If After week 8.... | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

If After week 8....

If after week 8...

  • I feel good about Beck He is our QB!

    Votes: 26 51.0%
  • Let another QB try this year but Beck is our future!

    Votes: 4 7.8%
  • Enough time spent on Beck, prepare to draft/aquire anotherQB!

    Votes: 15 29.4%
  • It was a mistake not drafting Ryan, we are set back again!

    Votes: 6 11.8%

  • Total voters
    51

dabeastdabone

Seasoned Veteran
Joined
Jul 29, 2004
Messages
2,343
Reaction score
2
Age
60
Location
Austin, Tx and Bali, Indo
If after week 8 Beck has:

(1) a QB rating below 55%
(2) 5 or fewer TD's
(3) 7 or more Int's
(4) Pulled from 2 games
(5) Dolphins are 2-6 or worse
(6) Dolphins are in the bottom 25% in the NFL in offense.
 
You started with the word "If" but failed to ask a question.
 
I guess if all the aforementioned are true we will have won more games then we did all of last year with a really young team. So I guess it could be stated that we are improving? I would take 2-6 over 0-8 anytime.
 
If after week 8 Beck has:

(1) a QB rating above 90
(2) 15 TD's or more
(3) Less than 7 Int's
(4) Started Every Game
(5) Dolphins are above .500
(6) Dolphins are in the top half of the NFL in offense.
 
i say give beck the entire season but i would like to draft aqb like flacco or henne i would love to have to many starting qb's
 
I wouldn't be so sure that Beck is going to be the starter.

McCown was promised an open QB competition and I don't think they would have lied to him about that (or else they would have a very hard time signing guys in years to come)

Also, Chris Simms is probably going to be cut by Tampa, and I think Tuna might not be able to keep himself from signing a QB named Simms.

Then we would have 3 QB's on the roser aged 28, 27, an d 26. So any of them could be our "QB of the future"
 
i say give beck the entire season but i would like to draft aqb like flacco or henne i would love to have to many starting qb's

I'm in agreement with Mel Kiper on this one (I agree with him way too much these days)

We either draft Ryan, or we don't draft a QB at all.

If we're unsure about Beck, then we have to draft Ryan. If we think Beck is our guy, then we have too many other needs to fill with those picks.

If Beck doesn't work out then you go back to the drawing board next year.
 
I don't deal in what ifs. I'd prefer to decide when it actually happens. I'm not going to pre-plan Beck's failure. Until then, he's our QB and I believe he has the tools to be successful.
 
I think some people on here are HOPING that Beck fails just so that they can say that THEY were right instead of just hoping that things work out with Beck so the team can win games....I'm with Beck cause he's our QB of OUR team so why can't just everyone root for the guy?

Ozzy rules!!
 
I think some people on here are HOPING that Beck fails just so that they can say that THEY were right instead of just hoping that things work out with Beck so the team can win games....I'm with Beck cause he's our QB of OUR team so why can't just everyone root for the guy?

Ozzy rules!!

You nailed it
 
I dont think Beck starts the season and if he does will be benched by week 2 in favor of the better veteran McCown
 
Back
Top Bottom