Merged:Carey or Crowder? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Merged:Carey or Crowder?

Carey or Crowder?

  • Vernon Carey

    Votes: 93 59.6%

  • Channing Crowder

    Votes: 63 40.4%
  • Total voters
    156
FinFanatic80

FinFanatic80

"In the tuna we trust."
Joined
Mar 6, 2008
Messages
686
Reaction score
1
If you could re-sign 1 and only one of them, who would you take?

Just wanted to get a feel for which way a lot of other fin fans would lean on this topic. Thanks.
 
If you could only resign one of them, it has to be Vernon Carey, but I'm not sure you resign either. Channing Crowder doesn't make big plays and Carey hasn't lived up to the billing. I think both are replaceable, Crowder especially.
 
If you stuck a gun in my face and told me to chose I would say Crowder. Carey has been solid and think he a must resign. But I dont think there are many available Mike linebackers that are as consistent as he is in our system.
 
I sure hope you're wrong Hargitt because Channing Crowder has been far from consistent for us.
 
Very tough but I would say Crowder because of the unity of this defense with Crowder there along with the potential replacement to Carey being in free agency (the staff here happens to love and be familiar with Jordan Gross). Top three priorities now should be Bell, Goodman, and Crowder. I love Carey, especially cause he's a Miami guy, but he truly has regressed this season. Plus, Crowder is only 25 and still learning this whole 3-4 thing.
 
I believe it will be Crowder...he stops the run and would be much cheaper. Carey is a fine OL and can play many spots, but his price for average is still VERY high. Bell and Crowder is probably where we'll go.
 
Honestly? After what I saw against Baltimore I'd let both walk. The defense as a whole didn't play poorly, but Crowder just throws his head the RBs when he tries to tackle, and Carey was probably the worst linemen we had this year.
 
Neither. They're going to ask for huge raises they don't deserve.

If I was forced to choose I'd say Crowder.
 
I'd say Crowder. Jordan Gross can replace Carey.
 
I'd say it's a toss up. I'd say Carey if I had to pick, just because that leaves a more glaring hole going into the draft that will HAVE to be addressed.

Yeremiah Bell is priority #1 though!
 
i say you pay carey the money and move him to rg and get a rt through free agency
 
Huscroft6 said:
This poll shouldnt even be CLOSE
Click to expand...
Why not? They're both equally average and both have equal potential to get better (or stay mediocre).

Signing either of them to anything but a very reasonable contract is really not something we should be looking at. Bell comes first. Hell, I'd look at Goodman before focusing on these two.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom