HERALD: Dolphins Offseason Needs | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

HERALD: Dolphins Offseason Needs

Perfect72

It's Only Happened ONCE!
Joined
May 18, 2004
Messages
1,448
Reaction score
665
Location
Florida
One of the amazing things about these Miami Dolphins making such a strong and, yes, improbable push toward being in the playoffs this season is that on paper they pretty much seem to need a ton of help.

No disrespect to the front office but it failed miserably to put together a linebacker corps that is 10 star players deep.

(Yes, that is a joke).

Back of the roster players are there for a reason. And yet last week the Dolphins found themselves reaching deep into the roster to put some of those players on the field as starters. Consider, for example, the four linebackers who played in the victory against the Arizona Cardinals:

Spencer Paysinger.

Mike Hull.

Donald Butler.

Neville Hewitt.

A career special teams guy. A 2015 undrafted and undersized free agent making his first NFL start. A a guy who was waived by the San Diego Chargers and was a street free agent when the Dolphins signed him in late September. And another 2015 undrafted free agent.

Not exactly prized draft picks or free agents any of them.

So I tell you, it’s impressive the Dolphins are doing what they are doing amid injuries to starters, with plans at other positions not proceeding as expected, and sometimes even with less overall talent than the opposition.

And that brings me to this:

When this season, already something of a feel-good story, comes to a close, the Dolphins’ front office will be under the gun to not just hold serve but to find breakthrough so that eventually the Dolphins continue moving toward the high calling of winning an NFL title.

We’ve been here before.

In 2008, the first year under Bill Parcells as football czar and Tony Sparano as head coach, the Dolphins made the amazing climb from 1-15 to 11-5 and the AFC East title. After that season, Parcells told me he had no illusions about how talented that team was or was not.

He admitted that team had some serious holes.

And he said it was thus his personnel department’s assignment to stock up so that Miami could add to the work that had been done in 2008.

It didn’t happen.

The Dolphins instead made significant personnel mistakes and not only did not advance but rather tumbled back to something just below mediocrity and near irrelevancy. Within a couple of years, Parcells was gone, then Sparano was fired, then general manager Jeff Ireland was replaced.

That’s what happens when you go 11-5 and then draft Pat White and Patrick Turner and John Jerry and Daniel Thomas. Yes, the Dolphins hit on some guys, too -- Vontae Davis and Mike Pouncey and Reshad Jones come to mind. But it wasn’t enough when free agency was providing gems such as Jake Grove, who played I think three minutes for the Dolphins.

Bottom line, the Dolphins of that day laid a great foundation in Year One and followed by building a straw hut to face a New England Patriots hurricane.


More at LINK: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/armando-salguero/article121244503.html

Your thoughts? :ponder:
 
We need linebackers and we need defensive ends. I feel we can survive with our secondary, especially once Jones returns next year. Defensively during this draft we need to focus on linebacker and D ends. I feel like Lippett and Howard could be a decent tandem. I just don't feel that bad about our secondary like I do about our linebackers.
 
Interior OL can usually be had fairly reasonably in FA - dudes with experience, getting fair contracts... it's the one area that, in my opinion, can always be successfully addressed in free agency without taking on poor splashy contracts...

We could use more help at safety in terms of depth and most obviously - LB - across the board. Get a DE, get 2-3 LB's, get a S and use FA to get more help on the interior OL (I foresee us replacing probably Albert or Pouncey or maybe both).
 
Looking at this team defensively I'm pretty optimistic that we can build a formidable group. I'd retain Branch, Rambo and Thomas. Then I'm pretty happy with the bookends in Branch and Wake. The secondary with Maxwell and Howard/Lippett is fine with me. Reshad and a combo of Rambo, IAQ and Thomas I think works, but I wouldn't be opposed to getting a true ball-hawking FS if it presents itself. That leaves us basically with depth and LB to solve outside the organization. You've got Kiko for one spot, Hull and Hewitt for depth. Need to get another high-end starter and SLB are usually not too expensive for a subpackage role. Plenty happy with our interior DL. A splash signing like Hightower would be nice, but regardless need to enter this draft looking at DE's first and foremost, as well as linebackers.

As for offense, just do your best to keep Stills. Address the guard position in FA. Keep Sims and Gray around and look to draft a TE.

The way I see it, retain the aforementioned guys. Use FA to address the guard position, SLB and maybe SCB competition. Outside of retaining our own and the guard position those aren't expensive demands. Then enter the draft and go defense heavy, mixing in a TE and an interior OL.
 
I was suprised they didnt draft a lb in two years.
 
I think the needs are:
LB x 2
Slot CB
DE
OG (possibly 2 depending on whether Albert is retained)
TE
FS
C (depending on whether Pouncey is retained)
 
1st rd: LB (obviously)
2nd rd: OL (the #1 driving force behind any success we have had this year has been blocking, build on it, don't take it for granted. See: Dallas)
3rd rd: LB or CB
Get an athletic TE in there somewhere late round
 
Miami started the year with Alonso, Jenkins, Misi. The rest were OK back-ups. By all accounts, Misi was above average strong side, Jenkins was average (above two years ago- hopes of returning to that form), and Alonso was great for the Bills and traded by the Eagles - an unknown. Some positions these office people have to hope will pan out (hope Tannehill doesn't get hurt, Hope these LB's are coached up, Hope a RB takes control) and that the coaches can coach them up. I'm not certain I would complain at whatever position is drafted in the first three rounds, cause Miami can use the help just about everywhere, really.

And for a change, I trust the coaches to be able to "coach them up".
 
Outside of the obvious need at LB, the problem our roster is the inconsistency in the trenches,. Albert, Pouncey, Bushrod, Earl Mitchell, Jordan Philips. Either due to injury or inability. Contrary to the propaganda, Pouncey is a great player but he just cannot be counted on to play 16 games. That presents multiple problems. You still have to pay him due to the contract restrictions and you also have to have a premier backup. Ideally, it would be a top RG who could also excel at center but then you have to shuffle the line. It would be hard to carry a quality backup center unless you can draft one low and develop him quickly.

There is a similar issue at LT but we already have Tunsil. If they cut Albert as some have wanted, that would leave holes at LG, C & RG. That's a tough pill to swallow when you have so many other needs to fill on the defense.

Mitchell and Phillips look like All Pro's at times and then disappear for long stretches. Phillips development is still a mystery going forward.

I believe you have to build the trenches. Plain and simple.

Find that guy who can play guard and center and then find an upgrade to Steen or Urbik. Bushrod needs to be upgraded if we really want to form a dominant line. He's just passed his prime.

I would look at DE in the first round if one is worthy just because of the value. Branch is a complimentary player and Wake won't last forever. If not I would look at BPA between LB, DT or OL and check them off the list as the draft progresses. Find a good deal in FA before the draft to help fill the voids.
 
One of the amazing things about these Miami Dolphins making such a strong and, yes, improbable push toward being in the playoffs this season is that on paper they pretty much seem to need a ton of help.

No disrespect to the front office but it failed miserably to put together a linebacker corps that is 10 star players deep.

(Yes, that is a joke).

Back of the roster players are there for a reason. And yet last week the Dolphins found themselves reaching deep into the roster to put some of those players on the field as starters. Consider, for example, the four linebackers who played in the victory against the Arizona Cardinals:

Spencer Paysinger.

Mike Hull.

Donald Butler.

Neville Hewitt.

A career special teams guy. A 2015 undrafted and undersized free agent making his first NFL start. A a guy who was waived by the San Diego Chargers and was a street free agent when the Dolphins signed him in late September. And another 2015 undrafted free agent.

Not exactly prized draft picks or free agents any of them.

So I tell you, it’s impressive the Dolphins are doing what they are doing amid injuries to starters, with plans at other positions not proceeding as expected, and sometimes even with less overall talent than the opposition.

And that brings me to this:

When this season, already something of a feel-good story, comes to a close, the Dolphins’ front office will be under the gun to not just hold serve but to find breakthrough so that eventually the Dolphins continue moving toward the high calling of winning an NFL title.

We’ve been here before.

In 2008, the first year under Bill Parcells as football czar and Tony Sparano as head coach, the Dolphins made the amazing climb from 1-15 to 11-5 and the AFC East title. After that season, Parcells told me he had no illusions about how talented that team was or was not.

He admitted that team had some serious holes.

And he said it was thus his personnel department’s assignment to stock up so that Miami could add to the work that had been done in 2008.

It didn’t happen.

The Dolphins instead made significant personnel mistakes and not only did not advance but rather tumbled back to something just below mediocrity and near irrelevancy. Within a couple of years, Parcells was gone, then Sparano was fired, then general manager Jeff Ireland was replaced.

That’s what happens when you go 11-5 and then draft Pat White and Patrick Turner and John Jerry and Daniel Thomas. Yes, the Dolphins hit on some guys, too -- Vontae Davis and Mike Pouncey and Reshad Jones come to mind. But it wasn’t enough when free agency was providing gems such as Jake Grove, who played I think three minutes for the Dolphins.

Bottom line, the Dolphins of that day laid a great foundation in Year One and followed by building a straw hut to face a New England Patriots hurricane.


More at LINK: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/armando-salguero/article121244503.html

Your thoughts? :ponder:

Nickle corner, LB, DE depth, O-Line Depth (G) Pretty manageable I'd say
 
Mitchell and Phillips look like All Pro's at times and then disappear for long stretches. Phillips development is still a mystery going forward.

DL dirty work rarely gets noticed. They're busy gathering up double blocks to free their teammates to the ball. Phillips gets doubled almost just as much as Suh does.
 
DL dirty work rarely gets noticed. They're busy gathering up double blocks to free their teammates to the ball. Phillips gets doubled almost just as much as Suh does.

Phillips is coming along nicely....makes some bonehead plays from time to time, but is a physical freak that is getting more consistent.
 
LB for sure. Cut Williams, re-sign Branch. Hope Howard comes back and is healthy. Any FA DEs worth a look?
 
Nickle corner, LB, DE depth, O-Line Depth (G) Pretty manageable I'd say

Add TE and starting OG (two would be great), not just O-line depth. Possibly FS, Center and another DT for more depth.

It's manageable if you have a front office that knows what their doing...not so much with this front office. I don't see too many teams with this many holes coming into the season drafting two, TWO special teams players in Drake and Grant and adding a WR when it wasn't necessary.
 
Back
Top Bottom