Merged: Why is Feeley chopped liver??

[kpcane]

Why is Feeley chopped liver??

Maybe I saw something different than everybody else, but I thought that AJ was not the worst QB in the world last year. It was his first year in a new system, a huge QB controversy, and a line that couldn't block a powder puff team. I thought he had a great arm, but he just turned the ball over too much. If Frerotte isn't finding the right guys, and he's turning the ball over, why not give AJ a chance? If we do need to go out and get a new QB in the draft, why don't we at least give AJ a LEGITIMATE chance to prove himself? Frerotte is really annoying me right now, and I just want to know why AJ is not being talked about at all, and why everybody is so down on him. Yes it was a terrible trade for us, but get over it, he could have some serious value for our team if given a chance.

 

[kastofsna120]

saban wasn't here last year and and he can only go by what he's seen, and clearly he's seen that frerotte is the better QB of the two

 

[CalDolFan10x14]

Cause he stinks....like onions. Get it liver....onions.......nevermind. :goof:

 

[NaboCane]

AJ had seven freakin' months to win the job, and didn't. That's the name of that tune.

edit: Eight. EIGHT freakin' months.

 

[Canadianfishfan]

I think in the preseason it was his job to lose.... With the $$$ they're paying him I can see dumping him.

 

[kpcane]

saban wasn't here last year and and he can only go by what he's seen, and clearly he's seen that frerotte is the better QB of the two

Frerotte is not a better QB than Feeley. I don't care if God Saban said he is, the only reason he starts is because he knows the offense the best. Feeley has a much better arm, but he can't work on his decision making while he's 3rd string. It's moves like these that make me question the legitimacy of the new coaching regime.

 

[kastofsna120]

Frerotte is not a better QB than Feeley. I don't care if God Saban said he is, the only reason he starts is because he knows the offense the best. Feeley has a much better arm, but he can't work on his decision making while he's 3rd string. It's moves like these that make me question the legitimacy of the new coaching regime.

whatever it is, frerotte has been better than feeley since saban has been here

 

[kpcane]

I think in the preseason it was his job to lose.... With the $$$ they're paying him I can see dumping him.

Totally not the case.

Here are the preseason numbers:

Feeley
34/54 280 yards 1TD 1 INT
5.19 yards per attempt
63% completion

Frerotte
33/74 384 yards 1TD 1INT
5.19 yards per attempt
45% completion

 

[kpcane]

whatever it is, frerotte has been better than feeley since saban has been here

See above post, and let me know who you think has been better, and who was given more of a chance in this system.

 

[Disgustipate]

Frerotte is not a better QB than Feeley. I don't care if God Saban said he is, the only reason he starts is because he knows the offense the best. Feeley has a much better arm, but he can't work on his decision making while he's 3rd string. It's moves like these that make me question the legitimacy of the new coaching regime.

Look... Did you pay attention at all during preseason? Feeley consistantly made bad decisions, and showed a regression from last season. You cannot honestly say you think Feeley showed more then either Frerotte or Rosenfels.

 

[kpcane]

Look... Did you pay attention at all during preseason? Feeley consistantly made bad decisions, and showed a regression from last season. You cannot honestly say you think Feeley showed more then either Frerotte or Rosenfels.

Look at the stats my man. I honestly think Feeley is better than Frerotte.

 

[Disgustipate]

Totally not the case.

Here are the preseason numbers:

Feeley
34/54 280 yards 1TD 1 INT
5.19 yards per attempt
63% completion

Frerotte
33/74 384 yards 1TD 1INT
5.19 yards per attempt
45% completion

You're setting aside the fact that in preseason, Frerotte actually opened it up and threw deep, while Feeley pretty much just dink and dunked.

 

[kastofsna120]

Totally not the case.

Here are the preseason numbers:

Feeley
34/54 280 yards 1TD 1 INT
5.19 yards per attempt
63% completion

Frerotte
33/74 384 yards 1TD 1INT
5.19 yards per attempt
45% completion

did you see feeley's last 2 games? that atlanta game was atrocious

 

[Disgustipate]

Look at the stats my man. I honestly think Feeley is better than Frerotte.

You've got serious, serious issues that I'm in no way qualified to help you with. [Insert Diety Here] help you soul, man.

 

[Canadianfishfan]

Totally not the case.

Here are the preseason numbers:

Feeley
34/54 280 yards 1TD 1 INT
5.19 yards per attempt
63% completion

Frerotte
33/74 384 yards 1TD 1INT
5.19 yards per attempt
45% completion

I dont think it was a decision of stats...Otherwise Sage would be starting. It had to do with the "intagables" Poise.. pocket presence..Leadership...
It was all stated by the coach.