Here is my view on the QBs in this draft:
JOE BURROW: 527 attempts, 76.3%C, 15.5 attempts per sack, 87.8 attempts per interception, 8.9 attempts per TD, 118 Reliability filter.
Takes too many sacks but does not have "elite" escapeability like Wilson or Jackson or frame and arm to take the pounding like Cam or Wentz or Allen. That's a risk.
Production reliability is over 100 which indicates wacky numbers, unreliable production. He is an elite decision maker and scorer, so he will likely be okay. Comp on numbers: Derek Carr, Marcus Mariota, Jimmy Garoppolo.
What makes him first round QB: winning grit, ability to scoot to offset some of the risks, and high scoring ability. Could potentially pan out to lead a team to playoffs and give a chance at SB on rookie contract. I'd pass.
TUA TAGOVAULOA: 252 attempts, 71.4%C, 25.2 attempts per sack, 84 attempts per interception, 7.6 attempts per TD, 198 Reliability filter.
Somewhat low attempts per game, not used to carrying the team, and wacky unreliable production. Elite decision maker and elite scorer. Comps: Case Kennum, Sam Bradford. Doubt that he will pan out on rookie contract. No use for this player on rookie contract.
JUSTIN HERBERT: 428 attempts, 66.8%C, 17.8 attempts per sack, 71.3 attempts per interception, 13.4 attempts per TD, 64 Reliability filter.
Borderline takes too many sacks, but has the frame and athleticism to take the pounding. Good scorer, and elite decision maker. Comp: Mitch Trubisky, Dak Prescott. He can give a team a decent chance on rookie contract.
JORDAN LOVE: 473 attempts, 62%C, 23.7 attempts per sack, 27.8 attempts per interception, 23.7 attempts per TD, 17 Reliability filter.
Poor completions, poor decision making, poor scoring, just a depressing quarterback. Not worth it. Will likely do nothing on rookie contract. There is no use for this player on rookie contract. Comp: Jameis Winston.
JACOB EASON: 405 attempts, 64%C, 19.3 attempts per sack, 50.6 attempts per interception, 17.6 attempts per TD, 35.6 Reliability filter.
Eason is an okay prospect, but he does not score enough, Late rounds prospect for a backup role. Comp: Blake Bortles, Davis Webb, Nick Foles. No use for this player on rookie contract.
JAKE FROMM: 385 attempts, 60.8%C, 25.7 attempts per sack, 77 attempts per interception, 16.0 attempts per TD, 75 Reliability filter.
Completions are low and scoring is low, but he is an elite decision maker. Late rounds as a backup. Essentially no use for this player as a starter on rookie contract. Comp: Nathan Peterman, Danny Ettling, Garrett Gilbert.
JALEN HURTS: 340 attempts, 69.7%C, 14.8 attempts per sack, 42.5 attempts per interception, 10.6 attempts per TD, 41 Reliability filter.
Sacks are high, decision making is a little low. Scoring is great. He is 6-1. Comps: Kevin Hogan, Johnny Manziel, Robert Griffin. I'd pass. No use for this player on rookie contract. It all depends on running usage, if he can supplement his passing game with running.
ANTHONY GORDON: 689 attempts, 71.6%C, 34.5 attempts per sack, 43 attempts per interception, 14.4 attempts per TD, 74 Reliability filter.
Clears the benchmarks across the board. Negatives are he is a one year starter, but he did squeeze in 689 attempts which is an equivalent of two seasons of passing, and he did well; and arm strength is not top notch. Comp: Deshaun Watson, Teddy Bridgewater, Worth a shot at starting job, he can give a team a decent chance.
Cole McDonald: 511 attempts, 63.8%C, 26.9 attempts per sack, 36.5 attempts per interception, 15.5 attempts per TD, 40 Reliability filter.
Decision making is borderline and scoring is a little high, but not terribly bad. High comp is Drew Lock, but he is not quite as good. More appropriate comps are Matt Stafford and Kirk Cousins. He is an excellent value in mid rounds.
QUARTERBACKS WORTH DRAFTING TO GIVE YOU A CHANCE AT PLAYOFFS AND POSSIBLY SB ON ROOKIE CONTRACT:
Herbert (which I would pass on because the value is not top 10)
Gordon, this is where the value is.
McDonald. this is where the value is.
