Hall of Fame Modern-Era Semifinalists

[DolFan707]

Sorry no Reggie Roby (R.I.P), or the Mark Brothers. But we do have 3 men that were former Dolphins: the big one is:
Bob Kuechenberg - G - 1970-1984 Miami Dolphins
also...
Thurman Thomas - RB - 1988-1999 Buffalo Bills, 2000 Miami Dolphins (I don't count him as a true Dolphin...I hope he doesn't get in)
George Young - GM/Administrator - 1968-1974 Baltimore Colts, 1975-1978 Miami Dolphins, 1979-1997 New York Giants, 1998-2001 National Football League

also on this list of 25 men:
Michael Irvin - WR - 1988-1999 Dallas Cowboys
Paul Tagliabue - Commissioner - 1989-2006 National Football League

 

[FinsAreLife]

well i hope kuech can get in, but honestly ive lost some respect for the guy after the things he said about our team this year.....although i do thank him for lighting a fire under our players a$$es.

 

[DolFan707]

so far all 9 Miami Dolphins players that are in the HOF have played the majority or all of their seasons on the Dolphins.

 

[jguig]

Irvin should not get in. He's been in jail too many times. Has done too many drugs and ho's. Not what the HOF deserves.

Yes, off the field stuff does matter.

 

[PhinsRock]

I'd like to see Keutch get in, none of the rest. I also want Irvin in, I didn't like his off-field bs either, but I see the HOF as being about what you did on the field. It's not a poster-boy society club. There are a few guys in the HOF that may not have gotten the bad publicity Irvin did, but were not the nicest of guys off the field or even on for that matter.

This does bring up a question I have, did Lawrence Taylor LB for the Giants get into the HOF? If not, then my arguement is dead wrong, if he did, then I'm right as rain.

 

[Silverphin]

I'd like to see Keutch get in, none of the rest. I also want Irvin in, I didn't like his off-field bs either, but I see the HOF as being about what you did on the field. It's not a poster-boy society club. There are a few guys in the HOF that may not have gotten the bad publicity Irvin did, but were not the nicest of guys off the field or even on for that matter.

This does bring up a question I have, did Lawrence Taylor LB for the Giants get into the HOF? If not, then my arguement is dead wrong, if he did, then I'm right as rain.

Yeah, Lawrence Taylor is in the HoF.

 

[GoonBoss]

Keuch should get in.

Thermal should get in as well. The guy was great.

Irvin....God, I hope not. Friggin' push-off artist.

 

[Dolphins=LIFE]

IS Richmond Webb in the HoF?? If not, there's a fin that should be.

 

[Dol-Fan Dupree]

Irvin should not get in. He's been in jail too many times. Has done too many drugs and ho's. Not what the HOF deserves.

Yes, off the field stuff does matter.

LT is in the hall of fame. Nuff said

 

[Alex44]

Keuch should get in.

Thermal should get in as well. The guy was great.

Irvin....God, I hope not. Friggin' push-off artist.

Every WR pushes off, some just do it better than others and dont get called

I dont know if Irvin has the stats for the Hall but I do think he should be in.

 

[bluehaze]

WTG Keuch! He should get in the HOF just for lighting a fire under this teams butt!

 

[jguig]

LT is in the hall of fame. Nuff said

LT totally redefined his position. I agree that he's a bad apple, however, he did revolutionize the position. Irvin was just a superior player at his position.

 

[cnc66]

LT totally redefined his position. I agree that he's a bad apple, however, he did revolutionize the position. Irvin was just a superior player at his position.

imo, that's a fair evaluation...LT changed the whole game... every time I see our JT strip the ball I think of LT.

 

[Silverphin]

I don't think he was that bad of an apple. After that infamous tackle on Theisman, LT was practically begging for the ambulance to help him.

 

[jguig]

I don't think he was that bad of an apple. After that infamous tackle on Theisman, LT was practically begging for the ambulance to help him.

I'm referring to his crack problems after his playing days.