Madison vs. Surtain: Who's better? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Madison vs. Surtain: Who's better?

Who's the better CB?

  • Sam Madison

    Votes: 28 19.9%
  • Patrick Surtain

    Votes: 113 80.1%

  • Total voters
    141

finnyboy002

Dolphins Canadian Representative
Joined
Jan 7, 2005
Messages
153
Reaction score
0
Location
Brampton, On
I had this debate with a friend of mine just yesterday. He thinks Madison is the better CB, I argued for Surtain. My reasoning is that he is younger, and faster, and that from what I've seen, opposing teams have been taking shots (throwing towards) Madison and not even attempting to go to Surtains side. It's hard to debate 'cause I love 'em both, but I think Surtain is the better CB.
 

GreenMonster

Never con a con man
Joined
Apr 15, 2005
Messages
4,912
Reaction score
0
Age
42
Location
Atlanta
I voted Madison because early in Surtains career he took some of the pressure off of Pat by always covering the #1 WR. Note much seperates these 2 in the skills area..
 

dolfanattic5

you got chambered
Joined
Mar 28, 2005
Messages
933
Reaction score
307
Age
33
madison compared to both in their prime surtain is better now.
 

SCall13

Finheaven QB
Joined
May 25, 2003
Messages
13,541
Reaction score
223
Location
Charlotte, NC
At both of their peaks of performance, they were pretty equal. But right now, Surtain is better.
 

GreenMonster

Never con a con man
Joined
Apr 15, 2005
Messages
4,912
Reaction score
0
Age
42
Location
Atlanta
Nublar7 said:
Currently I have to go with Surtain.

I think most will agree to that... But for the whole career to now its really close in my opinion, I give the small edge to Sam.
 

R_t_Kraken

Super Duper Club
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
10,094
Reaction score
37
Location
South Cackalaka
For their entire career? Madison is better. Today, Surtain has the edge. But I believe Madison is still a great player nonetheless.
 

finnyboy002

Dolphins Canadian Representative
Joined
Jan 7, 2005
Messages
153
Reaction score
0
Location
Brampton, On
SCall13 said:
At both of their peaks of performance, they were pretty equal. But right now, Surtain is better.

I would say that Surtain is still in his prime, and hopefully Madison can find that extra gear for us in the next few years.
 

LarryFinFan

Left So Fla, never the Fins...
Joined
Mar 10, 2004
Messages
7,694
Reaction score
2
Location
NC
finnyboy002 said:
I had this debate with a friend of mine just yesterday. He thinks Madison is the better CB, I argued for Surtain. My reasoning is that he is younger, and faster, and that from what I've seen, opposing teams have been taking shots (throwing towards) Madison and not even attempting to go to Surtains side. It's hard to debate 'cause I love 'em both, but I think Surtain is the better CB.


In their primes (which Madison is probably just past his, whereas PS is in the mid portion of his) Surtain was and is the better CB...Madison is less physical and slightly below the level of a cover guy as Surtain. That being said, Madison had the better year last year, but Surtain will be better longer than Madison will be for us...
 

FireInTheNole

Renolegade
Joined
Feb 18, 2005
Messages
235
Reaction score
0
Age
45
clear.gif



Shampoo is better! I go on first and clean the hair! Conditioner is better! I leave the hair silky and smooth! Oh, really, fool? Really! :D
 
Top Bottom