McDaniel Fired | Page 53 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

McDaniel Fired

ForksPhin said:
Where this arguments falls apart is when considering the franchise in question. Do first-time head coaches sometimes become highly successful? Of course. Do first-time head coaches hired by incompetent leadership and ownership succeed? Much more unlikely. The Dolphins need a ready-made leader to come in and rebuild this franchise. They don’t need the latest hot-shot coordinator who has never run anything.

So, to extend your comparison, Tua flamed out. Never take a small, injury-prone, athletically- questionable, and injured Alabama QB again. Details matter.
Click to expand...
What makes you feel confident incompetent leadership and ownership can identify an already failed head coach somewhere else as being the right guy this time? Harbaugh, sure, that’s a no-brainer, but who else is out there that you are confident this organization will be right about that has already flamed out somewhere else?
 
EasyRider said:
This is the dumbest post in this thread. This needed to happen. He was never going to last beyond next year. He should’ve never been offered the job from the beginning.
Although I like Harbaugh he’s not the end all and be all. But good for finally dumping McD
Click to expand...
Learn the game. Tua was the issue. Dumbest thing I ever read.
 
rickd13 said:
What makes you feel confident incompetent leadership and ownership can identify an already failed head coach somewhere else as being the right guy this time? Harbaugh, sure, that’s a no-brainer, but who else is out there that you are confident this organization will be right about that has already flamed out somewhere else?
Click to expand...
It’s not about confidence. It’s about changing what they’ve already proven they cannot accomplish, that being identifying a first-time, never-been-a-head-coach at any level candidate. If you’re happy trying it again for what would be the 5th consecutive time, good for you. Let’s just hope they identify another coordinator who never really called plays, like Philbin, Gase, Flores, and McDaniel. It’ll work out perfectly.
 
ForksPhin said:
It’s not about confidence. It’s about changing what they’ve already proven they cannot accomplish, that being identifying a first-time, never-been-a-head-coach at any level candidate. If you’re happy trying it again for what would be the 5th consecutive time, good for you. Let’s just hope they identify another coordinator who never really called plays, like Philbin, Gase, Flores, and McDaniel. It’ll work out perfectly.
Click to expand...
I would rather take a chance on the unknown, than someone I know has already failed at least once. 11 of the 14 head coaches in the playoffs right now were first time head coaches with the team they are coaching currently.
 
rickd13 said:
I would rather take a chance on the unknown, than someone I know has already failed at least once. 11 of the 14 head coaches in the playoffs right now were first time head coaches with the team they are coaching currently.
Click to expand...
Everyone has their preferences. Neither of us can predict the future. I’ll take the approach that past results indicate future performance for now.
 
ForksPhin said:
A playoff win and two coach of the year awards with a bottom-3 NFL franchise in a vicious division.

That is how.
Click to expand...
He wasn't even allowed at the game for the playoff win it was van pelt and prier, and their opponent Tomlin has come out flat to the likes of Tebow, Bortles, and McCarron in the playoffs so that win wasn't much to write home about. (Yes I know tomlin beat our gase/concussed matt moore combo)

The next game Stefanski blew big time with ultra conservative play not to lose **** against a chad henne led KC in the 2nd half.
 
Cleo'sLemon said:
He wasn't even allowed at the game for the playoff win it was van pelt and prier, and their opponent Tomlin has come out flat to the likes of Tebow, Bortles, and McCarron in the playoffs so that win wasn't much to write home about. (Yes I know tomlin beat our gase/concussed matt moore combo)

The next game Stefanski blew big time with ultra conservative play not to lose **** against a chad henne led KC in the 2nd half.
Click to expand...
Pick away at any scab you’d like. I wonder how Jesse Minter’s last playoff win went. Oh wait…he doesn’t have one. Neither does Chris Shula or Jeff Hafley. Nor does Mike McDaniel, Brian Flores, Adam Gase, or Joe Philbin.

I’ll say again, everyone is entitled to their opinion. I want a coach with head coaching experience.
 
royalshank said:
Old news now but felt the need to say, kudos to Mr Ross for cleaning out the GM and idiot HC at the same time.
Click to expand...
I'm still amazed Ross made both moves this season...and both were the right move! I have the bigotry of low expectations when it comes with him making the right choices for this franchise. Glad to see something positive come from the Ross regime...finally. If we can somehow lose Tua this offseason, it will be stellar.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom