Two things.
1. We drafted his replacement in Hunter Long ... nowhere near the upside, but a solid player. If Long makes the roster, either we're not re-signing Gesicki (most likely) or we're giving up on the promising Adam Shaheen, both of whom are superior athletically compared to Long.
2. This is the best possible year to re-sign players, and it is no coincidence that the Patriots chose this year to splurge in FA. The cap is unrealistically low. In two or three years time any contract signed today will be an incredible bargain, so no need to worry about re-signing Gesicki even if we make him the highest paid TE, because like Xavien Howard's ... it's going to look low very quickly. And, we are not going to make Mike Gesicki the highest paid TE, so any contract he signs will be a good one for the team signing him. If we let him go, we're just plain dumb at this point.
Don Shula always said you need to keep your best players ... and when it's so cheap to do and your player has phenomenal upside and is an ascending player ... it's a no brainer. But, we're the Dolphins ... so there's always a group pounding the table to screw it up. Tunsil was a good player, and we let him go ... but got a king's ransom for him. None of those picks have made the Pro Bowl yet though, so the jury is still out. In Gesicki's same draft class we drafted Minkah Fitzpatrick, who has already been an All-Pro FS every season that he was NOT a Miami Dolphin. He repeatedly asked to be given a specific position ... not an unreasonable request. We wanted a chess piece, and we knew he wasn't happy. It remains to be seen how that pick turns out, but I have very high hopes for Jaelan Phillips. Giving Gesicki away for nothing would be foolish.
Just my humble opinion ... and reasonable minds may disagree. But, we have a terrible history of letting our talented people leave ... and we never build anything. I was hoping that ended when Tannenbaum left. Guess we're still throwing good money after bad and refusing to re-sign our own.