Gibson or Vick? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Gibson or Vick?

WestCoast13

WestCoast13

Practice Squad
Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
149
Reaction score
0
Who do u guys think we shud pull up for this weeks game now that Booker will be out? I want Vick
 
Don't think it really matters since the likelihood that either would receive playing time is rather unfavorable. But in the unlikely situation that might happen, I would pick Vick, as he has a tremendous amount of upside.
 
I think this is a referendum on Vick. If the team values him, they'll choose Gibson. There isn't room on the roster for the player once Booker is healthy because by then surely someone else will be hurt or underperforming and the slot will go to that position. You don't want to risk having him get in the game and make a big play only to be snatched up by another team when you attempt to put him back on the PS. If Vick has long term value, it would be better to keep him out of the limelight and plan for the longer term.
 
thejetssuck said:
, I would pick Vick, as he has a tremendous amount of upside.
Click to expand...

At least in comparison to fred who has been around for a while, and if was really any good would have cracked someone's starting lineup by now.
 
Jimmy James said:
I think this is a referendum on Vick. If the team values him, they'll choose Gibson. There isn't room on the roster for the player once Booker is healthy because by then surely someone else will be hurt or underperforming and the slot will go to that position. You don't want to risk having him get in the game and make a big play only to be snatched up by another team when you attempt to put him back on the PS. If Vick has long term value, it would be better to keep him out of the limelight and plan for the longer term.
Click to expand...

You make a very valid point, I had not thought of that.
 
i def want to see vick, id be very excited to watch him play and im hoping that he does this sunday against the jets...i believe he was a real steal and can contribute now that there is a roster spot for him
 
i think we should pull up Gibson just so we can have a jump ball WR besides Chambers
 
I just read something that said Culpepper might be inactive for the rest of the season, in that case we have to promote Vick as our 3rd QB and as another WR. he might even play some QB if our QBs don't play well
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom