My Can't Miss Draft Philosophy | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

My Can't Miss Draft Philosophy

JTech194

Starter
Joined
Jun 14, 2004
Messages
2,132
Reaction score
174
Location
Miami Florida
A lot of teams Miss on their early round pick IMO because they put too much emphasis on physical ability and not enough on the type of PERSON they're drafting.

In the early rounds... There is minimal difference in the physical ability between one player and another. Eli Apple is not that much more physically Gifted than Vernon Hargraves etc.. What REALLY separates the studs from the duds is.... THE TYPE OF PERSON THEY ARE! Teams should spend as much time and resources finding out WHO the player is as opposed to what they did on the field and in workouts. Why do i feel this way??

Because it takes a SPECIAL type of person to get paid early round draft pick money, and STILL have the work ethic and determination to be GREAT! When you're broke... you have no choice but to put in the work, you don't have as many options. When you're Rich however.... you have PLENTY OF THINGS you could be doing other than studying your playbook, working out, breaking down film (partying, smoking week, banging chics etc..)

If I were GM I would spend more time researching WHO THE PLAYER IS as opposed to what he can do physically

I'd try my best to find out, what does the player like to do for fun, what do his friends like to do? how are his parents and how did they raise him. When he was young.. what types of things did he talk about doing once he made it? What neighborhood did he grow up in, what type of music does he like (you can tell a lot about a persons maturity level based off the music they listen to)

I'd talk to his friends, family, pee wee highschool and college coaches, people that knew him in school, people that didn't know him in school but went to the same schools he attended,

Picks like DION JORDAN should NEVER HAPPEN!

I'd take a guy that might not be as athletic as the next guy, but has the mental makeup I'm looking for before i go for the athletic freak that does not have the mental makeup I'm looking for.

Take a guy like Justice Winslow for the Miami Heat. A lot of teams passed on him because of his lack of shooting ability and athleticism. BUT what they failed to properly evaluate and measure is his Maturity, attitude, personality and work ethic and what affect those traits would have on his ability to play in the league.
 
They do this already

Not thoroughly enough. IF they did... Guys like Jamarcus Russell and Dion Jordan wouldn't happen.

---------- Post added at 03:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:21 PM ----------

Also... A lot of teams put more value in athletic ability and what the player does on the field than all of the other stuff. And i think they got it backwards. Some of the greatest athletes were not always the most athletic or biggest etc.... it's the mental makeup, work ethic, and type of person they were that made them great.
 
Teams fall in love with the workout warrior. The guys who look the part, and fail to identify if they are just gifted athletes who can get away with athletics only or guys who know how to actually play the sport and understand the game. I feel like the majority of the guys at the top of the draft fall into the "athlete" category and that's why there are so many busts in the draft.
 
If we draft Eli Apple it would be like drafting Dion Jordan at the CB position, all hype but no production.
 
Not thoroughly enough. IF they did... Guys like Jamarcus Russell and Dion Jordan wouldn't happen.

---------- Post added at 03:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:21 PM ----------

Also... A lot of teams put more value in athletic ability and what the player does on the field than all of the other stuff. And i think they got it backwards. Some of the greatest athletes were not always the most athletic or biggest etc.... it's the mental makeup, work ethic, and type of person they were that made them great.

Teams will always miss on guys. You make it seem like everyone who interviews will turn out to be fantastic employees. It's not that easy.
 
All I can say is...Tim Tebow...


Who they are...doesn't always mean they can play the game...
 
I think your leaving out a huge component here in coaching. A guy like Tyrann Mathieu who had terrible character concerns when coming out is now thriving under excellent coaching.

Point being, there are multiple things you need to look at when ranking and selecting players. You cant just choose one trait as the tell-all, as you are proposing.
 
Not thoroughly enough. IF they did... Guys like Jamarcus Russell and Dion Jordan wouldn't happen.

---------- Post added at 03:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:21 PM ----------

Also... A lot of teams put more value in athletic ability and what the player does on the field than all of the other stuff. And i think they got it backwards. Some of the greatest athletes were not always the most athletic or biggest etc.... it's the mental makeup, work ethic, and type of person they were that made them great.

Raw talent is very enticing. Teams for the most part have personnel that do thorough background checks.... They know they just hope they can get through to the player
 
All I can say is...Tim Tebow...


Who they are...doesn't always mean they can play the game...

Tim Tebow is an extreme example to use here. He couldn't play QB. He was a glorified RB that threw the ball occasionally. IF Tebow was a TE or FB he would have found success in the league. There were teams willing to let him try TE but he was deadset on playing QB...
 
Teams will always miss on guys. You make it seem like everyone who interviews will turn out to be fantastic employees. It's not that easy.

Team miss because they Value athletic ability more than they value the makeup of the person. Example, Zach Thomas was a 5th round pick correct?? Why? Because he didn't have the size or speed teams look for. What they didn't realize is that his work ethic and smarts would make up for the lack of size an speed. If you know where the play is going... you don't have to be that fast to get there.
 
And when I say makeup of the person.... I'm not talking about drafting choir boys. It takes a special kind of man to play this sport at a high level. Players have to have that dog in them.
 
I think your leaving out a huge component here in coaching. A guy like Tyrann Mathieu who had terrible character concerns when coming out is now thriving under excellent coaching.

Point being, there are multiple things you need to look at when ranking and selecting players. You cant just choose one trait as the tell-all, as you are proposing.

You got it wrong brother. Mathieu might have had some off the field issues but that's not what I'm referring to when I say teams show investigate the type of person they are drafting.

We're drafting FOOTBALL PLAYERS not Pastors or Priests. I wan't my players with some aggressiveness and attitude and I'd be willing to overlook certain off the field issues.

The character traits I'm referring to are things like... what motivates him? What drives him to play this game? Is it money, fame, the means to get women, etc... or is it the need to be the best at what he does, the need to knock the snot out people etc... Does he have the attitude that no one is bringing him down ala Jarvis Landry, Knowshon Morene (when he was healthy) etc...
 
It's so much easier to be right with hindsight than foresight....

Every team misses on a good percentage of their picks and trades. What separates the winning from average teams is just one or two more picks or trades working out over the NFL average.
 
Back
Top Bottom