Mythbusters: Dolphins Narrative Edition | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Mythbusters: Dolphins Narrative Edition

Penthos

Am I on speaker phone?
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Messages
5,085
Reaction score
1,252
Location
Orlando
Myth: McDaniel's teams are undisciplined
Busted: Over the last four games, Miami has averaged fewer than four penalties per game, including only ONE against the Rams, just TWO against the Cardinals, and FOUR against the Raiders.

Myth: Tua is a one-read QB who crumbles under pressure and can't extend plays or make throws off schedule
Busted: Since his return from injury, Tua has REPEADETLY made big time, drive extending plays in clutch moments by avoiding pressure, getting outside the pocket, and hitting 3rd read receivers on the run

Myth: The NFL has figured out McDaniel's offense
Busted: Over the four games since Tua's return, Miami has averaged more than 27 points of offense per game. McDaniel has shown game planning flexibility by adapting to the types of defenses other teams play against Miami to mitigate Waddle and Hill.

Myth: The players don't respect McDaniel
Busted: If the team didn't respect the him, he would have lost the locker room. Given the last for games, this is clearly not the case: Miami lost to Buffalo and the Cardinals by a combined 4 points, then went to LA and beat the favored Rams followed by a two-score victory at home against the Raiders.

Myth: Grier is a terrible GM
Busted: While Grier is far from perfect, the moves of replacing Connor Williams (who retired from Seattle mid-season) with Aaron Brewer, not resigning Christian Wilkinson (who was lost for the season 4 weeks ago) while picking up Calias Campbell, and adding Jonnu Smith in the offseason, have all been net positives. Drafting Achane last year, then Malik Washington and Jaylen Wright this year, looks to pay dividends for years to come. Again, not saying Grier is a great GM, but looking at the amount of talent Miami has, he is objectively not terrible, especially compared to the GMs Miami has had over the last couple decades: Dennis Hickey, Jeff Ireland, and Randy Mueller.
 
I was with you until the Grier part.

I’ll say this - the Cards game was the 2nd time I saw Tua play in person. Last year was at the Meadowlands vs the Jets and it was a weir game and we were far from the field. Vs the Cards we were up close and I posted that anyone who doesn’t think he goes through his progressions is flat out wrong because I could see it plain as day up close.
Agree, myth busted.

McDaniel has kept the locker room - I didn’t expect that. I also am not ready to say he’s figured out the discipline thing just yet. Gonna take more than four games but the trend is very good to see.
 
Myth: McDaniel's teams are undisciplined
Busted: Over the last four games, Miami has averaged fewer than four penalties per game, including only ONE against the Rams, just TWO against the Cardinals, and FOUR against the Raiders.

Myth: Tua is a one-read QB who crumbles under pressure and can't extend plays or make throws off schedule
Busted: Since his return from injury, Tua has REPEADETLY made big time, drive extending plays in clutch moments by avoiding pressure, getting outside the pocket, and hitting 3rd read receivers on the run

Myth: The NFL has figured out McDaniel's offense
Busted: Over the four games since Tua's return, Miami has averaged more than 27 points of offense per game. McDaniel has shown game planning flexibility by adapting to the types of defenses other teams play against Miami to mitigate Waddle and Hill.

Myth: The players don't respect McDaniel
Busted: If the team didn't respect the him, he would have lost the locker room. Given the last for games, this is clearly not the case: Miami lost to Buffalo and the Cardinals by a combined 4 points, then went to LA and beat the favored Rams followed by a two-score victory at home against the Raiders.

Myth: Grier is a terrible GM
Busted: While Grier is far from perfect, the moves of replacing Connor Williams (who retired from Seattle mid-season) with Aaron Brewer, not resigning Christian Wilkinson (who was lost for the season 4 weeks ago) while picking up Calias Campbell, and adding Jonnu Smith in the offseason, have all been net positives. Drafting Achane last year, then Malik Washington and Jaylen Wright this year, looks to pay dividends for years to come. Again, not saying Grier is a great GM, but looking at the amount of talent Miami has, he is objectively not terrible, especially compared to the GMs Miami has had over the last couple decades: Dennis Hickey, Jeff Ireland, and Randy Mueller.
I disagree regarding Grier ..if we fail to make the playoffs the inability and then failure to get a competent backup QB to Tua has to be one of the biggest mistakes of the season.
No matter how many hits he got, failing to address that backup QB has been a major mistake.
You didn't need a superstar just someone better than Skylar, snoop or god forgive Boyle..
Especially with Tua's injury history.
 
Myth: McDaniel's teams are undisciplined
Busted: Over the last four games, Miami has averaged fewer than four penalties per game, including only ONE against the Rams, just TWO against the Cardinals, and FOUR against the Raiders.

Myth: Tua is a one-read QB who crumbles under pressure and can't extend plays or make throws off schedule
Busted: Since his return from injury, Tua has REPEADETLY made big time, drive extending plays in clutch moments by avoiding pressure, getting outside the pocket, and hitting 3rd read receivers on the run

Myth: The NFL has figured out McDaniel's offense
Busted: Over the four games since Tua's return, Miami has averaged more than 27 points of offense per game. McDaniel has shown game planning flexibility by adapting to the types of defenses other teams play against Miami to mitigate Waddle and Hill.

Myth: The players don't respect McDaniel
Busted: If the team didn't respect the him, he would have lost the locker room. Given the last for games, this is clearly not the case: Miami lost to Buffalo and the Cardinals by a combined 4 points, then went to LA and beat the favored Rams followed by a two-score victory at home against the Raiders.

Myth: Grier is a terrible GM
Busted: While Grier is far from perfect, the moves of replacing Connor Williams (who retired from Seattle mid-season) with Aaron Brewer, not resigning Christian Wilkinson (who was lost for the season 4 weeks ago) while picking up Calias Campbell, and adding Jonnu Smith in the offseason, have all been net positives. Drafting Achane last year, then Malik Washington and Jaylen Wright this year, looks to pay dividends for years to come. Again, not saying Grier is a great GM, but looking at the amount of talent Miami has, he is objectively not terrible, especially compared to the GMs Miami has had over the last couple decades: Dennis Hickey, Jeff Ireland, and Randy Mueller.
Who have they beat? Any winning teams? Which ones?
 
Ok, in all fairness, Skyler was injured at the beginning of the 3rd qtr of his first start (game 3). Given the complexity of Miami’s offense, that’s hardly enough time to know how he would have performed in subsequent games.

Miami lost a starting QBs in 3 out of their first 6 games. No GM can prepare for that.
 
Back
Top Bottom