I don't think so, but I want to see what others think. Many people on here dislike the signing so a poll is a good way to gauge average fan opinion on the matter. I do think the contract was too much unless it has injury clauses all throughout it.
I posted this in an earlier thread started by someone questioning why, if the FO was looking for a 'bigger' center did they signing a guy 5 years older and with an injury 'history' when he is barely heavier or taller than Satele. I think my response shows a good justification in the signing (big money and all) as well as why I think he marks an improvement over Satele (though I like Samson as a player, I do think he would be better suited as a backup in our system or starting in a zone blocking scheme elsewhere). So anyway, here's my response from before:
"I'm not positive about this but I think the FO is going on the old saying "plays bigger than the numbers/size indicates". Both Satele and Grove are identical in measurables (height, weight etc) but I think there are two factors in Groves favor they like: strong initial punch and physical strength. Grove may be equal in size to Satele, but the guy is strong as an ox (did bench reps of up to 490lbs I believe I read somewhere) and he probably gives a much greater surge up the middle than Satele (I'm no o-line expert and havn't examined the film as others have, but that's the general idea I'm gathering). Samson is an excellent athlete for Center, with potential to be a good pulling guard. However he does not have the same nasty demeanor, strength, or initial punch Grove has. Yes, I'll conceed I'm a bit concerned by Grove's list of injuries, but he's in his physical prime, has lots of untapped potential (bigtime prospect out of VT if I recall correctly), and he provides a more physical, nasty interior lineman than Satele. I like Samson a lot, but he does not fit well in the offensive scheme being run in Miami right now, and would benefit playing in a zone blocking scheme. When people talk about 'size' in their center, I believe it was CKParrothead that pointed out Samson is actually in the middle to higher end of centers in measureable size/weight. However, Samson does not PLAY as big as many other centers. I believe the FO wants someone built more like a bulldozer to pave the way of the interior offensive line. A lot of people are down on Grove because he played in Oakland and they notoriously had a bad line (which he was part of). However, I think put him on the same line as Long, Carey, Smiley, and Thomas and I think we'll see a far improved performance from him. Truly the only concern I have with him is the amount of money he received, but every FA period the money gets more and more inflated, whether the player 'deserves' it or not. Overall though I think this is a really solid signing."