Not an unreasonable position at all.Umm I think I will go ahead and deem him a top 3 QB in the league. I dont need anymore evidence than one of the top 3 seasons by an NFL QB ever.
Another year, even close to the previous, and I will join you.
Not an unreasonable position at all.Umm I think I will go ahead and deem him a top 3 QB in the league. I dont need anymore evidence than one of the top 3 seasons by an NFL QB ever.
Not a totally unrealistic scenario, particularly if Rosen plays well, but not spectacular.even if i had the 1st overall and needed a QB i would pass on any of the QB's in 2020. trade down and get a lot more picks, and then in 2021 get our QB Trevor Lawrence!!
we need to keep building the DL and OL and LB with the 2020 draft.
"Elite" and "greatness" are functions of time.
Wanting to give someone an elite label to prove a point doesn't make the point any more valid or the player any more talented.
If he is great, there should be no concern with waiting another year or two for him to prove it.
As for being Brady's in OT, I will quote a high school coach from my past...
"Don't blame the refs or a single play on losing the game. If you were that much better than your opponent the score should never have been close enough to matter."
The Chiefs had 4 quarters to effect the outcome and didn't. They lose because they lost. Ask the Saints if the one play prevented then from making the SB or if they should have won the game in the 4 quarters leading up to it .
Mahomes isn't "elite" yet. He's just played one season. Simple as that.
Does anyone get the point of the post? The point was to draw a comparison to previous QB's (who all turned out to be good QB's) drafted and playing on a terrible team their rookie years. If we're going to judge Rosen on his rookie year playing on a bad team, we're not looking at the full picture. Just because he didn't have an outstanding rookie year doesn't doom him to failure. Had he been drafted by one of the better teams and failed miserably, then there would be a valid point.He isn't wrong. It's a pointless endeavor to compare QBs before and after all of the rule changes that make it easier for a QB to succeed in today's NFL.
Kinda feels like this around here!Once more, I was responding to "play at an MVP level and lead us to a 10-6 record at worst"
And the Defenses now have a 1-year book of study. Not easy doing it year after year.While Mahomes impressed the hell out of me last season, 1 year does not an "elite" QB make.
The odds are surely in his favor, but lets give him another year, or two before we hang that moniker around his neck.
And the Defenses now have a 1-year book of study. Not easy doing it year after year.
even if i had the 1st overall and needed a QB i would pass on any of the QB's in 2020. trade down and get a lot more picks, and then in 2021 get our QB Trevor Lawrence!!
we need to keep building the DL and OL and LB with the 2020 draft.
Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. -Mark TainHaha just like NFL teams have film on Rosen. Gonna get harder for him..............Excuse the bad play of Rosen but down play 50 TDs by Mahomes.
Because he is. Look at the film of some of his games, and he was only a Freshman.Why do people think Lawrence is better than Tua? Is it because the only game they've watched of either was the Championship game?
Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. -Mark Tain
Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience. -Mark TainDeflect away.