schwartz (7th round) could've also helped out that figure. I guess the Colts win because 0/0 equals infinity. :lol:
 
i might try this, but the manningham picked absolutely killed me hahah
 
1st-11th overall (from Buffalo) Jonathan Stewart, RB Oregon (taken 13th) -2
1st-18th overall Chris Williams, OT Vanderbilt (taken 14th) +4
2nd-44th overall (from Carolina) Early Doucet, WR LSU (taken 81st) -37
3rd-94th overall (from Buffalo) Steve Justice, C Wake Forest (taken 201st) -107
3rd-95th overall (from Buffalo) Brad Cottam, TE Tennessee (taken 76th) +19
4th-125th overall (from Atlanta) Brian Johnston, DE Gardner-Webb (taken 210th) -85
5th-146th overall Nicholas Hayden, DT Wisconsin (taken 181st) -35
6th-173rd overall (from Buffalo) Kevin O'Connell, QB San Diego State (taken 94th) +79
6th-177th overall Arman Shields, WR Richmond (taken 125th) +52

Total -112/9 picks or -12.44avg fairly pathetic... Brian Johnston and Steve Justice absolutely killed me... Shields and O'Connell made it better than it could have been...
 
Saint Greg said:
1-10 $700,000 - Ryan Clady, OT, Boise State 1-12 -2
2-41 $500,000 - Kentwan Balmer, DT, North Carolina 1-29 +12
3-79 $400,000 - Xavier Adibi, LB, Virginia Tech 4-118 -39
4-115 $350,000 - Jeremy Thompson, DE, Wake Forest 4-102 +13
5-141 $350,000 - Craig Steltz, S, LSU 4-120 +21
5-156 $350,000 - Paul Smith, QB, Tulsa - UDFA -96
6-168 $350,000 - Dwight Lowery, CB, San Jose State 4-113 +55
6-172 $350,000 - Harry Douglas, WR, Louisville 3-84 +83
7-203 $350,000 - Wallace Gilberry, DE, Alabama - UDFA -50
UDFA $350,000 - Jalen Parmele, RB, Toledo 6-176

Total = -0.3
Click to expand...


if you sign a guy as an UDFA that was drafted, that doesn't count does it? Parmele...
 
The UDFA don't count I believe, because it is based on the draft we had compared to the real one. So it's just based on the players we drafted, hence why it's the draft game and not draft and undrafted free agents game?

Let the democracy decide.
 
42. Jerod Mayo, LB, Tennessee (10) = +32
98. John David Booty, QB, USC (137) = -39
138. Jeremy Zuttah, OL, Rudgers (83) = +55
142. King Dunlap, OT, Auburn (230) = -88
174. Letroy Guion, DT, Florida State (152) = +22
204. Marcus Monk, WR, Arkansas (248) = -44

Total: -10.3

But if UDFA's were allowed:
Antwaun Molden (79) = +174
Darrell Strong (UDFA) = 0
Louis Holmes (UDFA) = 0

Total: +12.4
 
schisno said:
The UDFA don't count I believe, because it is based on the draft we had compared to the real one. So it's just based on the players we drafted, hence why it's the draft game and not draft and undrafted free agents game?

Let the democracy decide.
Click to expand...

It should be the players that WE drafted compared to the actual draft... Maybe, if you want to have an undrafted free agent game, then you can compare those players you signed to where they actually were drafted... it's the old apples and oranges... but please, nobody talk about their banana...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom