If RB, and Caddy switched teams.......

[Butterfrog 2.0]

Well I think both teams picked the right guy, but.......... If they were on opposite teams Brown would be the unquestioned R.O.Y right now. Brown in Tampa bay with a MUCH better O-line, and a coach that would CONSTANTLY feed him the ball, and Brown probably being able to stay healthy when Caddy didn't Brown would probably be leading the league in rushing right now. And Caddy would probably have less yards(and carries) than ronnie does right now. They are both good RB's but I think Ronnie is less in need of the right System to do well than Caddie. Thoughts???

 

[Dol-Fan Dupree]

I don't think the Tampa Bay line is much better

 

[Butterfrog 2.0]

I don't think the Tampa Bay line is much better

Are you serious??? Have you seen the holes they've opened up for their RB's???

 

[Dol-Fan Dupree]

Are you serious??? Have you seen the holes they've opened up for their RB's???

I have seen the amazing cut backs and great runs by their runningbacks.

 

[cnc66]

I think Caddy's injuries are partially bad managment. When he got dinged they still ran him a gagillion times. When Ronnie got dinged we were able to take it easy on him and he got a chance to recover. To switch not only the carries but the attitude would likely end with like results.

 

[Atila]

i agree with cnc, i think they made the wrong move by playing caddy SO heavily while he was a bit nicked up.

i also think that had RB been taken by tampa and stayed injury free, he'd have prob around 500-600yds running an a lot of catches too...i think tampa bay would of involved him a lot more in their passing game as well considering how talented he is catching the ball as well.

 

[FinsNCanes]

If you look at attempts, yards, YPC they are both just about even.


Why should Williams even be considered ROY is the question and not RB. . . ?

 

[DolphinDevil28]

Let's just be elated we have Ronnie Brown as the cornerstone of our offense for a long time and forget about Caddilac Williams, huh?

Move on people.

 

[Scrap]

Both teams picked the right guy.

 

[FrankP]

:sleep:

 

[Jimi]

Thats a lot of probablys and ifs.

 

[AjFazz85]

yea speaking of ifs... if my mother had balls she would be my father.

 

[bakedmatt]

tampa's offensive playbook and good execution are very responsible for the wide open holes. in that spread offense that gruden likes to run, the defense doesn't know whether to expect run or pass. it also doesn't hurt that they're executing over there.

 

[jlfin]

Are you serious??? Have you seen the holes they've opened up for their RB's???

No. Caddy has great vision and sometimes makes the holes seem bigger than they are.
The Phins pretty much shut down their running game (except for a 33 and 56 yd runs). Take those out of the equation and the Bucs looked like they were running into a wall ( I was at the game). They established nothing against our defense. If not for the ineptitude of Gus (missing one big play after the other) that game would have looked much different.

 

[Maynard the Hammer]

Let's just be elated we have Ronnie Brown as the cornerstone of our offense for a long time and forget about Caddilac Williams, huh?

Move on people.

too bad he isnt the cornerstone right now