HERALD: Dolphins Raise Questions Rather than Provide Answers about Tannehill’s Knee | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

HERALD: Dolphins Raise Questions Rather than Provide Answers about Tannehill’s Knee

Perfect72

It's Only Happened ONCE!
Joined
May 18, 2004
Messages
1,448
Reaction score
665
Location
Florida
As press conferences go, the one the Miami Dolphins held Wednesday to culminate a successful season was not awful by the standard of Tony Sparano and Jeff Ireland once upon a time openly hating each other in front of the media or Laremy Tunsil canceling a press conference because he suddenly got an acute case of food poisoning and his head blew up like a balloon.

But awkward?

Yes, this one was awkward. And curious.

And possibly troubling if things don’t turn out just right for the Miami Dolphins.

The reason for all this is because in a setting meant to provide answers, the Dolphins effectively created a significant question during the time Adam Gase, Mike Tannenbaum and Chris Grier talked to reporters.

The question was a simple one: Does Ryan Tannehill need knee surgery this offseason?.

I figured the answer would be a simple and quick, “Nope.”

But that’s because I’m an out-of-the-loop outsider who finished a few credits short of my medical degree. The Dolphins, working with the latest information and having top doctors both inside and outside the organization examining Tannehill’s knee, couldn’t be quite so certain.

So they equivocated.

“We’re still going through that process right now with the trainers with what our next step is, where his health is, how strong is his knee,” Gase said. “We’re still going through that. We’re still collecting information. Doctors are still giving us what possibly could be down the road. So it’s hard for us to really pinpoint anything as of this moment right now.”

I heard this answer and tried to figure out if that meant yes, he needs surgery, or no, he doesn’t. And it was neither. So I pressed because the Dolphins didn’t put Tannehill on injured reserve after he suffered a partially torn ACL and MCL in his left knee in early December.

The doctors at that time gave Gase and others assurances surgery likely was not necessary. And that’s the reason Gase said this on December 12, when asked about the prospect of Tannehill needing surgery:

“Unless something changes, it doesn’t look like that’s what is going to be happening,” the coach said at the time.

On Wednesday the answer was nowhere near so clear.

“We still don’t have all the exacts,” Gase said. “We’re working through that right now. Until we’re told by our doctors and our medical staff, ‘This is where we’re at,’ specifically, he’s still going through a rehab stage right now and doing what he can do with the trainers.

“Our doctors are evaluating it. I’ve said it before. I don’t have the information to tell you guys what’s going on with where we exactly are at and what happens moving forward, so right now it’s on our medical staff to give us the information we need going forward.”

You’re darn tootin’ it’s on the medical staff. The medical staff seemed to have enough information a month ago to believe Tannehill didn’t, you know, need surgery and now that belief, poof, is lost in ambiguity?

Did something change? Did Tannehill suffer a setback in rehab? Did the doctors get it wrong?

All these unknowns suddenly popped up during the presser. And, of course, the moment the Dolphins’ hazy message was relayed via the dreaded Internet (can’t wait until that fad passes), fans and media outlets were freaking out.

Dolphins decline to say Tannehill doesn’t need surgery!

Tannehill may need surgery!

Aliens land on Tannehill’s knee!

More at LINK: http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/armando-salguero/article125946654.html
 
In retrospect he should've just got it day one, but I don't condemn Gase for holding out him playing late in the playoffs. Just get it done. Ryan would be back in time.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Wouldn't be the first time the doctors got it very wrong.....Brees, Culpepper ring the bell?

Ozzy rules!!
 
Do you think Gase and the Dolphins brass really want you to know what's going on? Of course they don't they want everything to be up in the air going into free agency and the draft. Information is the most important factor to both of those evaluations. I think if Tanny was going to need surgery we would of seen something Monday or Tuesday saying he was getting it done.
 
sigh. Clearly Tannehill is still recovering from the sprain. If there is a setback from that then he will need surgery. He is going through the process that is in place. In other words, there is no definite yes or no answer yet.

The media wants to make this a story since they didnt get a yes or no answer. Had Gase said no and later on he will need surgery, they will crucify him and Gase knows this.
 
sigh. Clearly Tannehill is still recovering from the sprain. If there is a setback from that then he will need surgery. He is going through the process that is in place. In other words, there is no definite yes or no answer yet.

The media wants to make this a story since they didnt get a yes or no answer. Had Gase said no and later on he will need surgery, they will crucify him and Gase knows this.

I hear you but I've been watching NFL football for a long time and typically it's sprained knee, out x amount or weeks, no surgery or torn ACL out for the season requires surgery. I've never seen in between before, it's curious IMHO.
 
I heard Dr David Chao discuss it the other day on Sirius NFL radio. He said that there was a possibility that the Dolphins medical staff are waiting for the MCL to heal itself then they could still decide to undertake the surgery on just the ACL, if needed. I think that Dr Chao is a former San Diego Chargers team doctor. He also said that he has great respect for the Miami Dolphins medical team and because the team is not communicating a lot of the details associated with the Tannehill injury, he was only speculating. However, he definitely raised the possibility that there could be a deliberate strategy to wait and let the MCL heal itself, if it can. It sounded like the ACL cannot heal itself.
 
I heard Dr David Chao discuss it the other day on Sirius NFL radio. He said that there was a possibility that the Dolphins medical staff are waiting for the MCL to heal itself then they could still decide to undertake the surgery on just the ACL, if needed. I think that Dr Chao is a former San Diego Chargers team doctor. He also said that he has great respect for the Miami Dolphins medical team and because the team is not communicating a lot of the details associated with the Tannehill injury, he was only speculating. However, he definitely raised the possibility that there could be a deliberate strategy to wait and let the MCL heal itself, if it can. It sounded like the ACL cannot heal itself.

Bingo.. been following him all along and he has always maintained surgery was on the table and have posted some of his stuff on here, including his comments today in the Gase/Tannenbaum/Grier thread.
 
Don't forget that Ryan Tannehill graduated with a Science degree (pre med) from Texas A & M and aspires to become a doctor and then an orthopedic surgeon post football career. He would not be your typical footballer in that he would probably be totally fascinated by the medical analysis and look at it as a learning opportunity. His visit to Dr James Andrews in Pensacola the other week didn't attract much attention but Dr Andrews is regarded as the best orthopedic surgeon in the country and he would probably perform the operation if required. Interesting that Tannehill visited him talked it all through and no surgery was taken, preferring to wait and see how it heals.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I hear you but I've been watching NFL football for a long time and typically it's sprained knee, out x amount or weeks, no surgery or torn ACL out for the season requires surgery. I've never seen in between before, it's curious IMHO.

You know what, since it's so black and white and you seem to have it down to a science; perhaps you should apply for team physician. I'm sure they would welcome that type of input.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Since it looked bad at the outset it was probably bad. Not complicated. I'm guessing surgery of some type.
 
The only good news from our early playoff exit is that there's no what-if in regards to delaying a potentially needed surgery, but that they still don't know bothers me. I had a torn UCL in my thumb last year which for three months my doctor and I discussed surgery but gave it a chance to heal on its own...which it did until I re-tore it doing nothing but reaching for something while driving and hitting it not that hard. I kid of wish they would just do a surgery and get it stronger for the future.
 
from NFL.com complete BS. Anyway I wonder if that vague answer is a hint of moving on from Tannehill? http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap30...ebrief-divisional-round-loaded-matchups-ahead

4) Ryan Tannehill's injury simply didn't impact Miami's season that much. Matt Moore ran coach Adam Gase's offense as well as Tannehill, winning the games he should and losing to the true AFC superpowers. Bigger factors in Miami falling short in Pittsburgh: the banged-up, erratic offensive line, and absent members of the secondary, like cornerback Byron Maxwell, safety Reshad Jones and safety Isa Abdul-Quddus.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You know what, since it's so black and white and you seem to have it down to a science; perhaps you should apply for team physician. I'm sure they would welcome that type of input.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Ok then. I'll be right as soon as they announce the required surgery.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top Bottom